killing bhavishya was WRONG

rainabow thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
on every level it was wrong.

yes he is a wicked person and needs to pay for his crimes. but at the same time it's easy to forget that he is mentally unstable and should have been treated for it years ago. the fact that he wasn't can only be attributed to dharaben. if anyone should be up in flames, it's her...but even that i wouldn't agree with. i don't feel sorry or think he should bear no responsibility for what he has done, but this isn't the way to go.

saraswati knows what it is like to be burned alive. it's unimaginable pain and trauma that never fades. her sisters and her mother were also aware of her suffering and her long road to recovery. to me it is inexcusable that they would induce that same pain and suffering on another person NO MATTER HOW WICKED HE IS. rather than do that, they should prove to bhav that they are above his repulsive and psychotic behavior. they should show him what civilized people do in such a situation. even if they did have to kill him, it could have been done in a much less barbaric manner.

saraswati has been through a lot at a young age, but it doesn't give her the right to decide who lives and who dies, and how they live and die.

no one seems to be going after the true culprits here. i don't understand this phenomenon. is everyone at every institution across india totally corrupt? i mean kajri manages to escape prison every time by flirting with the guards, and now bhav just pays an asylum worker off to get released. make an example out of that worker and do it so that no other employee ever dare repeat that mistake.

don't underestimate the punishment that he could have had. reflecting on his pathetic life in an asylum, receiving shock treatments and living among other crazy people until the day he dies is no small punishment. i think it would have been more fitting and civilized.

Created

Last reply

Replies

76

Views

7k

Users

27

Frequent Posters

shalini4frenz thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
i dont agree with u.... it was the right or i shuld say the best puishment he shuld get... he burnt saraswati too... wht do u say abt tht???

he should also knw how being burnt is like..if they jus left him in a mental asylum or anywhere else then it would have been ridiculous...

people who torture others should be given the worse treatment ever...u knw as they say it... jo jaise karega, voh aisa bhugtega...somethin like tht... he got the same thing he did to saraswati

i support the gals.. and they are right.. u should never underestimate gals... gal power...
brenda88 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
I also dont agree with you. To me, i think if they would have taken bhav to the justice?
they would send him back to the mental hospital and that was what happened before rite???
Wouldnt he come back?
I guess he would have...
It is him who doesnt want to get cured, although he is mental and all that, why must he punish durga and innocent person?
What did she do???
It wasnt her faualt at all....
DivyaD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Ok, I also do not agree that they should have taken matters into their own hands as it is wrong - the most unjust part is still to come as I am almost certain that Saras will probably be arrested for burning Bhavishya.

Each and every step he has taken has been to harass the sisters and the family. He chose the worst way possible to get his revenge which was to slowly kill Durga. I am not saying that he deserved what he got at the hands of the women, but nor am I saying that this was the way to deal with it.

On one level I am happy that he got what he did because this way gave all the ladies satisfaction as they have each been terrorised by him. But, maybe scare him a bit with the oil, etc but burn him to death... no...🤢 The ladies are at the end of the day soft hearted woman and I would have thought that they would never have come this far in exacting revenge. This was actually scary watching all of them so bent on murdering him...

Maybe he is not dead yet... we still have to see that hmmm? (Well I hope so... then we can see him going to jail) ... and probably escaping yet again! 😡

A plan to get back at him, expose him and and all that is one thing... but murdering him in cold blood, and in that way too! I cannot accept that...

sanw thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
Bhavishya needs a strict punishment for all that he has done
till now we havent seen him being killed although he is trapped in fire
prbably the family hands him to the police
Mizzme thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
Bhavishya needs a strict punishment for all that he has done
till now we havent seen him being killed although he is trapped in fire
prbably the family hands him to the police
yh even if he is sent to prison he will find another way out just like he when was in the asylum
CarulinaTina thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
Yes, he needed strict punishment. But is that enough reason to take law into your own hands?! Law definitely makes mistakes and the wrong people walk free, but taking another human being's life is completely wrong.

They killed and murdered him mercilessly and then just stood there and watched him burn? Sorry, but I don't find anyway to justify that. And on top of that, Saraswati and all the rest said that this was a lesson for all the men who abuse their husbands, and all the women who are abused.

This is probably the worst message that ever could be passed on television. Is that what they are trying to teach us? There are so many abused women in India, and Betiyaan is a very popular show. If they all follow this then all the abused women will begin to burn their husbands to get justice w/o going thru legal channels.

So far they have portrayed the betiyaan as humane and civilized, but I saw the exact opposite yesterday. They tried acting like devis, but to me they seemed like barbarians.

Like rainabow rightly said, Saras KNOWS how it is to be burned alive... how can she just sit and watch as another human being goes thru the same pain?! They could have easily trapped him, exposed him for who he really is in front of the family, and then sent him to the mental asylum jail. Yea, he's bound to come out again... but thats the sad part of our legal system, yet this is much more civilized and humane to get justice.

In all other shows the heroine always is abt to murder the villan, but stops because she doesn't want to stoop to his level. But that EXACTLY what Saras did. She stooped to a mentally unstable man's level, and burned him alive.

Pathetic.
Edited by *Kruthi* - 17 years ago
187176 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8
I think if i was writer etc i would have done it so the first time it went to court they won the case and he went to jail/assylum and that is the end! Shows it realisticly and no need to re run story..however now because hes managed to escape guess this was best way to end the track but murder is not right 😕
mainkaun thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
No Sars did not stoop as same level as Bhav- This is classic case of DOMESTIC VIOLATION- and all she did was self defence
If you talk about law- this would not count as a murder - lets call it as an encounter (the way police does) - lets be real ppl like him do exists in real world and the only way to get rid of them is encounter. some time taking law in hands is necessary - u have no option left - how many lives he has been playing with?

is everyone at every institution across india totally corrupt? -- in most of places yes - do we need proof, come on look around in India.

Sars should/will not get arrested - it counts as self defence

If he is not dead then (if I were sars) I would make sure he is dead
CarulinaTina thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

In what way was what she did 'self defense'? It was basic premeditated murder. It was planned out that they would lure him to the mandir, and then burn him alive. It would only be counted as self defense if he had lured them somewhere and was just abt to kill them, so they had to burn him alive to save themselves. But that was NOT the case here, so it does NOT count as self defense.

Yes, I agree... sadly our law is quite corrupt. But burning a man alive?! After the SAME thing has been done to you? That is stooping to his level and causing him the same pain that she felt. It didn't seem civilized to me at all, and the entire sitn could have been handled much more humanely if they had just turned him in.

Abt such criminals being murdered in an encounter when it gets that drastic, that is only done by the police... not by normal civilians. If normal people start taking law into their hands, then there would be no law and justice in the country. There wouldn't even be a need for the law anymore. People would just go around murdering who ever has done wrong to them. Our corrupt legal system has let many murderers walk free, but that doesnt give us the power to take law into our hands. I completely disagree with what they've done.

Edited by *Kruthi* - 17 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".