Dan radcliffe questioned Rowling's plots - Page 2

Originally posted by: cezzurockz

i thk he said it frm the movie pt of view bt if he hv read the whole series these thgs happens accordingly bt i didnt want sirius to die

well thats the point! he hasnt read the entire series

Originally posted by: charmedsherry

In an interview asking Daniel radcliffe about his opinion and thought on Life and adventures of harry potter he replied with a sceptic tone that:

At the end of The Sorcerer's Stone, Goblet of Fire, and Order of the Phoenix.

In The Sorcerer's Stone, even if Harry never went down to the place where the mirror was in the end, Voldemort and Quirrel wouldnt have been able to get the stone anyway because Dumbledore says only someone who didnt want to use the stone could get it from the mirror. If anything Harry could've only helped them get the stone.

In The Goblet of Fire, if Harry knew he didnt submit himself into the Goblet, then wouldnt he be more suspicious and wouldnt he withdrawl from the competition because someone obviously wanted him dead and in the end if he took the goblet by himself, Cedric wouldnt have died.

In Order of the Phoenix, if Harry didn't go to the Mystery place then the death eaters wouldnt have been able to get the prophecy anyway and Sirius wouldnt have died. If he was more serious about the Occlumency then none of it would have happened. The only good thing that happened was that the people knew voldemort was alive. I am a fan and friend of JK Rowling but she probably shouldve thought more about the plots before she wrote the books and had us act in the movies.

-Dan Radcliffe

abt movie 1- dd said that only the person who doesnt want 2 use the stone for themselves would get d stone...thats y hp got it

movie4- even if harry wanted 2,he couldnt coz of the magical contract stating that the names which come out of the fire would have 2 participate and abt the cup,how was he supposed to know that the cup was a port key....i mean he knew that somebody wants 2 kill him in this whole affiar,but he did nt know when and where...

movie5- jkr made harry not very good at occulmency coz hp in general good at almost everything- he was ok in studies,good in DADA and played quidditch well...so he couldnt be picture perfect..he had to have his flaws- like being jealous of his best friend,being bad in some subjects.....having crushes...thats what makes him a normal human being....

i jst think dan needs to read the books..thats it....