Indian Idol 14 - Performance Discussion (9&10 Dec'23) - Page 3

Raj Babbar Special

Piyush was amazing as always. He is my favourite make singer this season.❤️ His rendition of "Hothon Se Chhu Lo Tum" was absolutely phenomenal.😍

Utkarsh gave his best and his performance was amazing.👏🏻

I do not have much to say about Anjana. The judges are unnecessarily biased towards her. Imho, she kills the essence of every song she sings. I just can’t with her.😒

Ananya’s tribute to Smita Patil ji was so heartfelt. Raj Babbar ji was so emotional and I teared up too. Such a beautiful performance and the gift she received from Babbar saab was precious and invaluable.🥹

After a long time I really loved Adya’s performance. She sung it really well.🤩 Salma Agha's performance of "Dil Ke Armaan" was so soulful.😍

Subhadeep was okay. It was a disappointing performance knowing his caliber. I liked "Dushman Na Kare" in his voice though.🙂

Mukesh Special

My mom is a huge Mukesh fan so it was treat to watch this episode with my mum. So nice to see Nitin Mukesh ji after so much time.❤️

Muskaan was good. Her second song "Woh Chand Khila" was so nice and she's so lucky to get an opportunity to duet with Nitin ji.👏🏻

Dipan's rendition of "Kabhi Kabhi" was okay but "Sawan Ka Mahina" was better. It was not his strongest performance.

"Kahin Door" is my favorite Mukesh song also because it's filmed on Rajesh Khanna ji who is one of my favorite stars from yester years so it was very difficult for me to disconnect the original song to the one sung by Mahima. Also, "Pal Do Pal" is an iconic song. This performance was a miss for me.😐

But the part Nitin ji sang was just so emotional. The pride with which he sang his father's song was all heart.❤️

Obom and Vaibhav, both are good singers but today was just not their day. Their style of music is completely different from that of Mukesh ji.

"Ek Pyaar Ka Nagma" was my granny's favourite song and I just couldn't take Menuka's singing. It was her weakest performance till date. This song is too iconic for me to disconnect it from Lata ji and Mukesh ji's voice.💔

Surender's performance was good, but he literally sang only 2 lines.😐

The duet between Nitin ji and Kumar Sanu of "Suhani Chandni Raaten" was so heartwarming.🥹😍

Shreya and Nitin ji's performance was so beautiful. "Dil Ki Nazar Se" is one of my favorite songs.❤️

Out of the bottom three, I felt Surender is the weakest so I guess the elimination was fair.

I'm looking forward to next week's episode of Pardes' silver jubilee celebration with Subhash Ghai and Mahima Chaudhry. I wish SRK would have joined them too.😍

My post from yesterday got erased. So I will repost again:

For me, Muskaan & Mahima were superb and excellent! Though Menuka's version of "Ek Pyaar Ka Nagma" was fast at times (it is a slow song), I still thought it was decent.

I don't agree with Surender's elimination, but what can I do?!

The duet between Nitin ji and Kumar Sanu of "Suhani Chandni Raaten" was so beautiful.🥹😍

Shreya and Nitin ji's performance of "Dil Ki Nazar Se" was amazing as well.❤️

Looking forward to next week's episode.

Originally posted by: A HUGE FAN

My post from yesterday got erased. So I will repost again:

For me, Muskaan & Mahima were superb and excellent! Though Menuka's version of "Ek Pyaar Ka Nagma" was fast at times (it is a slow song), I still thought it was decent.

I don't agree with Surender's elimination, but what can I do?!

The duet between Nitin ji and Kumar Sanu of "Suhani Chandni Raaten" was so beautiful.🥹😍

Shreya and Nitin ji's performance of "Dil Ki Nazar Se" was amazing as well.❤️

Looking forward to next week's episode.

Same here from Sunday episode absolutely loved Muskaan and Mahima. I was looking forward for Menuka’s ek pyaar ka nagma because it’s one of my favorite song but somehow she couldn’t pull like she usually does. Infact I enjoyed more when all the contestants and judges sang at the end. Other than that like everyone I loved Saturday episode more.

Originally posted by: reborn-re

Same here from Sunday episode absolutely loved Muskaan and Mahima. I was looking forward for Menuka’s ek pyaar ka nagma because it’s one of my favorite song but somehow she couldn’t pull like she usually does. Infact I enjoyed more when all the contestants and judges sang at the end. Other than that like everyone I loved Saturday episode more.

I agree 100%!