Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 37 - Page 135

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Its not about societal stigma...mannat can face all of it, but what about dua...

See....malla is pretty clear about her partner status that her partner cheated on her and left her.... This way she can teach yuvi to be strong and answer back in such situations and not get effected because they are not at fault....its the fault of father

yuvi can easily be taught to be confident and not get effected with such allegations of society because he knows he or his mother are not at fault,it is his father who left them and he is at fault....But how can mannat teach dua to be strong and not get effected without giving her a reason as to why her father is not around her.....

Mannat doesn't want to say vik betrayed her,because despite of whatever happened she still can't believe vik did all of it, and may be she doesn't want vik to face societal wrath even indirectly...she can't say vik and her are seperated/divorced because then dua would want to meet vik, which vik won't accept as per mannat and dua will have abandonment issues at such young age..mannat cannot say vik died...basically mannat has no answers to give to dua

So she cannot give the child her name, because then society will ask Dua about her father and dua will not have any answer to give to them and she might get effected because of all of these... And mannat is not yet ready for real marriage, so through fake marriage ..vik will not get societal wrath, Dua will not get effected by societal allegations, and mannat need not be in a real marriage where she cannot do justice to that relationship..

I have a different perspective on this. If Malla can tell truth to Yuvi then why not Mannat?

As such she thinks Vikrant rejected their kid and we know that’s not the case. But if we see from Mannat’s POV that’s true.

And if you ask me lying is never an option. My parents always taught me to say truth and be ready to face the consequences of it. And I always taught the same to my kid.

We say oh! They are kids and will not understand but Kids are in fact very understanding and they do understand the situation.

My kid ask me so many embarrassing questions and I always tell her truth though twisting it little bit considering her age. And if it’s really not age appropriate for her then simply tell her that it’s not appropriate to tell her now and will tell later and my kid understands that my mom is telling the truth and will tell me later.

Sometimes back when my kid was watching episode with me and said” how can Mannat lie on his face ? She loves him so she should tell the truth to him. He will definitely get angry after knowing truth”. Even my kid understood that she is doing wrong by hiding the truth.

And see Mannat and RoTu their one lie landed them in this mess. They should’ve stuck to truth. And one more problem is there that Vikrant is also oblivious to this truth that Dua is his daughter. They all are again doing the same mistake which they did with Vikrant by hiding his birth truth😭

Anyways that’s your POV and I do respect it. But for me like I said honesty is the best policy.

I do apply that in my life and taught the same to my kid so for me this lying and hiding things doesn’t makes sense. But it’s ITV where logic, truth and justice never go hand in hand😜.

❤️🤗

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Vikrant is as much a victim as Mannat that is why you will see me swinging back and forth in posts , I am here only and only for ManVik

Dirty allegations were inexcusable and Vikrant is no saint we all agree on this.

The point I was trying to make though was, how did it get to this ugly situation? Who enabled Vish , the villains , who caused the fire on KC, EB Mannat into lying all for his brother? And then he goes on to leave the same brother in a matter of hours because Vikrant believed the same mother whom he believed for years until he himself heard the truth from Dadi, until then he infact put Vikrant and Mannat at risk multiple times believing Vish 🙄

For me DK is as much the villain as the 3 witches. His actions spoke louder than the words pre and post leap 🙈

Red is when his actions were driven by the thought that he wanted to tell the truth to Vik and take Aman back and seek revenge for their father.

He changed his position when he was shown the proof ... that is a good enough logic to why he did support RoTu and Mannat.

Blue... is same as Vikrant... it all happened in the same day for him as well... where Vik was in no position to listen to an alternate version. DK was clubbed by Vik in the same bracket as others. Mannat even told DK what he thinks about them. So he knew what all is going in Viks mind... Shrutis accident was a massive shock for everyone and just as they were doing the funeral rights.... Malla came with the divorce papers... DK tried to reason with Vish and Vik hit him...

What more he could have done?????

Green... He initiated the issue with an intention of bringing back Aman and even then he was pro Mannat... which is what he told Vish as well... the intention as I point out repeatedly was never to separate ManVik and pursue/marry Mannat.

Had DK been intending a luxurious life ... he too would have stayed in SM. He doesnt have any romantic intentions for Mannat... neither there was any child in picture. So to 'live his brothers life' which doesnt have anything to offer in terms of riches, luxury and love makes no sense.

I am sorry in my opinion, we cannot even compare Malla and Mannat. Malla ‘s child is a stolen child. She can say anything and change things as per her choice because there’s no history for the child.

Dua has a history of her parents not being married socially, her parents separating, her father rejecting her, her mother being accused of having an affair. And there are all facts of her life , they are not fabricated lies.

Plus Vikrant has always believed Malla .. whatever she has done in the past is irrelevant. Malla has no fear at all.

It angers me to think he has lived with Malla and supported her for more years than Mannat!!

We can say he is indifferent to her but he considers her important enough to stay in his house as his family.

I’m not supporting the birth certificate thing Mannat has done but I don’t think Malla, such a despicable character can be considered as someone who has done the ‘right thing’ in this case.

I am sorry but I feel very strongly about Malla. being around Vik.

In today's episode, Vikrant has a problem with his so-called dhokebaaz parents supporting Mannat. In an earlier episode, he had a problem with Mannat siding with those dhokebaaz people.

Now, what do we make of the character if we just hold on to what he says. 😂.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Red is when his actions were driven by the thought that he wanted to tell the truth to Vik and take Aman back and seek revenge for their father.

He changed his position when he was shown the proof ... that is a good enough logic to why he did support RoTu and Mannat.

Blue... is same as Vikrant... it all happened in the same day for him as well... where Vik was in no position to listen to an alternate version. DK was clubbed by Vik in the same bracket as others. Mannat even told DK what he thinks about them. So he knew what all is going in Viks mind... Shrutis accident was a massive shock for everyone and just as they were doing the funeral rights.... Malla came with the divorce papers... DK tried to reason with Vish and Vik hit him...

What more he could have done?????

Green... He initiated the issue with an intention of bringing back Aman and even then he was pro Mannat... which is what he told Vish as well... the intention as I point out repeatedly was never to separate ManVik and pursue/marry Mannat.

Had DK been intending a luxurious life ... he too would have stayed in SM. He doesnt have any romantic intentions for Mannat... neither there was any child in picture. So to 'live his brothers life' which doesnt have anything to offer in terms of riches, luxury and love makes no sense.

DKs professional life has also gone for a toss waise.

While DK is called out as corrupt if I remember correctly, Vikrant wielded his Saluja (which he is not) power, turned into a shrewd businessman, stopped his promotion & destroyed his career. Still DK is trying to help RoTu & Mannat with whatever money he has..

And even now he is still vowing to destroy Mannat...

What Vikrant knowing the half truth has done to Mannat & is still harboring grudge against her & wants to destroy her , if Mannat also keeps the same attitude & does something to him then everyone will bash her left & right...

Originally posted by: Taiyo

In today's episode, Vikrant has a problem with his so-called dhokebaaz parents supporting Mannat. In an earlier episode, he had a problem with Mannat siding with those dhokebaaz people.

Now, what do we make of the character if we just hold on to what he says. 😂.

He is a mess..... In a matter of hours he had so many contrasting opinions... On one side he says rotu betrayed him and on other side he still considers them parivaar...

On one side he still questions if mannat-dua-dhairya are really a family... making it look like he trusts mannat's loyalty towards him ,despite seeing them as family... On another hand he says he was stupid in not understanding mannat's fitrat...

On one side he owes to put mannat in jail... And on other side he fells may be ronnie is right about proofs

He confronts mannat about stealing his family.... How??? How did mannat steal his family... Why does he think mannat stole his family.... What could mannat get out of it... Because even their property is with Vik....

Does he even understand what he is thinking, speaking, doing?????????

Either writers purposely wants to show Vik as a confused disturbed soul who doesn't make any sense... Or their writing is poor that they are not able to put out their vision for vik's character

I am not even joking Vik really needs therapy...

What are they writing, how are they writing Vikrant?? To what end??

Am really getting annoyed. And there’s no respite going by coming scenes

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

He is a mess..... In a matter of hours he had so many contrasting opinions... On one side he says rotu betrayed him and on other side he still considers them parivaar...

On one side he still questions if mannat-dua-dhairya are really a family... making it look like he trusts mannat's loyalty towards him ,despite seeing them as family... On another hand he says he was stupid in not understanding mannat's fitrat...

On one side he owes to put mannat in jail... And on other side he fells may be ronnie is right about proofs

I am not even joking Vik really needs therapy...

@Chaotic

He feels betrayed he says.... "Pyaar mujh se jataya aur shaadi kisi aur se kar li.... Mein hi pagal tha jo tumhara fitrat nahi samaj paaya"

Vik again conveniently forgot that he made those promises to her about love, put sindoor in her maang, slept with her & then due to truth broke the marriage inspite of her pleading begging multiple times to not do that...

I wish Mannat also tells him ki "tumhari fitrat bhi mai samajh nai paayi, pyaar mujhse kia, maang meri hi bhari, suhaag raat mere saath manaaya par shaadi ke mandap mei chora mujhey and aaj haath thaam kisi aur ka lia"

Until Mannat wasn't in his vicinity he controlled his pent up emotions..the moment she came in front of him he started his angsty phase with her spilling out some things..Mannu affects him a lot...khair...maar hi do ek dusre ko...inka angsty phase begins ...

https://x.com/i/status/2013996411541770345

Originally posted by: scarlett22

What are they writing, how are they writing Vikrant?? To what end??

Am really getting annoyed. And there’s no respite going by coming scenes

Don't know what they are planning to do, to what extent are they messing up vikrant...

For mannat, they clearly show her turmoil, flashbacks... But for Vik literally nothing....

Mannat atleast have a linear thought... But vik is all over the place... Not even two contrasting opinions..... his dialogues, scenes portray multitudes of contrasting opinions which doesn't even make sense...