Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 32 - Page 83

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Could well happen….but 5 years and stay away once he knows she’s expecting a child.

Unless after walking out he has the accident and looses his memory, I just can see once calmed down he doesn’t try to reconcile? As in OG Selim forgave his parents and reconciled with them…and Cennet once the witch was outed.

Thats the core point na Shazia...

What if he doesnt know she is pregnant... or she herself doesnt know... and if the fight is because of a CA then Mannat would be too upset to go back.

It would the usual chance encounter kind of thing where he meets the child.. forms a bond... blah blah blah...

Originally posted by: Moor278

Valid points..

Here's the counter argument

1. Mannat is not actually lying (based on what has been shown in the episodes.. not counting the green dress BTS as we dont know the context)

2. All of what she has said is validated.

3. Vik told both of them that he was wrong in misinterpreting them... in the kitchen. After that, there have been one situation where DK Mannat are in compromising positions... in his room, they edited the head caress in the hospital corridor after shooting. The only other close kind of scene was today when DK entered Mannus room without knocking and showed immense concern.

4. The hiding part is not just Mannat DK... its also RoTu.. shouldn't he ask them too???

5. Since Vik has apologized and they have clarified... plus unke mann main mail nahi hai... how would these 2 think Vik is getting affected???

The larger point is most of us are mixing BTS and the dread and judging Mannat DK while nothing untoward is part of episode.

What to trust???

very true …I’m flip flopping 😂 but I think that intentional by the writers. They are showing bts then actual episode are different and the interaction between Mannu/DK are very innocent.

Are they throwing us a red herring and will be a different twist ? HOPE so.

But in the other hand Vik is too prone to fall for it, and already has seen to doubt, even though they both explained wasn’t the case.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Ok, So we have decided it's CA and that too after marriage is what I am reading waah sone pe suhaaga . Based on this

Have a serious question after watching the new BTS of Vikrant walking in on Mannat & DK, I as a audience have no problem with the scene DK as Jhetji or just a friend and Mannat is close to him so she is taking his blessings, hugging him.

Vikrant who is unaware of the truth (yes he won't find out anything on his own, he will just consume information and I have resigned here as well 😔) keeps seeing these moments again and again with no explanation. He hasn't reacted at all so far from what I noticed. Is it human nature (not referring to Vikrant here) to finally react after seeing something n number of times, which keeps bothering, irritating you and there is no explanation of why it's happening 🤔. Considering ManVik met DK at the same time & he doesn't understand this sudden bond, Vikrant also asked about the blackout, he apologized to Mannat & DK for misunderstanding them they were hiding something (I'm no way am I defending CA , just focusing on human nature). Is it not Mannat or DK's responsibility to not give more such opportunities where Vikrant may believe they are hiding something considering they don't want the truth to ever come out? How is Vikrant to take in & process all these scenes and not react when he doesn't know what, why anything is happening?

Don't know where this scene will be placed but Mannat did see Vish recording her in that green dress with DK , or even otherwise knows Vish & Malla are dangerous and can use anything to reveal the truth. Why hand more such opportunities to them ?

Just trying to understand psychological aspect of how someone would react if they are lied to constantly, they do not understand why something is happening which is bothering them, the person they love is suddenly seen to be spending more time with someone whom they just me & they are unable to find a way out of this confusion, get any answers. How would these individuals react😬

Dil jeet liya completely Rd , well explained🥰

Exactly ,I said same in other contexts long time back..Mannat and DK are supposed to be more conscious,not to give reasons for any scope of misunderstanding when he already openly said about his misunderstanding them and apologized regarding old age home fiasco..Moreover being surrounded by witches, waiting for a right opportunity to destroy them,they need to be more vigilant..Not supporting CA but in these situations Vik isn’t wrong to think in those lines.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Thats the core point na Shazia...

What if he doesnt know she is pregnant... or she herself doesnt know... and if the fight is because of a CA then Mannat would be too upset to go back.

It would the usual chance encounter kind of thing where he meets the child.. forms a bond... blah blah blah...

But Manu would know she is within a few weeks/months…..would she deny her child that right? And deny Vik his child too knowing what he’s said about children….

Struggling with both staying apart for so long…if leap was 6moths or year etc it’s feasible…

Memory loss is the only logical thing for me.

I can understand Vikrant misunderstanding Dhairya's intentions, but I can't accept his suspecting Mannat.

Of course he needs an explanation as to why Mannat is suddenly close to DK and they need to think too.

Vikrant doesn't know Dhairya is spending time with them because of him and not Mannat.

But Mannat I can also say is supremely confident about Vikrant. She was confident even during the wedding that he does not love Malla. She knows he loves her. Unfortunately, his tendency to react irrationally always lets her faith down.

Now even if he questions DK calmly, without reacting, are they in a position to tell him the truth??

Originally posted by: Moor278

Valid points..

Here's the counter argument

1. Mannat is not actually lying (based on what has been shown in the episodes.. not counting the green dress BTS as we dont know the context)

2. All of what she has said is validated.

3. Vik told both of them that he was wrong in misinterpreting them... in the kitchen. After that, there have been one situation where DK Mannat are in compromising positions... in his room, they edited the head caress in the hospital corridor after shooting. The only other close kind of scene was today when DK entered Mannus room without knocking and showed immense concern.

4. The hiding part is not just Mannat DK... its also RoTu.. shouldn't he ask them too???

5. Since Vik has apologized and they have clarified... plus unke mann main mail nahi hai... how would these 2 think Vik is getting affected???

The larger point is most of us are mixing BTS and the dread and judging Mannat DK while nothing untoward is part of episode.

What to trust???

Mera post was based off of BTS hee hain since CA hasn't happened yet

I didn't bring RoTu in the equation since we were discussing CA🙈

Point 5, exactly Vikrant apologized, meaning his train of thoughts went in that direction so he felt guilty and apologized. Now, when he keeps seeing these instances wouldn't it even occur to them what might Vikrant think considering he already apologized once 🤔. (Want to highlight I never seen a man woman relationship in one track ) ? Wouldn't they wonder how Vikrant would perceive this sudden bond between them when ManVik met DK at the same time and they along with RoTu are involved in a truth truth game? Wouldn't it occur to them how he may perceive seeing Mannat hug someone whom they just met and she calls him Sir 🤔 ?

The reason I am thinking in this direction is Vikrant is getting all this information without a Dictionary or glossary. How is he to process all this information? If he just sees all these and not react would that make him a great bf or husband? If he asks them what is happening, will they tell the truth?

Originally posted by: scarlett22

I can understand Vikrant misunderstanding Dhairya's intentions, but I can't accept his suspecting Mannat.

Of course he needs an explanation as to why Mannat is suddenly close to DK and they need to think too.

Vikrant doesn't know Dhairya is spending time with them because of him and not Mannat.

But Mannat I can also say is supremely confident about Vikrant. She was confident even during the wedding that he does not love Malla. She knows he loves her. Unfortunately, his tendency to react irrationally always lets her faith down.

Now even if he questions DK calmly, without reacting, are they in a position to tell him the truth??

Agree Scar and well said bold

I am trying to understand how is Vikrant supposed to react or not react with everything he is seeing and this sudden close bond between Mannat and DK whom they just met.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Agree Scar and well said bold

I am trying to understand how is Vikrant supposed to react or not react with everything he is seeing and this sudden close bond between Mannat and DK whom they just met.

Even i had that same thought Rd ..

Actually i was trying to put myself in his shoes and was trying to think how would i feel if i see my hubby suddenly spending more time or in weird positions with another woman who we just met

But then really Hope makers don’t ruin Vikrant .. they can have him doubt but not voice it maybe ?

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Could well happen….but 5 years and stay away once he knows she’s expecting a child.

Unless after walking out he has the accident and looses his memory, I just can see once calmed down he doesn’t try to reconcile? As in OG Selim forgave his parents and reconciled with them…and Cennet once the witch was outed.

5 years is too much honestly for whatever Maybe the reason and they have been through worst. I can't stop myself from thinking how will Vikrant live without Mannat 😭 whereas Mannat will have the baby so she has a reason to be strong

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Mera post was based off of BTS hee hain since CA hasn't happened yet

I didn't bring RoTu in the equation since we were discussing CA🙈

Point 5, exactly Vikrant apologized, meaning his train of thoughts went in that direction so he felt guilty and apologized. Now, when he keeps seeing these instances wouldn't it even occur to them what might Vikrant think considering he already apologized once 🤔. (Want to highlight I never seen a man woman relationship in one track ) ? Wouldn't they wonder how Vikrant would perceive this sudden bond between them when ManVik met DK at the same time and they along with RoTu are involved in a truth truth game? Wouldn't it occur to them how he may perceive seeing Mannat hug someone whom they just met and she calls him Sir 🤔 ?

The reason I am thinking in this direction is Vikrant is getting all this information without a Dictionary or glossary. How is he to process all this information? If he just sees all these and not react would that make him a great bf or husband? If he asks them what is happening, will they tell the truth?

Understood.... but does that mean Mannat is having an affair???? isnt it too far fetched????

I agree with Scar and I have been saying this since the beginning... I can understand Vik suspecting DK... I dont agree on him suspecting Mannat... after all that they have been through...

Let him think she is an innocent and naive girl who doesnt understand DK is trying to trap her

bold... last I checked... he is a grown man of 30+ years... a reputed businessman... he should have the understanding to balance and listen to both sides.. something he has promised Mannat he will do