Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 18

Originally posted by: Moor278

How will Mannat know if Yuvi called Y mom or not? They haven't spent that amount of time together as far as I know

Arrey but she just assumed no?

Even when she saw them together in Mumbai. As long as we know Mannat was already pregnant when they separated so Dua being 6yrs makes sense. Yuvi is almost same age may be might few months younger than Dua. Even if we go by logic him being Preemie . My point is that they have to born in same year . I can say because my kids cousin and she was born in same year and my kid is Preemie so the age gap between them is mere of few months. It should've been less but because she is a Preemie so it's been few more months.

So according to her they separated, immediately he married and had kid. Time-line doesn't fit.

And even scientifically, logically it doesn't makes sense . At least to me 🤪

Anyways silly me🤪. Talking about logic again 😭🤪

In Mannatland to create MU everything is possible 🤪

Thanks to Mukta Mata and her logic🤪😡

❤🤗

As per what Mannat knows...

Vik sent her divorce papers... wanted nothing to do with her and her child (as told by Malla). Was extremely upset at her thinking she betrayed him.... in her words... chutkara chahiye tha ...

So its logical she would think he moved on!!!!

It is Vik who is illogical when he still says I am married (to Dr. Vishwas) but questioned Mannat that I was your husband.. and then thinks she married DK and has a daughter....

So according to him Mannat and DKs marriage is invalid is it???? Why doesnt he question how DM marriage is valid if he is still her husband?????

Why does he say tha and hai when talking about their relationship?????

Clarity usko nahi hai... Mannat ko hai 🤣

Kids age is immaterial at this point ... Asli grudge is both think they moved on

Originally posted by: Moor278

As per what Mannat knows...

Vik sent her divorce papers... wanted nothing to do with her and her child (as told by Malla). Was extremely upset at her thinking she betrayed him.... in her words... chutkara chahiye tha ...

So its logical she would think he moved on!!!!

It is Vik who is illogical when he still says I am married (to Dr. Vishwas) but questioned Mannat that I was your husband.. and then thinks she married DK and has a daughter....

So according to him Mannat and DKs marriage is invalid is it???? Why doesnt he question how DM marriage is valid if he is still her husband?????

Why does he say tha and hai when talking about their relationship?????

Clarity usko nahi hai... Mannat ko hai 🤣

Kids age is immaterial at this point ... Asli grudge is both think they moved on

Trust Vikku to stop us in our prediction tracks. I officially do not understand him now.

Do you think though that what Y did with Mannat to mislead about the nature of their relationship, Y may have done so with a lot of people in Vikrant's life? Vikrant seems spaced out half the time. To everyone else his relationship seems more than what it actually appears to be. Noone has seen how he is with her in private and she seems to exert her influence on everyone when he is not there. I haven't actually seen her do it in his presence.

Bold: I think the complication is in that, that marriage was never registered. How does he contest Mannat moving on? Their terrace marriage holds true to the two of them. So maybe Mannat has broken vows made in front of Babaji but he can't break those vows (that reasoning then doesn't make sense coz of Yashika though)

Update:

• Mannat thinks of how she decided to keep DK's name on the BC. And she is still upset. BTW, Dua was born in Dehradun. Vish was not wrong.
• DK asks Dua very smartly, what happened after he left. Dua innocently says Khadoos and Mama were fighting. Dua & DK play a prank to bring her out of the room.
• DK - Mannat chat. DK wants to tear up the BC because he feels it would give people the wrong impression. Mannat is firm that they don't need to explain their relationship to anyone. They will remain friends for life, grow old together! Noone was around when they were in the doldrums, so noone needs to care now!
• Vik is with Yuvi, who is upset that the bad lady was punished. Vik explains that she was not at fault, but the real culprits are in jail. And what followed was something I was not at all comfortable. Yuvi still looks low because Mannat was jailed. What a child!!
• So to cheer him up, Vik says, he will discuss with Mimo, and if he is good, they will on a holiday to London. Yuvi immediately cheers up. Kumar tells Vik Yashika is making khichdi for Yuvi. Vik mutters that a person who is nothing to Yuvi is so concerned but there's another person, who does not care about anything. Kyun bhai?? Why this unnecessary anger against Mannat all the time?
• Ya reaches Mannats house to pick up khichdi. She tells her, Vik and she are very happy together. But she got worried when she saw Mannat. Becasue the pull of first love is a lot. Mannat clarifies that when the first love gives pain, it's an learning experience! Yashika says she got worried about men's fitrat to cheat. Mannat looks very puzzled at this!! She also asks her about her husband. Mannat says their relationship is about trust, which is greater than love. Ya is happy that Mannat is happy & leaves .
• Neetu is goading Dua to take her to Vik. She says she should join the competition. Dua resists her, saying her mom won't like it. But Neetu keeps trying, then finally she lies and says Vik called her & told her to bring Dua. neetu's selfish thought is if Vik knows about Dua, he will calm down & forgive her too. Only later, she says she wants to unite the family. Where does Mannat stand in all of this?
• Ya brings khichdi. Vik smells it, gets up saying 'Mannat'. he remembers them b fighting over khichdi. Frankly, the FB seemed to be written ad hoc, & last minute. i didn't enjoy it too much. He tells Ya it can't be made by her , and she gets offended, makes a fuss, and he apologised, no questions asked . So his proof keeda is only for Mannat, not for anyone in his immediate circle. Ya, Arzoo are all rich, so he presumes they can't lie?? It is this trait that has led to this state in his life, where he is surrounded by blood sucking dementors
• Dua tries to leave with Neetu. bunty calls out loudly, and Mannat comes running out. She makes them both grate carrot for halwa..so Mom like, very cute scene. Dua slips away.

Pre-cap: Neetu sees Vik, falls when she tries to walk, but someone, am presuming DK, catches her.

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

I am on cloud nine!!! DCP and Mannat rocked it!

Everything I wanted everyone to hear out loud!!! I love their relationship

Nazar nah lage!!!

No constraints no questions asked …. This is such a beautiful bond!

The best part about this show unlike Mannat’s previous life is the fact that Dua here is mummypaglu instead of her predecessor’s baba jaap and secondly the strong support system Mannat has in DK and to some extent Ronnie( Don’t trust him given his past history of flipping like a pancake )

The biggest grudge I had with Mannat’s lost life was the fact that she had absolutely no support system with the entire zoo nivas thirsty for her blood. Thankfully that’s not the case here! Don’t wanna jinx it. Thu Thu Thu

From what I have understood so far and especially after Vik met Mannat... they are deliberately showing him unhinged of sorts... like he is not in control of his reactions or emotions...

To gain audiences sympathy for him... coz the moment there is Mannat around Vik becomes his maddest version and behaves the worst with her ... his behaviour at other times is to give reasons for his madness...

I kind of felt bad for Y... she clearly hasnt met the Khanna genes... doesnt know what they are capable of 😂. Malla and Vish she can handle. Aish and Mannat are different ball game.

Daman ka spoiler of Malla failing in her Y expose would tell us more.

I felt she underestimated Mannat when she went and blabbered about her happy married life .. but in her favour Mannat is unbothered about Vik till some truths unravel for her. Till then Y is safe.

Had Vik told Mannat that he is not married aaj ka Y ka explanation irrelevant hota and Mannat would have caught her 😅

Just that Mannat being Mannat... she shouldn't promote Y to Vik 🤦‍♀️

Ys ... men have a fitrat to cheat felt like a premonition

If and when Vik pursues Mannat later on... Y will conveniently blame Mannat for encouraging Vik or not stopping his advances

Another round of CAing Mannat would happen aisa laga

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Trust Vikku to stop us in our prediction tracks. I officially do not understand him now.

Do you think though that what Y did with Mannat to mislead about the nature of their relationship, Y may have done so with a lot of people in Vikrant's life? Vikrant seems spaced out half the time. To everyone else his relationship seems more than what it actually appears to be. Noone has seen how he is with her in private and she seems to exert her influence on everyone when he is not there. I haven't actually seen her do it in his presence.

Bold: I think the complication is in that, that marriage was never registered. How does he contest Mannat moving on? Their terrace marriage holds true to the two of them. So maybe Mannat has broken vows made in front of Babaji but he can't break those vows (that reasoning then doesn't make sense coz of Yashika though)

@Moor

RIP logic 🤪. That's the only thing I can say about this😭.

@Betty

About Yashi we are not sure yet what kind of relationship they share?

IDT it's romantic in any way because it's really evident the way Vikrant is around her. May be he considers her only as friend but we know what Yashi wants and projecting it in front of others 🤬.

Him letting her sleep in his room that also because for him she is his friend and may be somewhere he is trying to find that emotional support because he is all alone despite having people around him. Now we know Yashi is pretending but for him may be she is there to listen to him and she cares for Yuvi . Right now he is the most important person in his life.

On X I read one funny comment about Yashi by someone. That user said are we sure that Yashi is his GF? Dude doesn’t even acknowledge her unless and until she opens her mouth 🤪. He literally moves away when she tries to touch him or hug him.

Hope they will show how she landed in Vikrant's life 🤞. IDT that he is trying to move on. If we go by his conversation with Yashi about Mannat. He clearly said that to forget her he gave place to others in his life . He said about Yuvi not Yashi. She herself said am I not there?🤪. So it's clear for him she doesn't matter. She is the one who is forcing herself in his life using emotional manipulation and Yuvi😡

Honestly I still do feel vik is majorly responsible for how things turned out to be.. But it's not like the other side is completely right.. they did their share of mistakes but the only difference is they realised it and tried to make amends to their relationship with vik.. but vik in his impulsivity went over and above, and took wrong decisions...

But this doesn't mean story has to villainize him, the story has become one sided, they are showing struggles and emotional turmoil of mannat&co and rightfully so...but not doing the same for vik..... It's not easy to be on his side either..

i have issues with writers the way they are making mannat say things about vik without showing vik's side, it is so loop sided.. Mannat saying all those things is right from her pov but they also need to give vik's side of story..

Now the way they are showing things nobody will remember what rotu did, and that vik actually doesn't know about preganancy, they might feel rotu are completely innocent and vik actually questioned mannat's preganancy and rejected his baby...

The way they are completely whitewashing rotu is unacceptable too.... what rotu did to vik is completely unacceptable too, neetu did accident, ronnie tried to cover it up and ronnie bought vik with money kinda of child trafficking... And over and above all of this neetu gave life threatening drugs to vik....But they did deserve another chance considering that they do actually love him though with few selfish undertones,they do love him, and after mannat pointed out their mistakes they changed and hence they deserved another chance and vik impulsively throwing them out of their own house is wrong without listening to them and giving them one last chance. .

but vik himself could have bought back rotu had they not left the town overnight, this made him feel they don't love him or need him , maybe he felt confident about mannat taking care of them, and that they choose their own path and family..leaving him behind, so he kind of respected their decision and hence he didn't want to push his way into their life..

They are very well showing mannat&co's story and emotions.. but not doing the same for vik... Show both sides of the story and let audience decide if one is right and other is wrong, or both sides are right/wrong

Originally posted by: truptishree

@Moor

RIP logic 🤪. That's the only thing I can say about this😭.

@Betty

About Yashi we are not sure yet what kind of relationship they share?

IDT it's romantic in any way because it's really evident the way Vikrant is around her. May be he considers her only as friend but we know what Yashi wants and projecting it in front of others 🤬.

Him letting her sleep in his room that also because for him she is his friend and may be somewhere he is trying to find that emotional support because he is all alone despite having people around him. Now we know Yashi is pretending but for him may be she is there to listen to him and she cares for Yuvi . Right now he is the most important person in his life.

On X I read one funny comment about Yashi by someone. That user said are we sure that Yashi is his GF? Dude doesn’t even acknowledge her unless and until she opens her mouth 🤪. He literally moves away when she tries to touch him or hug him.

Hope they will show how she landed in Vikrant's life 🤞. IDT that he is trying to move on. If we go by his conversation with Yashi about Mannat. He clearly said that to forget her he gave place to others in his life . He said about Yuvi not Yashi. She herself said am I not there?🤪. So it's clear for him she doesn't matter. She is the one who is forcing herself in his life using emotional manipulation and Yuvi😡

Honestly had actors not mentioned that yash is his gf, nobody would have thought that yash is his gf.. But then actors don't know much about scripts, they just say their pov from the briefing they get for 2-3 days...

But then again vik himself said that he tried to move on during mezbani confession and doesn't have issue when yash says "baby", why would people allow their friends to call them baby... But honestly writer's can flip the narrative when ever they want, they can go ahead and contraindicate vik's mezbani confession and say vik never tried to move on and that yash is just his friend.. Etc... .. .