When was the right time to release TheKashmirFiles? - Page 5

Originally posted by: Nagmani

You crying more for islamophobia than showing solidarity to victims in a thread discussing kashmiri hindu genocide tells who you actually are.

I don't have to call anhbody anything. They are themselves sgowing what they are.

Sure and I also opened this thread few days back to talk about Islamophobia.

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/bollywood/5284165/how-authentic-is-the-kashmir-files

Waiting for a right time is none other than foolishness never wait for a right time. When you create your own opportunities , right time will automatically appears.

it’s just excuses to oppress the truth but truth tat Hindu genocide , kp exodus happened will be known to the world .

It’s time Kashmir files must be opened . Officially acknowledge hindu genocide , kp exodus . Stop trivializing d truth by saying kps are just migrants.

Not one Muslim has supported this movie.

They would rather side with their religion, than lend their support to the genocide victims.

every time I see here , this happened it will help bjp in election , tat happened it will help bjp in election . Apple fallen from tree , it will help bjp in election , ppl are breathing it will help bjp in election . Silly 🤪

Is it bjp phobia r Modi phobia , omg when ppl didn’t ve responsibility ya darr acha hai , oh man the phobia is real 😆 Stop whining , move on , if can’t move aside , let fresh air come .

Originally posted by: arnavfluffy

Not one Muslim has supported this movie.

They would rather side with their religion, than lend their support to the genocide victims.

Why ? Humanity must be shown to the genocide victims .

Originally posted by: AwaamKiJaan

The biggest question is has this movie benefited the society in anyway? Yes, now alot more people know about the plight of Kashmiri Pandits which they didn't know before. But does that ease their pain or changes what they went through?

How can a common man help the Kashmiri Pandits? That's the job of the government and I think they already knew what happened with them. They didn't need a movie to tell them. So if this movie was only made to make profit, then also it's all good.

It doesn't change or effect the lives of any person. But if this movie is being used to spread hate between communities then that's really bad. People making hate speeches after the screening, shouting anti-muslim slogans outside the movie hall. That shit is scary.

You go through any video on YouTube, whether it's about the movie or the real incident, it's filled with hateful comments against Muslims and other religions, and how Hinduism is the greatest religion in the world.

I saw one YouTube comment where a girl told she's a tribal Christian but she supports her Hindu brothers and sisters for what happened with Kashmiri pandits. The replies were filled with everyone telling her how her religion sucks and she needs to come back to Hinduism, because those are her roots, or that they don't need her support because she's a product of conversion.

If this movie is going to create more division between religions, then it would've been better if this film had never released.

On bolds..it created awareness. Awareness of what happened, what were the everlasting effects, how it affected the sufferers even decades later..the overflow of emotions, suppressed pain n sufferings..all came out. There never was a closure.

It gives a msg to the new gen to try n try harder so that such incidents r never repeated. Sadly we see this happening somewhere in the world time n again.

But hope this movie shakes the conscience of a person and forces him to think of consequences before resorting to be violent to someone. And hope it gives courage to a person to not give in to oppression n mindless violence..

Single most Intention.. this history shouldn't be repeated

Originally posted by: Nonpareil

every time I see here , this happened it will help bjp in election , tat happened it will help bjp in election . Apple fallen from tree , it will help bjp in election , ppl are breathing it will help bjp in election . Silly 🤪

Is it bjp phobia r Modi phobia , omg when ppl didn’t ve responsibility ya darr acha hai , oh man the phobia is real 😆 Stop whining , move on , if can’t move aside , let fresh air come .

Seriously..it gets so annoying. Bhagwan bana diya hai Modi ko. Bhakt hai ye log..Har cheez me Har baat me Modi dikhte hai, din raat, subah shaam unka naam lete hai..Modi Jaap japte rehte hai. Jahan unka naam na liya gaya ho wahan bhi unko dekhte hai.

Itne Modimay hai..Bhakt na kahe to kya kahe inko..interestingly they r not even realizing how enamored they sound in their hate for a person

Originally posted by: Kyahikahoon

Seriously..it gets so annoying. Bhagwan bana diya hai Modi ko. Bhakt hai ye log..Har cheez me Har baat me Modi dikhte hai, din raat, subah shaam unka naam lete hai..Modi Jaap japte rehte hai. Jahan unka naam na liya gaya ho wahan bhi unko dekhte hai.

Itne Modimay hai..Bhakt na kahe to kya kahe inko..interestingly they r not even realizing how enamored they sound in their hate for a person

I always see here india phobia , Hindu phobia , Modi phobia n spread india n Hindu hate etc..Seeing since long time , even forum became almost dead but whining going on n spreading hate going on …

Seems like Modi is world leader n has world bhakts lol . If keep world elections , it will help bjp in world elections n modi will be world president /pm 🤣

I didn’t understand one thing , one side say bohoo democracy is in danger but elections going 24/7 since 2014 in india n everything in world is helping in bjp election 🤣 Who is in danger if elections going on forever 🤪 🤣

so many gems 🤣

Originally posted by: capricornrcks

There was no dark conspiracy to suppress the truth as you seem to think. 😳Everyone was aware of the atrocities committed then and during the riots after Indira Gandhi's death.The same with the Serbian-Bosnian atrocities too. It was all discussed in the media. Unless you were living under the rock you couldn't help hearing about it.Now caring about the plight of the victims is another matter altogether. Most people are too busy or are unable to care much about what goes on outside their immediate sphere of influence.And the KPs were not a significant vote bank for any political party to take up their cause then. If politicians are taking up their cause now, it's not because their conscience has suddenly woken up.

As for the generations who came later, it' our job to read up on our history from different sources and form your own opinion. Most text books don't cover recent history. The wounds are still fresh. Somehow reading about Jallianwala Bagh or the Black Hole of Calcutta is tolerable because of the time passed. And the Mughals like it or not are as much Indian as you or me, and are part and parcel of the history of India.

Not true. Was a kid in 1990. U know what was talked about of that 11 month PM ship of V P Singh? The protests due to Mandal commission..5 lakh KPs fled their homeland..many lives lost. So many horror stories and we knew none of it.

What did we read..a student trying to immolate himself ..inciting similar protests across schools all over the country..stone pelters coming over to schools and throwing stones on windows, forcing schools to shut down..And us small kids huddled inside.

So when KPs were battling for their lives and surviving in refugee camps, the future of the nation was pelting stones...unaware of all this.

And didn't know for years..came to know only once we grew up a bit and came to know of a parents' colleague who went through the ordeal.

Knew about the exodus, but never imagined the extent of such suffering..what on earth would drive us towards reading the books or watching the documentaries when they were not even talked about. For us little ones Kashmir was this happy , pretty place where old bollywood movies were shot and Actors danced in the snow or in a Shikara on Dal lake..and then one day there came a movie like Roja that showed a different side to that Paradise..and everything that followed. I have been there as a kid..wish to see it again in its glory.

So I credit this movie for bringing the issue to light. For us it may be raw, but for new gen it's history from which they learn..