Why Smriti was so direct? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Caesie

Hey guys don't get angry.Sharad is a very good actor and a dancer.He is doing good job in BMTD and also did good in YHJ.His team was disqualified coz he was not there.Obviosly " Sharad and Toofani toli" was incomplete without Sharad thats why they are disqualified.No matters whatever is the reason.For example my sis had 102 F fever still she attended her board exams and had she not attended her exams she would have failed.Noone would have considered that she was ill.Its jst like that.I also felt a bad for him.But dont be angry with the hosts.Sakshi never said a single word against Sharad.She is the most kindhearted actor i have ever known on Indian Television.She also said earlier that she feels bad when any contestant recieve a bad comment.And as a host she could not favour a contestant.Its the duty of host and i am proud of Sakshi she is doing her duty well. 👏 👏 👏
Still Toofani Toli did good job and got second highest marks when they were not disqualified then also Hussain would have made to Finals coz his teams score was highest.So be Happy that his team performed so well and he proved that Sharad is a good mentor. 👏

Dear. Its not about being angry. And Sakshi is all good. But Smriti is and "was" quite patronising. On camera , she shouldn't have commented so. And if she meant all other people in backstage, why was camera zoomed to Sharad only? And like that?

If it was not meant for him, the director/ producer/editor should have edited that bit. Its not good to see an actor getting heat from other actors like this.

And if Ronit's opponent's comments were discussed like this on camera, why not Sharad's?

Originally posted by: maha_prakrti

There are favorites in any show and every show.... Lekin sides lene ki baat nahi hai, because they don't decide who wins!

Smriti said this yes, even I didn't like the indirect accusation.... But one thing we have to note is, they didn't point out Sharad... Clearly Smriti said people in backstage also have said to her that!

As for the comments again Ronit... Smriti and Ronit did say that the people who talked in th VT had spoken to them very nicely backstage and had praised his work... So not only him even when I heard it I thought how could any one be so rude on face commenting! I even felt this for Sharad, during his VT... So guess that doesn't account here at all!

As for on particular point here.... Smriti or Saakshi or Ravi as you said are not trained dancers and that's what gives them the full rights to comment on the dances in YHJ, because it is a public voted show... So obviously not everyone in public is going to know dance, not even ABC of it... So they are fresh eyes that trained eyes which are seeing the dances and clearly they can give good comments on it.... Because more than of technicality the spirit, the energy, the unity, and all is what is seen here....

Point to note I am saying nothing about Sharad here

This show is purely about dancing and star's popularity attached to it. Now if Smriti, Rabi kishen comments about someone continuously that " they didn't understand the theme" then the common people you are talking about will get confused easily. So after 3 episodes like that Sharad was out! Otherwise he was always above Ronit, Rohit or even Prachi. He is extremely popular and someone outside Balaji camp.

So dear"Tulsi" and Bhojpuri Rabi can and are able to influence people through their so called laddoos and comments. I think fair judging would have been fair than these non dancer pseudo-judges.

I hope I could make some point here.
What pains me more is , its not that I am all crazy for Sharad ( well I am not ) but I can see the crude comments he received. He kept mum, he is a nice boy. But why?

Ronit is equally popular if not more than Sharad which is why he has reached the finals. Ronit was on the top for 8 weeks straight. Smriti is definitely not being partial to Ronit. She asked Ronit, he answered.

Originally posted by: strangerz

i felt smiriti was rude 2 sharad 4 no reason, it was even in the news that he was injred; lets c her dance with an injury 😡

u r speaking of dance wid injury🤣🤣🤣. first let her dance normally

Originally posted by: tulasi99

u r speaking of dance wid injury🤣🤣🤣. first let her dance normally

You couldn't have said better!! 😆

Originally posted by: tulasi99

u r speaking of dance wid injury🤣🤣🤣. first let her dance normally

I think we are going out of the topic here...😕

U_Princess... I agree to what you said.. Everything.... But please don't bring in Balaji and their shows in this, which has nothing to do here... If Balaji is famous and their actors are famous and more reached to the audience then what is their effect on this show... That was way before YHJ... Why Sharad is not like not popular and all.. he is equally popular in or not in Balaji.... He is also known very well in public and he stayed almost till end right?

As for dancing and themes.... I accept what the judges say, non-dancers pseudo-judges they may be, but the audiences are also so... The only thing was much much more was expected from Sharad's team because his team consisted of instructors..... Maybe he is not a dancer, but he had five dancers actually dance teachers with him... So expectations from him was more that other teams and in some cases the judges felt with such a strong team he and his team could have done better.... Why what they did in wild card got praises right? That they expected in all the rounds that's it... Now what's wrong in that?

As for influence, please... Public are not so fool, like Ronit said, considering I am in public too, that they get easily influenced by judges comments.... People who see these kinds of shows must more than majority be educated, may be not high, but at least know what is right and wrong! So they cannot be influenced so very easily as moulding wet mud

Originally posted by: maha_prakrti

I think we are going out of the topic here...😕

U_Princess... I agree to what you said.. Everything.... But please don't bring in Balaji and their shows in this, which has nothing to do here... If Balaji is famous and their actors are famous and more reached to the audience then what is their effect on this show... That was way before YHJ... Why Sharad is not like not popular and all.. he is equally popular in or not in Balaji.... He is also known very well in public and he stayed almost till end right?

As for dancing and themes.... I accept what the judges say, non-dancers pseudo-judges they may be, but the audiences are also so... The only thing was much much more was expected from Sharad's team because his team consisted of instructors..... Maybe he is not a dancer, but he had five dancers actually dance teachers with him... So expectations from him was more that other teams and in some cases the judges felt with such a strong team he and his team could have done better.... Why what they did in wild card got praises right? That they expected in all the rounds that's it... Now what's wrong in that?

As for influence, please... Public are not so fool, like Ronit said, considering I am in public too, that they get easily influenced by judges comments.... People who see these kinds of shows must more than majority be educated, may be not high, but at least know what is right and wrong! So they cannot be influenced so very easily as moulding wet mud

I agree with you. Balaji part was not an accusation. Rather I was thinking aloud I think. As you say, public are not fool; true. Their theme's weakness; true but also it might have been the case of, " too many cooks spoils the broth".

I don't have any problem with anything, other than SI's rudeness.

😉do read my further reading into these characters : http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=964832&T PN=1&#16737355

Ronit acts 'a bit too good' to believe! it's one of those people who act so overly sweet that itz shady. 😕

***The words and actions of both brothers Ronit &Rohit today quite revealed their cunning side to me. Rohit came up (had planned it) and said his comments that "an artist negatively commenting on another artist isnt a true artist and that he's speaking because his brother Ronit will never say anything" <---and frankly, all this Rohit said was BALONI...reason being is Ronit DID speak back then that "angoor hai nahi toh khatte kya honge" (that shows his true side and arrogance over the fake "diplomatic" nice way he shows of handling criticism) and even today he said, " i wont mince words (but he really does in reality!), never have and i'm here you're not etc..." Ronit's face was to be seen when the comments were being shown previous week as he couldnt even help keeping the artificial smile face he shows (which is very apparent to me now) and had a very disgusted mean face (he wasnt aware of it of course😆). Now, the fact that Ronit is competing here he cannot afford to respond back to that girl in audience but his brother Rohit came on stage (had planned it ahead) n did it instead, and very rudely at that!! It was smart of Ronit to not take that risk and even later Rohit apologizes at the end (fake act so it doesnt affect his brothers chances of winning) when infact both said what they wanted to and still came out looking like Saintly nice on top! They both can really run for politics! 👏