AbhiRa/HarshAli AT #2 - Gaalon Se Guzarti Hai, Tere Gum Ki Nishani - Page 104

Originally posted by: Stardust91

Blue Blue,

Grey's has 2 doctors on their writers' team.....

I remember during Naira's thrombectomy how picky I was about what they were showing.

Then during lockdown 1, Bhavna did an interview with Kartik and said thay doctors and surgeons should not analyse the show.

Today I was like, whatttt is Abhi operating ON? Whattt.is he doing? I thought they would make it something to do with her heart....that is why Abhi would be there...she flatlined so he would cardiovert her. Instead they made it about her voice....fine I get why they did that because Abhi's rooh ka rishta with her aawaz but at that time they should have asked for an ENT surgeon.

It makes no sense for an interventional cardiologist or even a cardiothoracic surgeon to operate on someone who needs an ENT surgeon.

However, I do understand what they want to show they want her voice to be affected and Abhi to blame himself. Or they want him to be the one saving her voice for her.

However, this is ITV....not Grey's.

HC is BAE but ITV is not Grey's anatomy or Chicago Med or The Resident or House. It can't ever be. That's something I accepted a long time ago.

Originally posted by: jani_faizal

Hey Mush, I’ve stopped looking for logic and research and all when it comes to ITV… if I were to look at all that I’d be in the same page as you, but I’m just here watching two people in love without any of the logics behind it.

I do that too but makers are dealing with doctors and surgeons and many medical students watch it. It will create the RIGHT rage and makers should know they will be hurting sentiments of medical students the most because doctors won't even bother to watch this show and if they do, they will be like Rohit Sippy or ignore bcoz there phone will ping with something more important.

They literally made a mockery of whole hardwork and patience it requires to be a doctor and how hard it is to get someone back to life after the line flattens. You know someone who has last someone and has seen such a scene, even if they are not doctors or surgeons, they will be hurt.

But ITV has a habit on getting back the patient together with a tear drop on hand and meri dhadhakan chal rahi hai uski bhi chalegi nd the hold on the heart 😊 yahan par kam se kam breathe breathe toh bola

Am I confused or just understanding?🤪

Originally posted by: Khayali_pulao

I am a complete illiterate on this subject but I understand that it was a pure idiotic way of showing an OT scene. I did not like the direction here. It was not well scripted. Maybe we all had too many expectations

You know what when Akshara ECG showed a blank I was like man give her a CPR (hope I am right) you are a heart surgeon

@bold- exactly, I was crying my eyes out but hitting my head at the same time at some of the stupidity they were showing. This could have been epic but you know logic and itv don’t go hand in hand. If you want to watch itv, it’s best to leave all logics at the main door. I only enjoyed the episode for HC’s acting, he was still able to make me cry buckets even with this sort of writing.

Originally posted by: Khayali_pulao

Haan shock was the I was looking for 😆

That was the most I know too 😆

Originally posted by: ishqdinoorhai9

I do that too but makers are dealing with doctors and surgeons and many medical students watch it. It will create the RIGHT rage and makers should know they will be hurting sentiments of medical students the most because doctors won't even bother to watch this show and if they do, they will be like Rohit Sippy or ignore bcoz there phone will ping with something more important.

They literally made a mockery of whole hardwork and patience it requires to be a doctor and how hard it is to get someone back to life after the line flattens. You know someone who has last someone and has seen such a scene, even if they are not doctors or surgeons, they will be hurt.

But ITV has a habit on getting back the patient together with a tear drop on hand and meri dhadhakan chal rahi hai uski bhi chalegi nd the hold on the heart 😊 yahan par kam se kam breathe breathe toh bola

Am I confused or just understanding?🤪

@ Bold- I feel better now. Thanks Noor for putting things in perspective. 🤣

Originally posted by: jani_faizal

@bikd- exactly, I was crying my eyes out but hitting my head at the same time at some of the stupidity they were showing. This could have been epic but you know logic and itv don’t go hand in hand. If you want to watch itv, it’s best to leave all logics at the main door. I only enjoyed the episode for HC’s acting, he was still able to make me cry buckets even with this sort of writing.

Why do you think they hired HC? Bcoz they know, only he can make it all about his pain with his acting in the crap fest ... Makers hitted a six there

Originally posted by: jani_faizal

Just think how devastating it would be for the two of them that when she is finally ready to accept her feelings for him she’s unable to voice it😭. You know what I’m going to write my OS cause I don’t know if the makers will give us all this.

P.S. Can we please give this man a standing ovation. The emotions he brought just through his eyes and the lines he spoke, my god Akshu is one lucky girl.

He deserves appreciation for his skills.

Originally posted by: Eternized_Blues

@ Bold- I feel better now. Thanks Noor for putting things in perspective. 🤣

Bro meri expectations itni low hai ki mujhe breathe breathe thik lagega 🤣 bachpan se ITV dekhte badi hui hu and sometime back, I watched a scene where they ghusao a baccha in an OT and made him lock hands with his operating mother... The mother who has sinked, came back to life 😆 bata

Originally posted by: Stardust91

Blue Blue,

Grey's has 2 doctors on their writers' team.....

I remember during Naira's thrombectomy how picky I was about what they were showing.

Then during lockdown 1, Bhavna did an interview with Kartik and said thay doctors and surgeons should not analyse the show.

Today I was like, whatttt is Abhi operating ON? Whattt.is he doing? I thought they would make it something to do with her heart....that is why Abhi would be there...she flatlined so he would cardiovert her. Instead they made it about her voice....fine I get why they did that because Abhi's rooh ka rishta with her aawaz but at that time they should have asked for an ENT surgeon.

It makes no sense for an interventional cardiologist or even a cardiothoracic surgeon to operate on someone who needs an ENT surgeon.

However, I do understand what they want to show they want her voice to be affected and Abhi to blame himself. Or they want him to be the one saving her voice for her.

However, this is ITV....not Grey's.

HC is BAE but ITV is not Grey's anatomy or Chicago Med or The Resident or House. It can't ever be. That's something I accepted a long time ago.

You are right!!! A little bit work on the makers side is required to make things look more realistic than dramatical at least in such scenes. I am not asking too much. Knowing her reports, he could have called for an ENT like you said while still being in there supporting her emotionally.

Seems like they have completely lost it. The show which took off at such a great note is losing its charm day by day. Agar they are not giving a shock treatment to revive them even HC/ AbhiRa is not going to work.

Originally posted by: ishqdinoorhai9

Bro meri expectations itni low hai ki mujhe breathe breathe thik lagega 🤣 bachpan se ITV dekhte badi hui hu and sometime back, I watched a scene where they ghusao a baccha in an OT and made him lock hands with his operating mother... The mother who has sinked, came back to life 😆 bata

🤣
that’s why I said for me it’s an okayish episode. I don’t Know medical concepts as such but certain things really made it look weird. All the more I was emotional with HC and his acting. The way he cried forgetting that he is doc and all that