Episode 43 - The five promises

Constantly I remind of Jennifer Winget's Maya seeing Mudit's role of Sarkar. Maya is close to my heart, even though she was evil, I loved her. These type of characters, put the audience in a dilemma that whether to hate them or love them. Sarkar is evil but he won my heart. According to me not a single character has been written beautifully as Maya's character, Sarkar is the second best character after Maya's character in ITV. Maya intrigued me more because of certain aspects, but Sarkar if not more, is an equally intriguing character.

Ritu wants to expose Sarkar to Kirti, I am still confused whether Ritu should expose him or not, because I hate Ritu. That day when Kirti blamed Sarkar, I supported her but I was against the way she blamed him. Without proofs. Ritu has proofs Par mera maatha fat gaya hi Ritu ko support karu ya na karu Because I hate her obsession and on the other side a mother has a right to know who troubled her child

Kirti is in the queue while Ritu and Sarkar both want to reach to Kirti. One wants her to leave Panchghati, while the other wants her to stay. Ritu fails to search first while Sarkar reaches her first. Sarkar chalti bas ke beech mein aa jate hai That scene was funny. But I will leave analyzing that scene, Sarkar kitne dur the phir bhi pahunch gaye

Kirti and Puru get out of the bus and Puru hugs Sarkar as he feels that Sarkar has superpowers as he stopped the bus. Sarkar is crying and getting emotional and apologizes to Puru for not fulfilling his promise of not protecting. He was guilty, even Kirti was clueless why Sarkar is apologizing to him. Sarkar ties a black thread to Puru and says that her mother tied to him, to him safe. Achha to isiliye Sarkar ab tak safe the. Now the black thread is not him, does this means that Sarkar will be caught? Sarkar makes four promises to Puru and he addressed him as Aap, Aap means Kirti and Puru both. Sarkar ne indirectly Kirti ko propose bhi kar diya . First promise was that they wont stay alone, Second was he wont hurt their feelings, third was his ultimate goal of life is to protect them and the fourth was to love them always.

Kirti was speechless seeing their conversation, what can we expect her to speak? I loved Sarkar's scene with Puru keeping aside the Sarkar's evil intentions. Yeh Puru Sarkar ke konse version se baat raha tha. Sarkar 1.0 is Kill Kirti, Sarkar 2.0 is Love Kirti, Sarkar 3.0 is Scare kirti Now Sarkar 1.0 and 3.0 have been kicked by Sarkar 2.0 Which version made this promises? But Puru is a sweet boy yaar, he understands the language of love, innocent baby

Kirti is requesting Sarkar to not give such promises, but instead Sarkar promises her that he will always protect her at the the cost of his life Just as Kirti was confused, I was also confused and she asks why he is doing this for her, Sarkar is unable to tell that his version 2 loves her Kirti is convinced to stay back in Panchghati. Ritu sees this drama and she is so hurt that she is disappointed with Sarkar. Ritu ke umra mein jee lagakar padhte the, yeh chudel banane chali hai

Kirti's dialogue of Ravan captured my attention she said that mein khud apne liye Ravan paida kar rahi hu Aaj usi Ravan ki Lanka mein uske bhakt ne aag lagai hai If Kirti will stay at Sarkar's house, then she will be giving birth to Ravan, Manthara, Tadakasur, Kansa, Shakuni everyone in that house Ravan will be Sarkar, Manthara will be Ritu, Bittu will be Shakuni. Kirti is apologizing to Anju for stopping her efforts and focusing on Puru, Sarkar is so much happy hearing this.

Kirti and Puru reach school next day and their scene was so so cute The more I say about this scene it is less. Puru offers her a flower wishing a happy birthday. Kirti got emotional when Puru remembered her birthday 🥺🥺🥺 No one knew her birthday. Yeh Kirti ka birthday achanak se tapak pada hai aisa mujhe lagta hai Kirti agar mera birthday kal hota to, mein kud rahi hoti aur bacha zor zor se chillata mere birthday ke baare mein

Ritu wants to meet Kirti and so she leaves a note for her in the Malhar book. Kirti in the library and curiously opens Malhar's book, Ritu ka note niche gir jaata hai But surprisingly Sarkar has left a birthday note for Kirti. I felt that Sarkar has no idea about Kirti's birthday, but Sarkar homework kar ke aaye hai Sarkar is on cloud nine today, after a lot of planning plotting, he is happy today. Sarkar says Happu Birthday my Love The way he said it He is hot, bhaad mein uska kharaab side, but uski awaaz When Kirti found that it is Sarkar who left a note, she was smiling too.

While this Bittu has again used his tactic to trouble Sarkar and to get out of the cage. He burns the room Bittu ko ghar par rakha hai aur Bua ke ghar mein se kisine Bittu ko dekha hi nahi? Sarkar's home is about to catch fire. Madhuri goes into his house (Sarkar ke ghar ki chaabi Bua ke paas hai kya?) and Sarkar is now scared that if Madhuri sees Bittu then he will be screwed again because of Bittu But seeing the precap I feel that Bittu wont be seen by Bua

Precap is amazing if you just see that scene and not analyze anything

Kosha

Above is the update of Keh Doon Tumhein Ep 43 - The five promises

I feel it's too early for Sarkar to propose. But I understand the logic. He was almost on the verge of losing that one hope in his dark and grim life - Kirti and Puru. Those promises were made by Vikrant, solely and purely Vikrant - who loves Puru and Kirti—no one else.

The precap reminded me of Maya's hot air balloon proposal to Arjun. But the Saanjh here is an imbecile schoolgirl. I understand the "I love you," but I am unsure if Kirti is ready to be with him. Kirti is in full mood to reject the proposal. By what Maya did in Beyhadh S1, she befriended Arjun, but that has already happened here. Vikrant has played the friendship card more than enough. I think he will openly express his love now, as in not compel Kirti to be with him, but will not hide it anymore. And probably then Kirti will feel the love for Vikrant.

And in the meantime, deal with Ritu and Bittu, Sarkar style.

Originally posted by: libran90

I feel it's too early for Sarkar to propose. But I understand the logic. He was almost on the verge of losing that one hope in his dark and grim life - Kirti and Puru. Those promises were made by Vikrant, solely and purely Vikrant - who loves Puru and Kirti—no one else.

The precap reminded me of Maya's hot air balloon proposal to Arjun. But the Saanjh here is an imbecile schoolgirl. I understand the "I love you," but I am unsure if Kirti is ready to be with him. Kirti is in full mood to reject the proposal. By what Maya did in Beyhadh S1, she befriended Arjun, but that has already happened here. Vikrant has played the friendship card more than enough. I think he will openly express his love now, as in not compel Kirti to be with him, but will not hide it anymore. And probably then Kirti will feel the love for Vikrant.

And in the meantime, deal with Ritu and Kirti Sarkar style.

Kirti is gonna reject for sure

If Sarkar was Maya, then she would have screwed Kirti

And I will love if they both address each other as Kirti and Vikrant and as tum not aap.

Originally posted by: TheGirlofRagas

Kirti is gonna reject for sure

If Sarkar was Maya, then she would have screwed Kirti

And I will love if they both address each other as Kirti and Vikrant and as tum not aap.

Maya had trauma from her father, so she was wary of men until Arjun came. Her killing spree began with her father. Maya felt that control is love, and manipulation is love. Otherwise, she would turn into her mother after her father abandoned her. And an absentee mother was vital in shaping Maya's psyche and perspective on love. No one, not even Arjun, could help her with her insecurities.

Sarkar is very different. Sarkar ko bahut saare traumas hai - Mother, best friend and who knows what else. But he truly loved his mother. Kirti is a reflection of his mother. But, the Sarkar in him sees her as a threat to his serial killing spree because she can purge the darkness from him and extend a helping hand to the lost and scared child Vikrant. The way Vikrant hugged Puru today just showed how desperately he, at one point in time, wanted that tight hug from someone and never got one.

Vikrant will have to navigate his love story in a slightly different way. Kirti is too frightened by her last tryst with marriage and love. He has to give her that much space.

See Maya wasn't just broken, she was psychotic and it came from being abused at a very young age. She didn't have it in her to love anyone. For her it was always about obsession and control. She didn't understand right or wrong, good or bad. Anything was allowed in her obsession for Arjun. She was complex, but also quite simple. Her complexities came from the way she tried to hide her true identity and her past, but her simplicity came from the fact that once someone understood her, they had some way to counter it.

On the other hand, Vikrant is not psychotic or just obsessive. He understands that he is wrong when it comes to the murders. He comes from a loving childhood with his mother. He knows and understands love. But he also doesn't want to let anyone control him. I don't think that is Vikrant though - I think that is the Rohit in him and we haven't been introduced to Rohit properly. Vikrant is really living 3 lives - (1) Rohit, a man who cannot give up control and thinks women just want to use him so they should die, (2) Sarkar, part Rohit and part Vikrant, this man does the murders and keeps himself safe by manipulating people and situations, and (3) Vikrant, a lonely man who has a lot of love to give but hasn't found anyone who can love him since his mother died. Given the 3 personalities, it is difficult to understand him and know which to respond to and which to run from because it's not like he can turn one on or off. All 3 are within him and always fighting.

On the precap, I hope SP doesn't stick their leg into the show now. Because honestly the way it should go is Kirti refusing, Sarkar trying to encourage Vikrant to get rid of Kirti, Vikrant fighting Sarkar and then accepting Kirti's decision but not changing himself and showing her his love at every step of the way. That would be a beautiful way to go because now Kirti would see Vikrant's love.

That Happy Birthday My Love ufff.......

Kya voice modulation h. Sarkar doesn't seem to pretend anything while talking to Puru at all.

He meant those words. He said that he sees himself in Puru just hope he doesn't hurt that pure soul. Puru is so cute.

Kirti ko samjh to sab aa gya h but Kabootar ki tarah aankh band rakhna chahti h.

Originally posted by: Minionite

See Maya wasn't just broken, she was psychotic and it came from being abused at a very young age. She didn't have it in her to love anyone. For her it was always about obsession and control. She didn't understand right or wrong, good or bad. Anything was allowed in her obsession for Arjun. She was complex, but also quite simple. Her complexities came from the way she tried to hide her true identity and her past, but her simplicity came from the fact that once someone understood her, they had some way to counter it.

On the other hand, Vikrant is not psychotic or just obsessive. He understands that he is wrong when it comes to the murders. He comes from a loving childhood with his mother. He knows and understands love. But he also doesn't want to let anyone control him. I don't think that is Vikrant though - I think that is the Rohit in him and we haven't been introduced to Rohit properly. Vikrant is really living 3 lives - (1) Rohit, a man who cannot give up control and thinks women just want to use him so they should die, (2) Sarkar, part Rohit and part Vikrant, this man does the murders and keeps himself safe by manipulating people and situations, and (3) Vikrant, a lonely man who has a lot of love to give but hasn't found anyone who can love him since his mother died. Given the 3 personalities, it is difficult to understand him and know which to respond to and which to run from because it's not like he can turn one on or off. All 3 are within him and always fighting.

On the precap, I hope SP doesn't stick their leg into the show now. Because honestly the way it should go is Kirti refusing, Sarkar trying to encourage Vikrant to get rid of Kirti, Vikrant fighting Sarkar and then accepting Kirti's decision but not changing himself and showing her his love at every step of the way. That would be a beautiful way to go because now Kirti would see Vikrant's love.

Completely agree with you. SP usually interferes more in the prime time shows, and thankfully it is aptly slotted at 11,which does not need to actively deliver on TRPs. And I feel Kirti does feel for Vikrant, but her priority is Puru. Hence she doesn't want that relationship complications in her life which shifts her focus from her son. Vikrant needs to show her how actual love looks like, cause she has only seen abuse in recent times. I hope Vikrant understands that well, cause he knows very well how Kirti's past was.

Also, Vikrant intends to protect Kirti and Puru, even from his own darkness. So I feel he will confess but not compel Kirti. He just wanted to confess his feelings to her, because he wants to have a new beginning with her.

Originally posted by: libran90

Completely agree with you. SP usually interferes more in the prime time shows, and thankfully it is aptly slotted at 11,which does not need to actively deliver on TRPs. And I feel Kirti does feel for Vikrant, but her priority is Puru. Hence she doesn't want that relationship complications in her life which shifts her focus from her son. Vikrant needs to show her how actual love looks like, cause she has only seen abuse in recent times. I hope Vikrant understands that well, cause he knows very well how Kirti's past was.

Also, Vikrant intends to protect Kirti and Puru, even from his own darkness. So I feel he will confess but not compel Kirti. He just wanted to confess his feelings to her, because he wants to have a new beginning with her.

Well SP still wants TRP hence why this show is already on scanner to go off air in mid-November possibly.

Yes. Kirti cannot be that dumb to realize and understand that Vikrant cares for her more than just a friend would. I know that Vikrant is a serial killer and doesn't deserve a happy ending, but sometimes I just want and hope that Kirti and Puru can help him chase away his own darkness and become a better person with all the love that he and everyone deserves.

Originally posted by: libran90

Maya had trauma from her father, so she was wary of men until Arjun came. Her killing spree began with her father. Maya felt that control is love, and manipulation is love. Otherwise, she would turn into her mother after her father abandoned her. And an absentee mother was vital in shaping Maya's psyche and perspective on love. No one, not even Arjun, could help her with her insecurities.

Sarkar is very different. Sarkar ko bahut saare traumas hai - Mother, best friend and who knows what else. But he truly loved his mother. Kirti is a reflection of his mother. But, the Sarkar in him sees her as a threat to his serial killing spree because she can purge the darkness from him and extend a helping hand to the lost and scared child Vikrant. The way Vikrant hugged Puru today just showed how desperately he, at one point in time, wanted that tight hug from someone and never got one.

Vikrant will have to navigate his love story in a slightly different way. Kirti is too frightened by her last tryst with marriage and love. He has to give her that much space.

Bolded lines: Much true

He is yearning for love, that scene was beautiful

You nicely explained the difference in both the characters