Film Critics Guild issues statement - Page 2

Anupamaa is chairperson of this guild and Sucharita is vice chairperson

They have created group of 4-5 irrelevant people like them to go against movies

While Sucharita is liking comments suggesting a movie is Indian effort to colonize Pakistan

Imagine trying so hard to hurt a film which dared to show terrorists in bad light

Originally posted by: MsWhiskerson

Anupamaa is chairperson of this guild and Sucharita is vice chairperson

They have created group of 4-5 irrelevant people like them to go against movies

While Sucharita is liking comments suggesting a movie is Indian effort to colonize Pakistan

And this is the reason why critics like sucharitra and anupama are getting criticised, this is the reason!'they have a problem with the whole premise of the movie and the fact that this movie is about ind/pak, they are annoyed by it and attacking the film with words like hypermasculinity and hyper nationalism. They put the screenplay, performances, the technical aspects all to one side and just focused on the politics of the film, nothing wrong with mentioning it like hrithik did, but to make it your whole basis of being negative and trying to bash the film, like sucharitra is doing, that is why people are outraged by their reviews

Originally posted by: zara321

Amd this is the reason why critics like sucharitra and anupama are getting criticised, this is the reason!'they have a problem with the whole premise of the movie and the fact that this movie is about ind/pak, they are annoyed by it and attacking the film with words like hypermasculinity and hyper nationalism

Last few days, Pakistani members on this forum have been doing negativity here, attacking Indians who are watching and loving the movie, which didn't even release in Pakistan

Pakistan made a movie on Pahalgham, did any of us care about it?

And the movie isn't even against Pakistan, it is against terrorism 🤦‍♀️

Anupamaa reviewed the movie then sneakily deleted her review to do this drama but Sucharita didn't even review it, their ideologies didn't allow them to be honest about their work

And Sucharita openly liked replies against India

Why should Indians tolerate such people?

Originally posted by: MsWhiskerson

Last few days, Pakistani members on this forum have been doing negativity here, attacking Indians who are watching and loving the movie, which didn't even release in Pakistan

Pakistan made a movie on Pahalgham, did any of us care about it?

And the movie isn't even against Pakistan, it is against terrorism 🤦‍♀️

Anupamaa reviewed the movie then sneakily deleted her review to do this drama but Sucharita didn't even review it, their ideologies didn't allow them to be honest about their work

And Sucharita openly liked replies against India

Why should Indians tolerate such people?

I am a pakistani, I'm a muslim, I watched it knowing its an Indian film so I knew how the politics of the film is going to be; and i came out of the film appreciating the high level of film making and performances, its a good film no matter whether you agree or disagree with the politics, its entertaining and edge of your seet

In ka sara ecosystem hill gaya hai. The spotlight is shining on them. Will they continue doing 69 with Kjo gang,or will survival instincts take over?

Watch them during Dhurandhar 2. It will be very intersting.

Originally posted by: zara321

I am a pakistani, I'm a muslim, I watched it knowing its an Indian film so I knew how the politics of the film is going to be; and i came out of the film appreciating the high level of film making and performances, its a good film no matter whether you agree or disagree with the politics, its entertaining and edge of your seet

See, how you knew the subject and you watched it

https://x.com/GabbbarSingh/status/1998707486539526442

These are Pakistani individuals as well and they enjoyed it

Sucharita watched the trailer and knew movie is about a spy who infiltrated a gang then she based her entire review on Hyper masculinity 🤦‍♀️ she didn't speak about anything else, nothing about shots, editing...only commented on Ranveer wearing monochromatic kurtas

What kind of reviewer is that?

Though none should be attacked for their views but she should be loyal to the job she does

Originally posted by: you2

In ka sara ecosystem hill gaya hai. The spotlight is shining on them. Will they continue doing 69 with Kjo gang,or will survival instincts take over?

Watch them during Dhurandhar 2. It will be very intersting.

Most who can afford will ignore Dhurandhar 2, Sucharita won't because she was promoting her membership program in Dhurandhar 1 review

They don't get views anymore, only negative PR can fund her

Originally posted by: MsWhiskerson

See, how you knew the subject and you watched it

https://x.com/GabbbarSingh/status/1998707486539526442

These are Pakistani individuals as well and they enjoyed it

Sucharita watched the trailer and knew movie is about a spy who infiltrated a gang then she based her entire review on Hyper masculinity 🤦‍♀️ she didn't speak about anything else, nothing about shots, editing...only commented on Ranveer wearing monochromatic kurtas

What kind of reviewer is that?

Though none should be attacked for their views but she should be loyal to the job she does

My main reason to watch it was ranveer, wanted to support him, then i saw all the positive word of mouth which made me more excited to watch it. Yes I knew the subject of the film, I knew exactly what it was about and so nothing suprised me about the politics, i just wanted to watch a good film and thats exactly what I got! And to see ranveer give a stellar performance was the cherry on the cake, I left the film super excited for the second part

And i agree sucharitra doesnt even review properly, she didnt talk about any technical aspects, just went on and on about hypermasculinity

Any Sane Pakistani won't be offended by Dhurandhar, it isn't a film targeting people of Pakistan, It is a film based on true attacks happen in India by some group of terrorists who initaed from Pakistan. Facts about Kandhar hijacking, Parliament Attack, 26/11 is open in public, I don't see any complain about those facts or info, why pointing finger at Dhurandhar when it is shedding light on same info.

Yes, we can agree, as locals they knew more about Politics, so makers might have gone some angle wrong in saying who rule lyari will rule karachi. Baaki aisa kuch nahi hai jo disrespect kare kisi bhi sane citizen of Paksitan.

Ab aate hai Crictics pe, koi zaroorat nahi thi to troll anupama or suchitra, ye unka kaam hai, they are honest about it, what they feel, they say. Let them or others say whatever they want, we can't shut negative review in any way.

For this, apna Salman is mast, bc koi bhi critic kuch bhi bol de uski film ko, kabhi bhi palatwaar nahi kiya, na hi kisi Salman team ne, na hi makers ne. Dabangg to Dabangg 2, all 5 Blockbusters films were ridiculed by Critics, in fact they ran articles as how these films were huge success, questioning the audience choice in making them big.