Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 34 - Page 119

Originally posted by: Daman17

This has to come out. Shruti is an important character, and her truth will have a major impact on the upcoming track.

So they will end up knowing Aish is alive but coz of the plastic surgery it will take time for them to figure out her new identity?

The moment her new identity is discovered its game over again so that won't happen quickly likely.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Did he have his phone? Even if he had it we know how it's been put on flight mode previously. She might have been calling when they were still searching for Shruti. The way he was being kept under surveillance by the trio there is no way she would have gotten through to him.

In only watching bts the sequences are jumbled in my mind….but in Mannat and Vik’s confrontation on the terrace where she turns and after feeling dizzy walks away, Vik looks at his mobile then angrily throws it away……has he damaged his phone and that’s why Mannat hasn’t been able to reach him, or maybe even Shruti tried to call him?

We still have harrowing episodes to go of Shruti’s assault and murder, then Mannat’s frantic search, to finding out she’s died. Ayesha was brilliant during ARS shooting sequence, so will have very traumatic scenes yet again. Ayesha has shone in this track!

Kya yaar! I watched yesterday and today and came here to rave about the episodes. Total tear jerkers both episodes. And all acted so superbly.

Mukta Tai, we know you are banking on Adnan Khan to get through this phase, but not so much torture for poor Vikrant.

Adnan is just fantabulous. He keeps shifting eyes away from Ronnie, he tries to stare down Mannat but he fails. And his confusion when Vishakha talks, how come his anger is not valid, he asks Gagan. Absolutely true.

Vishakha's two arrows at him :

- They will take you away from me

- Mannat has separated Dhairya from me.

Vikrant is traumatised. But he is stubborn, does not grant any benefit of doubt even to Gagan.

Ronnie / Rushad was fabulous when he falls at Vikrant's feet. And when he fights for Neetu, showing Vikrant literally how to love your wife unconditionally!

Ayesha / Mannat, not much to talk today. But her expressions towards Vishakha, Vikrant (she understands his pain, but she is angry and disbelieving in this version of Vikrant), her comprehension when Vishakha speaks, knowing she is pressing all the right buttons.

Worth a watch, for regulars ..

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

In only watching bts the sequences are jumbled in my mind….but in Mannat and Vik’s confrontation on the terrace where she turns and after feeling dizzy walks away, Vik looks at his mobile then angrily throws it away……has he damaged his phone and that’s why Mannat hasn’t been able to reach him, or maybe even Shruti tried to call him?

We still have harrowing episodes to go of Shruti’s assault and murder, then Mannat’s frantic search, to finding out she’s died. Ayesha was brilliant during ARS shooting sequence, so will have very traumatic scenes yet again. Ayesha has shone in this track!

I will be brutally honest, don't believe he would have picked up the phone even if he had it on him. I mean he was dressed up within couple of hours all ready to rock and roll with his gang after kicking Mannat out of his life.

And his speech to Gagan (based on update yesterday) triggered me, how he was telling Mannat lied to him, someone needs to ask him what about his multiple lies and if Mannat forgave him . He is so full of himself 🙄

Originally posted by: Daman17

I don’t get triggered easily, but Shruti’s brutal killing scene was extremely disturbing. As far as Vik is concerned, he will suffer the consequences of his actions, and I don’t want Mannat to forgive him easily this time. Mannat dreamed of a life with him. She carried fears about her mother, which she even expressed before the terrace wedding. She gave Vik countless chances and even begged him, but he ignored everything. Despite repeated fights and even after knowing about the baby, she still chose to move forward and went to meet him, which lead to further misunderstandings between them. He deserves to suffer the most because, even if not directly, he is responsible for Shruti’s death. It is painfully poetic: with Shruti’s death, Mannat lost her own life too, and in the form of Dua, she will be reborn. Mannat was Shruti’s mannat, and Dua will now be Mannat’s mannat.

I think the brutality is about Shruti and Aish's unfinished business. When you look at it from Aish's perspective by that one act of saving Mannat Shruti destroyed the world Aish had built for herself. So the revenge had to be brutal.

I feel the brutal and graphic killing is for a reason... and like Vish has captured Aish cutting the chandelier Aish/goons might have captured Vish nearby...

In both cases one hiding themselves...

Aish and Vish both are not interested to share the Saluja wealth... I am pretty sure they are going to expose each other... question is who and when... surely not before leap

Personally I would want something to come out before leap.... 5 years is not enough... but it is more than nothing if the truth is out post leap .... Vik has to suffer for the consequences of his actions

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I will be brutally honest, don't believe he would have picked up the phone even if he had it on him. I mean he was dressed up within couple of hours all ready to rock and roll with his gang after kicking Mannat out of his life.

And his speech to Gagan (based on update yesterday) triggered me, how he was telling Mannat lied to him, someone needs to ask him what about his multiple lies and if Mannat forgave him . He is so full of himself 🙄

You see Vikrant has always had one problem. He can be given wise advise but most times it's like the advise goes past him. He hardly listened to the words Gagan said to him let alone process them. It's almost like if something doesn't fit in with his thinking or path he wants to take he almost dismisses it without thought.

When Aish's truth came out and he realised why Mannat had broken his heart he was just happy that now that matter is cleared and he can again get Mannat back into his life he never even bothered to fully understand the full story. It was i'm going to quickly divorce Malla and move on with Mannat. His original plan restored.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I think the brutality is about Shruti and Aish's unfinished business. When you look at it from Aish's perspective by that one act of saving Mannat Shruti destroyed the world Aish had built for herself. So the revenge had to be brutal.

There is a point in it, sadly 😥

But very brutal for audience at a prime time slot ..No need to show details; they can be assumed in a nuanced way if they have shown it subtly...

Originally posted by: Daman17

I don’t get triggered easily, but Shruti’s brutal killing scene was extremely disturbing. As far as Vik is concerned, he will suffer the consequences of his actions, and I don’t want Mannat to forgive him easily this time. Mannat dreamed of a life with him. She carried fears about her mother, which she even expressed before the terrace wedding. She gave Vik countless chances and even begged him, but he ignored everything. Despite repeated fights and even after knowing about the baby, she still chose to move forward and went to meet him, which lead to further misunderstandings between them. He deserves to suffer the most because, even if not directly, he is responsible for Shruti’s death. It is painfully poetic: with Shruti’s death, Mannat lost her own life too, and in the form of Dua, she will be reborn. Mannat was Shruti’s mannat, and Dua will now be Mannat’s mannat.

Considering the central role Shruti played in Mannat’s life and the horrific way her death is going to be shown it is very disturbing for a family show, all to demonstrate ARS’s the callous and cold heart.

You’ve described the significance of Shruti’s death impacting on burdening Vik with guilt so well and the writers have to be commended on if this is indeed their plan.

I do hope that choose this thoughtful and layered track to bring about Vikrant’s redemption arc in living with his guilt and bettering himself to be worthy of having some part in Mannat and his daughters life in the future. Rather that not moving much further and dragging on with the mu and endless vamp plots.

Originally posted by: Moor278

I feel the brutal and graphic killing is for a reason... and like Vish has captured Aish cutting the chandelier Aish/goons might have captured Vish nearby...

In both cases one hiding themselves...

Aish and Vish both are not interested to share the Saluja wealth... I am pretty sure they are going to expose each other... question is who and when... surely not before leap

Personally I would want something to come out before leap.... 5 years is not enough... but it is more than nothing if the truth is out post leap .... Vik has to suffer for the consequences of his actions

If he only knows afters 5 years of gloating and enjoying his life, is his pain and suffering worth after 5 years ?