Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

3.9k

Users

22

Likes

276

Frequent Posters

AnjuRish thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6

Team Ruhi (Gen 4)

Posted: 7 months ago
#11

I agree that such scenes could be avoided and it's very triggering..I have fam members who are doc ..they have spend years in studying to be der and the profession needs time dedication and lot of effort.. don't disrespect them

I fwd the scene since i dislike the jagga jassos or mahan bhashan scenes

Mehersudha thumbnail
Republic Rhythms Aazadi Quest Volunteer Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7

YRKKH Fans

Posted: 7 months ago
#12

I don't understand one thing. Whatever the story is given us by writers.When we like any character personally it's the character and artist ex abheera is best Sam is the best. When we don't like any character ex ruhi. Ruhi is lusty ruhi is hawasi amd mock garvita badly. So it's all in people perspective when favorite is not shown as per their happiness then it's writers fault. Is it not called hypocrisy

shahsb_26 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 months ago
#13

What the hell is wrong with Abhira, what the hell is wrong with writers, directors and executives...

This death sequence has to be lamest one... smiley36Rishta be like... kaun mehnat karna hai... Next week se nacch gaana hi karna hai ..

But there was no seriousness at all.... It was comedy and this scene in particular was just random stitching of dialogues but accusing doctors of being reckless is stupidest thing for anyone to do...

Edited by shahsb_26 - 7 months ago
janecastle thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7

Team AkshNav (Gen 3)

Posted: 7 months ago
#14

That scene was unnecessarily rude. Something was off about ABHIRA's behavior the entire episode. Whoever is writing this nautanki is off their rockers. And Sam needs to bring in some softness in her acting. May be it is the result of bad writing, bad dialogues and bad direction. There's only so much one can take.

Kaveri being sad for Shivani though was reminiscent of ABHIRA's changing spelling. Even girgit don't change colors as fast as Kaveri Poddar and few others.

DiamondLife thumbnail
Posted: 7 months ago
#15

The dialogue writer is very bad....

Doctors were doing their duty...Itna severe burns hai to they cannot save the patient..

The lines female lead is speaking to doctor is not relevant here. It does not make sense ...Doctor politely asked if not possible then hospital is ready to help in last rights.

DiamondLife thumbnail
Posted: 7 months ago
#16

Originally posted by: Mehersudha

I don't understand one thing. Whatever the story is given us by writers.When we like any character personally it's the character and artist ex abheera is best Sam is the best. When we don't like any character ex ruhi. Ruhi is lusty ruhi is hawasi amd mock garvita badly. So it's all in people perspective when favorite is not shown as per their happiness then it's writers fault. Is it not called hypocrisy

This is the difference we saw in season 3. The script was bad...despite that Harshad with his acting talent created a loving place in the viewers heart and won many awards. The entire team in their ego destroyed the story.

Here, Sam cannot give that depth emotions in her acting..this is not the only scene...many areas she needs to improve a lot. Her acting comes across very superficial. I cannot connect with this character Abeera because she is all over ..there is no core of her character. Abheera comes across very selfish person..she applies the rules and others and gives bhashan but when the same comes to her, she does not want to follow. This character is written very poor and uper se Sam acting is making it worse..

Edited by DiamondLife - 7 months ago
DiamondLife thumbnail
Posted: 7 months ago
#17

Originally posted by: MsWhiskerson

It is not character, it is the actor who ruined this scene.

Same scene and same dialogues with a different body language would work -


Abhira was supposed to be shocked and devastated instead Sam played it like she was fighting a battle

She is saying dialogues as if she is disappointed that she missed the train, there's no pain of losing someone she loved

Usko upma banake tease karne ki padi hai

seriously smiley18

There should be some mature dialogues like...maa se abhi abhi to jude hai...woh saare saal hamein jeene hai and yaadein banani hai...maa ne apni zindagi mein koi khusiyan nahin dekhi...abhi to muskurahat wapis ayi thi....something like that ...

ShadowImbue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 7 months ago
#18

TBH even the rudeness and blaming doctor didn't come across genuine or impactful. The performance was soo bad. Abhira should've emotional breakdown instead of blabbering about "mummy wasn't a random patient". It appeared she cared more about how doctor treated mummy than the news that mummy died. Dialogue writer, actor, director everyone deserves a round of applause for this masterpiece.

ShadowImbue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 7 months ago
#19

Originally posted by: DiamondLife

This is the difference we saw in season 3. The script was bad...despite that Harshad with his acting talent created a loving place in the viewers heart and won many awards. The entire team in their ego destroyed the story.

Here, Sam cannot give that depth emotions in her acting..this is not the only scene...many areas she needs to improve a lot. Her acting comes across very superficial. I cannot connect with this character Abeera because she is all over ..there is no core of her character. Abheera comes across very selfish person..she applies the rules and others and gives bhashan but when the same comes to her, she does not want to follow. This character is written very poor and uper se Sam acting is making it worse..

Disagreed. HC also gave few bad performances in Gen 3. He was exceptionally good in Tere Liye and Kis Des.

ThukkadRajaShah thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail 1st Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 7 months ago
#20

Originally posted by: Khanmiss

I agree with you that scene looked rude. But that is not the character's problem yaar. It is the writer's problem she is continuously degrading abhira. Because the writer doesn't like abhira. I know many ppl don't accept it. But look at the way they are portraying abhira . Does she ever get fl wale looks. Just recently she has started looking normal. Otherwise she looked like Dora the explora. And do they ever show her feelings , pain. Acc to the writer ruhi is the fl. She has always got all the attention. Whatever small problems she faces they highlight. And abhira who suffered so much they don't show anything about it. Even in bsp track . They just showed her running away with the baby. The never want to show abhira right. And they didn't do this to any other fl. I don't know how many agree but Akshu . She was so wrong at times but still they victimized her. She was so wrong that she didn't wait for the police and went ahead with Neil. Even then after leap so gave so many lectures to abhimanyu. The writer never showed her wrong . But she is consistently showing abhira wrong. She didn't even do anything wrong as such. But the writer clearly doesn't like abhira.

All the tracks which were abhira centric have only ruhi and vidya in the middle.

And Identity reveal which was abhira 's main track was shown in the worst possible way .

Likewise every other character too is the creation of writers and makers , not just abheera. No character is for real , whole yrrkh universe is fictional. So what's the point of criticizing other characters while abheera's disgusting acts are passed off as writer's will.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira · 3 months ago

Ruhi 6 year old or Maira 6 year old. If you want you can share your opinion. let me share mine. After yrkkh3 leap, Ruhi was one of the reason I...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".