Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 39 - Page 74

I am so very glad that you too have little faith in Vikku boy

I have not understood why he would marry Y jist to piss off Mannat when he think she has moved on and then proceeds to giver catering too???

Originally posted by: Moor278

I am so very glad that you too have little faith in Vikku boy

I have not understood why he would marry Y jist to piss off Mannat when he think she has moved on and then proceeds to giver catering too???

Delulu is the only solulu

That being said do you think vik has some other reason to say yes to yashika.. rather than his overconfident self actually trying to move on and parallely showing it off to mannat..?

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Yes, Scarlett you are right Mannat's main issue is pregnancy and divorce... I don't think she bothers much about other things.. nor does anyone on indore side, all their main issue is that vik went to extent of divorcing mannat and rejecting preganancy, that made them loose hope on him..

That's why when mannat will get to know that vik didn't do any of it she will soften towards vik, not enough to forgive him but enough to be on amicable terms with him and forgive him after vik asks for forgives and redeems for other things too... But the minute she will know vik didn't reject the pregnancy and didn't divorce her she will almost completely heal... Because even during pre leap she understood vik's trauma, even after everything she was senting message to vik saying in such trauma and anger we both said things that we didn't mean and done mistakes but it can be sorted out if we talk but we can't give upon each other...

Until then she understood that vik might said things in anger but he didn't mean anything, so even though it cant be let go just because it happened in anger, there is atleast room enough for redemption and forgiveness,so she was still hoping for their patchup.. But when she got to know he divorced her she felt maybe he didn't say those things in anger but actually meant it... that's what caused her immense trauma, but once she gets to know vik didn't send the divorce papers she will understand that vik didn't mean anything he said and even in anger or trauma vik didn't reject her pregnancy or completely broke ties... Even after this i don't want mannat to immediately forgive him because even though he said things in anger and didn't mean them, it's not okay for him to do that even in trauma .. so even after knowing pregnancy or divorce misunderstanding, vik should apologize and redeem and mannat if she wants to forgive should only do it after this apologies and redemption of vik..

But I guess the revelation that pregnancy and divorce things are a misunderstanding will heal both indore side and vikrant... Indore side lost complete hopes on vik when they thought that vik went to the extent of divorcing mannat on her mothers funeral and didn't even accept the baby.. until then they too understand what ever happened is because of trauma and anger ,mistakes of both sides, some less some more....but everything was still amendable..... they were hoping things will sort out and it would have if that misunderstanding didn't happen... but sadly that misunderstanding happened and wouldn't blame indore side much because they were in trauma too and were on edge of hope and that thing pushed them off the edge, so it was understandable...

But once they know it was just a misunderstanding then they will heal,and same way vik too after knowing about this misunderstanding will heal because all this while he felt they will not forgive him for his mistakes and don't want him in their life after what happened..that's why left town, but once he knows it's not because of his mistakes before but because of the misunderstandings later that they left, he will understand that their is still room for reunion because they were ready to give another chance for things to sort out between them even after everything it was misunderstanding which made them loose hope, so now that misunderstanding is cleared their is chance for them to sort things out .. this will heal vikrant.. And indore side too..

Thats why I hope this preganancy and misunderstanding thing gets cleared on atleast one side, then there wont be so much hostility and negativity.. Then it will be balance between positivity and drama... Currently with both sides trauma and extreme perceptions of each other there is just negativity all around.. Saw a interview of writer u shared yesterday.. and she is right people already have problems in their life they don't want negativity,they sure thrive on drama.. but even in drama they search for positivity, there should be balance .... and when ever they give overdose of negativity the trp falls despite the drama, example is wedding drama and the previous one month episodes... Until manvik faceoff the trp were good because there was balance of story and emotions, positivity-drama.. But after manvik faceoff it's all gloom, fighting, hostility.. Even now I don't see much change, same hostility is being continued on all sides... I hope makers tone it down a little bit...

Haven’t had much time to join in the forum discussions…….but your post made me think Chaotic, when leap happened we all suggested that once Mannat comes to find out that Vik didn’t know about the pregnancy and hadn’t sent the divorce papers/rejected the baby, Mannat will realise he was manipulated as was she……and she would soften towards Vik. Let’s assume, as always Mannat finds out but Vik still unaware.

However given the confrontations between Vikrant and Mannat (and co) post leap I’m now unsure whether Mannat will soften….as it is Mannat and DK know full well that Vik thinks Dua is DK’s daughter, and they have continued with that appearance in front of him. So will knowing bold make much difference to Mannat (and DK)? I feel they will continue with the MU. But if that’s case, when Vik finds out the truth and that Mannat already knew, rather than healing them both it will cause more animosity and divide. I really hope it isn’t this latter scenario, and before this Vik finds out M/DK aren’t married and raises questions about Dua’s paternity…..

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Haven’t had much time to join in the forum discussions…….but your post made me think Chaotic, when leap happened we all suggested that once Mannat comes to find out that Vik didn’t know about the pregnancy and hadn’t sent the divorce papers/rejected the baby, Mannat will realise he was manipulated as was she……and she would soften towards Vik. Let’s assume, as always Mannat finds out but Vik still unaware.

However given the confrontations between Vikrant and Mannat (and co) post leap I’m now unsure whether Mannat will soften….as it is Mannat and DK know full well that Vik thinks Dua is DK’s daughter, and they have continued with that appearance in front of him. So will knowing bold make much difference to Mannat (and DK)? I feel they will continue with the MU. But if that’s case, when Vik finds out the truth and that Mannat already knew, rather than healing them both it will cause more animosity and divide. I really hope it isn’t this latter scenario, and before this Vik finds out M/DK aren’t married and raises questions about Dua’s paternity…..

Shazia

But as per Mannat and DK he rejected his own baby right?

For Indore gang Vikrant rejected his own baby and send divorce papers so Mannat will not come to claim stake on property giving excuse of Baby. That much they are clear because Malla only manipulated the situation by saying same thing.

Post leap Vikrant thinks Mannat moved on with DK and Dua is their daughter because he is oblivious to pregnancy as well as divorce papers.

At least Mannat is sure that Vikrant doesn't think that baby is DK's. For all of them he rejected his own kid because he was angry at all of them for what happened.

TBH I am confused with this MU🤪 as well as Mannat's fear. If she fears that he will take Dua away because he is her father but if he rejected then now why will he come to claim her?🤔

Originally posted by: truptishree

Shazia

But as per Mannat and DK he rejected his own baby right?

For Indore gang Vikrant rejected his own baby and send divorce papers so Mannat will not come to claim stake on property giving excuse of Baby. That much they are clear because Malla only manipulated the situation by saying same thing.

Post leap Vikrant thinks Mannat moved on with DK and Dua is their daughter because he is oblivious to pregnancy as well as divorce papers.

At least Mannat is sure that Vikrant doesn't think that baby is DK's. For all of them he rejected his own kid because he was angry at all of them for what happened.

TBH I am confused with this MU🤪 as well as Mannat's fear. If she fears that he will take Dua away because he is her father but if he rejected then now why will he come to claim her?🤔

You and me too Trupti, I’m confused on what they think Vik thought pre leap and thinks now on who Duas father is.

But my post was more about Mannat getting to know Vik knew nothing about the pregnancy or divorce papers and they were both manipulated ….would it ‘soften’ Mannat and would she do anything differently??

(Does raise other qs of how & why is Vik is accepting Y’s proposal if he thinks he’s still married, or will his asking Mannat for a divorce be next track 🥺).

Originally posted by: truptishree

Shazia

But as per Mannat and DK he rejected his own baby right?

For Indore gang Vikrant rejected his own baby and send divorce papers so Mannat will not come to claim stake on property giving excuse of Baby. That much they are clear because Malla only manipulated the situation by saying same thing.

Post leap Vikrant thinks Mannat moved on with DK and Dua is their daughter because he is oblivious to pregnancy as well as divorce papers.

At least Mannat is sure that Vikrant doesn't think that baby is DK's. For all of them he rejected his own kid because he was angry at all of them for what happened.

TBH I am confused with this MU🤪 as well as Mannat's fear. If she fears that he will take Dua away because he is her father but if he rejected then now why will he come to claim her?🤔

Bold: Does this fear still exist after the promo we saw of Mannu bhai making a decision to go back to SM to cater for the wedding?I'd like to hear her explain to Ronnie why they are entering the lion's den.

Who knew just seeing Aish would cure Mannat of all her fears. She got an adrenaline rush and is already ready for battle.

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Haven’t had much time to join in the forum discussions…….but your post made me think Chaotic, when leap happened we all suggested that once Mannat comes to find out that Vik didn’t know about the pregnancy and hadn’t sent the divorce papers/rejected the baby, Mannat will realise he was manipulated as was she……and she would soften towards Vik. Let’s assume, as always Mannat finds out but Vik still unaware.

However given the confrontations between Vikrant and Mannat (and co) post leap I’m now unsure whether Mannat will soften….as it is Mannat and DK know full well that Vik thinks Dua is DK’s daughter, and they have continued with that appearance in front of him. So will knowing bold make much difference to Mannat (and DK)? I feel they will continue with the MU. But if that’s case, when Vik finds out the truth and that Mannat already knew, rather than healing them both it will cause more animosity and divide. I really hope it isn’t this latter scenario, and before this Vik finds out M/DK aren’t married and raises questions about Dua’s paternity…..

Yes Shazia you are right.. I don't think mannat will tell about dua even after knowing about the misunderstanding, she will act from a mother's perspective and feel the truth might hurt dua and not tell anyone the truth,today's episode reiterated that fact.. But when I meant she will soften I didnt mean she will want to be back with vik, or want to forgive him but just soften enough to be amicable in conversations away from current state of hostility...

This I say so because if you see most of indore side's issue with vik is preganancy and divorce thing, that made them loose hope on vik, they might be angry on vik for other things too but they might think those are redeemable, that's why even after everything they went to dhairya's house and were hoping things will sort out, if vik apologized and rectified then they would have given vik another chance... But the pregnancy and divorce misunderstandings turned the scenario, where they lost all hopes.. So knowing pregnancy and divorce misunderstanding they will soften enough to feel things are amendable once vik redeems..

And I too hope the second scenario where vik finds out first and I have a bit hope on that because even after seeing seemingly obvious situation of a child between dhairya-mannat and her calling them mumma, baba.....vik questioned to himself are they really a family, ..Even mannat at spot beloved yash-vik-yuvi are family because it was default conclusion anyone draws.. but vik despite seeing similar scenario still was questioning are they a family.. .because he knows in his heart mannat cannot move on with his brother,we might say vik is not using his brain and i agree too but more than brain he is not using his heart...since the day he got to know the truth about his birth,he subconsciously completely shut of his heart and just letting his brain win,that too very shallowly..he doesn't think much into anything he just acts by the minute and the information thats infront of him,doesnt dwell into things and all this is because he lost everyone he loves so he majorly shuts out any deep thoughts,just acting mechanically.....once he starts listening to his heart a lot of this heart vs mind dilemma of him will be solved, he will be back to his original vikrant self.....

other scenario where mannat&co knows the truth but doesn't reveal it can mean the preleap scenario will repeat all over again and it can get pretty messy.. which I too don't want

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Bold: Does this fear still exist after the promo we saw of Mannu bhai making a decision to go back to SM to cater for the wedding?I'd like to hear her explain to Ronnie why they are entering the lion's den.

Who knew just seeing Aish would cure Mannat of all her fears. She got an adrenaline rush and is already ready for battle.

Mannat’s a wildcat tearing and yelling at ARS, I wanted to see the white wig come off 😂 but you’re right it was the much needed anger and adrenaline Mannat needed to flip her out of her flight into flight mode. Now hopefully her sharp mind returns and see through all the disguises.

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Yes Shazia you are right.. I don't think mannat will tell about dua even after knowing about the misunderstanding, she will act from a mother's perspective and feel the truth might hurt dua and not tell anyone the truth,today's episode reiterated that fact.. But when I meant she will soften I didnt mean she will want to be back with vik, or want to forgive him but just soften enough to be amicable in conversations away from current state of hostility...

This I say so because if you see most of indore side's issue with vik is preganancy and divorce thing, that made them loose hope on vik, they might be angry on vik for other things too but they might think those are redeemable, that's why even after everything they went to dhairya's house and were hoping things will sort out, if vik apologized and rectified then they would have given vik another chance... But the pregnancy and divorce misunderstandings turned the scenario, where they lost all hopes.. So knowing pregnancy and divorce misunderstanding they will soften enough to feel things are amendable once vik redeems..

And I too hope the second scenario where vik finds out first and I have a bit hope on that because even after seeing seemingly obvious situation of a child between dhairya-mannat and her calling them mumma, baba.....vik questioned to himself are they really a family, ..Even mannat at spot beloved yash-vik-yuvi are family because it was default conclusion anyone draws.. but vik despite seeing similar scenario still was questioning are they a family.. .because he knows in his heart mannat cannot move on with his brother,we might say vik is not using his brain and i agree too but more than brain he is not using his heart...since the day he got to know the truth about his birth,he subconsciously completely shut of his heart and just letting his brain win,that too very shallowly..he doesn't think much into anything he just acts by the minute and the information thats infront of him,doesnt dwell into things and all this is because he lost everyone he loves so he majorly shuts out any deep thoughts,just acting mechanically.....once he starts listening to his heart a lot of this heart vs mind dilemma of him will be solved, he will be back to his original vikrant self.....

other scenario where mannat&co knows the truth but doesn't reveal it can mean the preleap scenario will repeat all over again and it can get pretty messy.. which I too don't want

That’s very true….there’s too much animosity between them with Mannat’s primary focus to protect Dua, so the old Mannat who forgave Vik easily is gone.

I wonder if Ronnie will be more likely to flip into wanting to tell Vik (to join Neetu’s side) when he get to know Vik didn’t know of the pregnancy/Divorce and talk to Mannat. Though he’s been very supportive of whatever decisions Mannat has made and not tried to influence her, even to accept Vik’s offer of money.

I’m glad there is some movement at least now with Mannat after ARS, even if thats means Mannat will be even more bitter towards Vikrant for failing to realise ARS’s obvious disguise and harbour a criminal.

One lie destroyed life's , one truth will rebuild life's 🤩

Keep scrolling

Keep scrolling

Keep scrolling

just kidding, Mukta's writers don't believe in such logic