Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 31 - Page 91

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

https://youtu.be/Q5sXV2Dy0WA?si=7ldjTAikf1Vt6-qg

See this guys

Naa rye ek toh this is IF update without video and then it says nurse comes running and informs she is dead . Tab toh pakka she has bribed the nurse and escaped if IF got it right this time.

Originally posted by: Moor278

I do understand if DK and Mannat come to a consensus that he shouldnt be told.... dono ne bade dhoke khaaye hai ... considering how much they love Vikku unka chupana banta hai ... let Princess Ana live in his fairyland... jo pyar karte hai vo to saath hai hi

But he will feel betrayed right? When this truth will come out eventually 😭.

Understandable that they don't want to tell him. But it's not about love ,it's about truth and they both know how hurtful it can be. The longer they hide , it will be more devastating for that kid and he will be more angry at them for not telling him sooner when they all know it 😭

I feel they should just tell him and let him decide 🤞.

Because as such Bobby 2, Vish and ARS all will do anything to present their twisted versions in front of him🤬

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Really I was thinking the same, how is it survived ? 🤮🤢 not a surprise it might have happened malfunction and editor's cut..🤮

Stylist really believes she is creating a masterpiece, but she should come here and read she is creating crass . This one was so bad and looks like a bra (without top) & when Mannat was pushing her I got scared 🤐

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

https://youtu.be/Q5sXV2Dy0WA?si=7ldjTAikf1Vt6-qg

See this guys

This would be awesome if its fake death. Reclaiming her power when she is operating from the shadows and Manvik not seeing her coming would work to her advantage.

Originally posted by: truptishree

But he will feel betrayed right? When this truth will come out eventually 😭.

Understandable that they don't want to tell him. But it's not about love ,it's about truth and they both know how hurtful it can be. The longer they hide , it will be more devastating for that kid and he will be more angry at them for not telling him sooner when they all know it 😭

I feel they should just tell him and let him decide 🤞.

Because as such Bobby 2, Vish and ARS all will do anything to present their twisted versions in front of him🤬

It was never Mannat's truth to decide if it should be told or not to be told and I don't even want her to be the one telling this to Vikrant. Till now Mannat was asking for time due to Vikrant's panic attacks and wanted to cushion him before revealing the truth. I wish she sticks to this plan🤞.

She should advocate for RoTu or DK to reveal the truth in a calm way. Even DK has no say in this since he was the one who came into their lives and now it's all jumbled, he cannot back away now. Vikrant will feel betrayed and he will be absolutely right in feeling so if they all hide the truth from him and he eventually finds out from Vishakha or ARS or 🤢 tells him.

How are they going to stop all the 3 from reveal the truth, by threatening them jail

Originally posted by: truptishree

But he will feel betrayed right? When this truth will come out eventually 😭.

Understandable that they don't want to tell him. But it's not about love ,it's about truth and they both know how hurtful it can be. The longer they hide , it will be more devastating for that kid and he will be more angry at them for not telling him sooner when they all know it 😭

I feel they should just tell him and let him decide 🤞.

Because as such Bobby 2, Vish and ARS all will do anything to present their twisted versions in front of him🤬

RD/Trupti

oh of course it’s not their right to withhold this information, if they do it’s to protect Vik from information that will lead to further physiological damage and of no benefit (remember the hang ups he had when he felt Mannu sold his love for money). But completely agree not to tell also will lead to all the betrayal issues and damage as you’ve said too, let alone the vultures waiting for the opportunity to use for their own benefit. It’s not their truth to tell, but they are the two with 1st hand experience to know how it feels and perhaps whether and how they would have wanted to find out.

But Trupti….once he’s been told Vish sold him for money, that can’t be undone….so nothing left for him to decide….

other than not having anything to do with Vish and acknowledge RoTu’s innocent and love…….i’m flip flopping I know ☺️

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

RD/Trupti

oh of course it’s not their right to withhold this information, if they do it’s to protect Vik from information that will lead to further physiological damage and of no benefit (remember the hang ups he had when he felt Mannu sold his love for money). But completely agree not to tell also will lead to all the betrayal issues and damage as you’ve said too, let alone the vultures waiting for the opportunity to use for their own benefit. It’s not their truth to tell, but they are the two with 1st hand experience to know how it feels and perhaps whether and how they would have wanted to find out.

But Trupti….once he’s been told Vish sold him for money, that can’t be undone….so nothing left for him to decide….

other than not having anything to do with Vish and acknowledge RoTu’s innocent and love…….i’m flip flopping I know ☺️

You know @Shazia @moor it's very difficult to call out right or wrong in this situation considering Vikrant was sold for money and RoTu bought him 🤬.

Not sure if I can compare Mannat's situation with Vikrant, but considering Vikrant, his mentality this might turn out worse for him than how Mannat how bravely she embraced the truth though we (I was atleast) were surprised she didn't have a mental breakdown 😭

I kind of agree if they decide to let it be and not tell the worst truth of his life about his mother selling him for Money. But, long term if they or infact Mannat can think about it she would agree Shurti should have told her when she saw ARS , which only led to so many misunderstandings, trauma and Shurti almost dead. What if he starts getting his flashbacks or panic attacks again, then what ? Mannat even pointed out to Neetu yesterday about drugging and that was wrong. What is there plan then?

I would prefer if they still stick to the plan of telling the truth but with a doctors advice so it won't effect him mentally due to the blackouts he is been having.

I am still not too attached to DK as a character due to his pendulum behavior, but Mannat & Vikrant have a uphill task and they better stick together to survive this emotional upheaval ❣️.

Ok, so the solution to getting frustrated with this show is to go on a break. and come back with renewed love and forgiveness ()

I quite liked today's episode.

- I liked Mannat clearly telling Neetu not to do stupid things like drugging Vikku. Neetu had forgotten it, looks like. but am not happy about Mannat accepting it as love! . If nothing else, Vikrant would be extremely angry if she supports this by default, after having thrown a huge puski bomb before about Neetu giving him meds.

- She also told her, in a matter of fact way, not to try slashing her wrists all the time!!

- Vrudhashram plan by Shruti. Did anyone not notice Shruti is the second person apart from Vikrant who is going about life as usual??

- Vishakha threatens Rotu and Mannat walks in ,saying they will tell Vikrant the truth. She calls Dhairya and they have an argument about speaking rudely to Vishakha.

- It's a tense scene when Vikrant walks in. And what a superb portrayal by Adnan as he looks at everyone turn by turn, reacts to each one as they lie to him. He has a different expression for Mannat, Rotu, Dhairya . He has understood something is going on.

- Scene with Neetu and Vikrant. It is clear Neetu is terrified and it is also comforting that she truly loves Vikrant, was willing to give away everything to Vishakha. Why can't they just add a little bit of depression or paranoia or even PTSD (from losing her own son) to make her earlier stunt a little palatable??

- Scene in Vikrant's room when Mannat leaves for the Ashram.

- Vikrant notices Mannat leaving with Dhairya and wonders about her lie. Though she didn't lie, Dhairya was also going to the Ashram and offered to take them along

- Malla and ARS - Like I think @moor mentioned, ARS and Mannat are slowly facing each other in this tussle of Vikrant's truth. ARS tells Malla to convince Vishakha to tell the truth herself.

- And Malla convinces Vishakha. FFed the scene not before noticing Malla calls Vishakha 'Vish Aunty' (Poison Aunty??) Good touch

Originally posted by: Rdigest

You know @Shazia @moor it's very difficult to call out right or wrong in this situation considering Vikrant was sold for money and RoTu bought him 🤬.

Not sure if I can compare Mannat's situation with Vikrant, but considering Vikrant, his mentality this might turn out worse for him than how Mannat how bravely she embraced the truth though we (I was atleast) were surprised she didn't have a mental breakdown 😭

I kind of agree if they decide to let it be and not tell the worst truth of his life about his mother selling him for Money. But, long term if they or infact Mannat can think about it she would agree Shurti should have told her when she saw ARS , which only led to so many misunderstandings, trauma and Shurti almost dead. What if he starts getting his flashbacks or panic attacks again, then what ? Mannat even pointed out to Neetu yesterday about drugging and that was wrong. What is there plan then?

I would prefer if they still stick to the plan of telling the truth but with a doctors advice so it won't effect him mentally due to the blackouts he is been having.

I am still not too attached to DK as a character due to his pendulum behavior, but Mannat & Vikrant have a uphill task and they better stick together to survive this emotional upheaval ❣️.

so well articulated ❣️

It is an emotional volcano waiting to erupt I agree, and in the real world better to open past memories and trauma with Psychiatric help and advice. In fact Neetu needs help too! Certainly there’s an uphill struggle to try to manage the situation given too many 🔪🐍 and then cope with the aftermath too for Mannu as it’s her intended life partner, the others are all just interested/interferring bystanders.

I've decided I am like Shruti, still waiting for the wedding.

I think the terrace, outhouse are all infested, everyone comes there to do whatever required, crowded places now.

Now I want Mannat and Vikrant in his room, as lawfully wedded, fighting, holding collar, sulking, whatever.