Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 36 - Page 112

Originally posted by: Padmajaan

She calls him baby and he seems cool with it and is all touchy and feely YUCK!!

I wonder how the makers can justify all this and still want us to root for Manvik or for Dua to be reunited with dad. because he does seem to have moved on except that he seems to ONLY trust the most evil women out there.

And his reactions of missing Mannat and not being able to move on etc just doesn't cut any ice with the viewers because of such sloppy writing!

Yes I wonder what his defence is gonna be when mannat confronts him of moving on... Is he gonna say he had a gf, tried to move on, shared a room, went on date trips but still he didn't move on.. .

Not a great defense if you ask me.. Especially against a woman who despite facing everything never tried to moved on and dedicated her life to look after their child and his parents... To match the depth of mannat's love his defense atleast should have been that irrespective of their past he never moved on or wanted to move on because he knows no on can take her place... Atleast such kind of scenario would have made vik stand a chance with mannat.... Currently vik's character and his love for mannat is coming across as relatively week when compared to mannat's

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Yes I wonder what his defence is gonna be when mannat confronts him of moving on... Is he gonna say he had a gf, tried to move on, shared a room, went on date trips but still he didn't move on.. .

Not a great defense if you ask me.. Especially against a woman who despite facing everything never tried to moved on and dedicated her life to look after their child and his parents... To match the depth of mannat's love his defense atleast should have been that irrespective of their past he never moved on or wanted to move on because he knows no on can take her place... Atleast such kind of scenario would have made vik stand a chance with mannat.... Currently vik's character and his love for mannat is coming across as relatively week when compared to mannat's

Does Vikrant need to have not moved on to be worthy of Mannat? And does his love for Mannat need to match the depth of her love? Is Mannat waiting for Vikrant to come back or it's just that she has chosen to shut the door on love? Vikrant is going to find her in the same place having not betrayed their love not because she was waiting on him but that she chose to fill the void with their child.

It's going to have to be up to Mannat to decide if she wants to give their relationship another chance considering Vikrant's faults and all.

They have given Mannat a family and Vikrant has nothing. it's not surprising he is trying to find love somewhere so his life can have meaning.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Does Vikrant need to have not moved on to be worthy of Mannat? And does his love for Mannat need to match the depth of her love? Is Mannat waiting for Vikrant to come back or it's just that she has chosen to shut the door on love? Vikrant is going to find her in the same place having not betrayed their love not because she was waiting on him but that she chose to fill the void with their child.

It's going to have to be up to Mannat to decide if she wants to give their relationship another chance considering Vikrant's faults and all.

They have given Mannat a family and Vikrant has nothing. it's not surprising he is trying to find love somewhere so his life can have meaning.

Yes, I totally get your point and you are right everyone deserves love nobody deserves to be stuck in their past and suffer.. And vik totally deserves to move on....one shouldn't say vik betrayed mannat etc... Because he didn't, he only is trying to move on after their breakup and waiting for years...

My point is if he had moved on, he shouldnt look back or expect mannat to be back nor should mannat go back... Because when two people breakup there is lot of trauma involved in it so to be back together and rebuild relation they have to go through lot of pain and all this is worth it if they are not able to move on with other people and are irreplaceable in each other's life... But if they moved on with other people what's the point to go through all that pain again and get back together....

Now here we might have confusion whether he moved on or he is just trying to move on.... Writers might present it as he is trying but not able to move on but as per their narration it does seem he moved on... One wouldn't be in a proper relationship if one didn't move on, if one were just trying ,they would just be getting to know each other and not enter into a proper relationship.....and they wouldn't be as physically proximate as yash-vik and wouldn't be going on date trips... And all these for 2-3 years.....

Now this is where makers have to clear things ,how long is their relationship...if these things are recent for few months then I would believe that he is just trying to move on ..... No one who were in relationship for 2-3 years and went on multiple dates can say they didn't move on..by this time they would realise it's not working and they would leave the relationship, even if other person is trying to hold on,they will feel suffocated and walk off themselves....and if they didn't walk off even after 2-3 years then it's given that they have moved on, it's just matter of time before they realise it

Its the inconsistent writing that's the problem rather than the character itself... Because the vik they presented initially wouldn't just abandon rotu like that, even if he feels they are responsible for their Father's death, mother's suffering.. He would stay away from them but atleast would have kept a tab on them... Just like these there are several inconsistencies in writing...

There was this comment from Yashika when she enters Mezbaani and seeing the glitters that our Devdas is again pining for his lost love. It must be a pattern that Yashika thinks shes gaining Vikrants affection but he has some memories that push him back into Mannat jaap.

Yuvi and the separation and Vish ARS had thought would transfer Vikrants attention to her Lauti beti. She realises she has failed in the mission. Ars calls Mannu her Bad sua but DUA has arrived to be thr blessing in the life of her loved ones. She is a mix of the angelic forces and impish forces working to being retribution to the witches. Her self proclaimed protector is DCP. He is the Shruti maa parallel . His love for DUA is pure. He is not obsessed but totally devoted to her to provide the child stability and independence something Vikrant didn't receive and is unable to provide YUvi.

Originally posted by: Daman17

For those who did not understand the Gurbani shlok, here is a simple explanation of the version currently used in Mannat during the prayer scenes.

Sene de vich, Satguru ankhan di jot jaga gaye, Wah Wah Guru mereya, chidiyaan ton baaz bana gaye. De sar chadhiye eh tere bande ji, Jo tusi sikh dinde, maidaan ch josh na ghatda. vich bhar diyaan apniyaan, Ki chahide saanu..Hai jind jaan teri. Ki karaan main teriyaan vadiyaan, mere Maalka Kaun hai badshah? Bandeya da badshah. Mere Maalka, Rab ji, Waheguru, Waheguru, Satnam.

Meaning In that prayer moment, these lines express inner surrender and faith. One seeking strength from Waheguru, believing that the Guru awakens light and clarity even in the darkest situations and can transform helpless people into strong, fearless ones. By offering your life and ego at God’s feet, you accepts that whatever happens is in His hands and with tears and devotion, one asks for nothing except truth, courage, and protection for the loved ones. The prayer shows complete trust that Waheguru is the ultimate authority above all people and circumstances and that only his grace can guide through the emotional and moral battles one is facing.

Essence of shabad

1. Complete surrender

2. Transformation through Guru’s grace

3. Fearlessness and faith

4. Devotion without demands

5. Recognition of God as the ultimate King

Such a beautiful explanation of Gurbani shlok and its principle of surrender to God..Thank you, Daman .

One more point to add to enhance the principle of complete surrender to Waheguru, Mannat surrendered herself and everything to God at seashore after the meet up at wedding function.It shows her devotion without demands.

Waheguru brought Vikrant into her life as BDB, now Dua to replace him, and Dua is BDB to both her parents..What a divine intervention which is believed to happen for a reason, to fulfill God's will, answer prayers for a purpose..

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Such a beautiful explanation of Gurbani shlok and its principle of surrender to God..Thank you, Daman .

One more point to add to enhance the principle of complete surrender to Waheguru, Mannat surrendered herself and everything to God at seashore after the meet up at wedding function.It shows her devotion without demands.

Waheguru brought Vikrant into her life as BDB, now Dua to replace him, and Dua is BDB to both her parents..What a divine intervention which is believed to happen for a reason, to fulfill God's will, answer prayers for a purpose..

Tagging you guys

Beautiful explanation Daman.

Manvik bond has been chosen by Babaji. And He will find a way through Dua to make them meet soon.

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Beautiful explanation Daman.

Manvik bond has been chosen by Babaji. And He will find a way through Dua to make them meet soon.

Scar & Resham waiting for your update of yesterday's episode.

There is one clarification about DK's intentions for audience when he says, Mannat 's BDB WAS/ IS/ WILL always be Vikrant and Dua's BDB is DK..here comes clash with Vik when he claims his daughter..

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I hear DK has appointed himself as Dua's Babaji ka Banda. If the comments i'm seeing on X can be relied on i think Coolmeg is enjoying the final days of a sane DCP 🏃‍♀️🏃‍♀️🏃‍♀️🏃‍♀️

Aren't they now diluting this Babaji ka Banda term. There was something special about it when it was used just on Manvik. Now it's just being extended everywhere.

The entire episode I was like …. Yeh to gaya ab!!!

DCP VS Vikrant is loading!

DCP didn’t just declare himself BDB for Dua he did it with power!! He repeatedly stated he is the father!
he did say BDB for Mannat is and will always me Vikrant but he called him BDB for Dua!

Vikrant is going to have a tough battle!!! I so want him to beg fight cry …… I can’t wait!!!

I am ready for DCP ka next phase…. I know it will be heartbreaking but I signed up for it!! DCP will give him a tough fight but I also know he is going to end up with a shattered heart losing Dua! He definitely loves her and cares for her very much!!!

Originally posted by: Daman17

For those who did not understand the Gurbani shlok, here is a simple explanation of the version currently used in Mannat during the prayer scenes.

Sene de vich, Satguru ankhan di jot jaga gaye, Wah Wah Guru mereya, chidiyaan ton baaz bana gaye. De sar chadhiye eh tere bande ji, Jo tusi sikh dinde, maidaan ch josh na ghatda. vich bhar diyaan apniyaan, Ki chahide saanu..Hai jind jaan teri. Ki karaan main teriyaan vadiyaan, mere Maalka Kaun hai badshah? Bandeya da badshah. Mere Maalka, Rab ji, Waheguru, Waheguru, Satnam.

Meaning In that prayer moment, these lines express inner surrender and faith. One seeking strength from Waheguru, believing that the Guru awakens light and clarity even in the darkest situations and can transform helpless people into strong, fearless ones. By offering your life and ego at God’s feet, you accepts that whatever happens is in His hands and with tears and devotion, one asks for nothing except truth, courage, and protection for the loved ones. The prayer shows complete trust that Waheguru is the ultimate authority above all people and circumstances and that only his grace can guide through the emotional and moral battles one is facing.

Essence of shabad

1. Complete surrender

2. Transformation through Guru’s grace

3. Fearlessness and faith

4. Devotion without demands

5. Recognition of God as the ultimate King

Beautiful!!! Thank you so much for sharing this meaning!!! Absolutely amazing!