Originally posted by: jojo_mojo
Today i could not help but compare Mithi and Malini.
Highly educated Malini derives her identity through a man - either her father or her husband. That's why its shocking injustice to her that Imlie did not get either her husbands name or her fathers name. While uneducated Mithi believes in her own identity. Malini's thought process reflected in her speech; When Mithi said Imlie is her daughter and she doesnt need anyone else's name, Malini immediately questions her. What about your identity? What about your haq? Why didnt you demand for it?
Mithi impressed me with her dialogue today "Mangne se bheek milat hai; haq nahi. Aur hum bhikaaran nahi". The pride in her voice, the self respect had my heart. Even NN looked mildly impressed. This show continues to be a case study in what it means to be truly independent. On one hand we have malini, a highly educated, "independent" woman who literally begged aditya for her "haq", chose to stick to him despite knowing he did not care for her; and her high society mom who knew that Dev cheated on her but she still continued her marriage because of "Malini". On other hand we have Mithi, a poor, uneducated woman in village who knew Dev ran away after spending a night with her because he was not ready to take responsibility for her or her unborn child. Though she knew she could have demanded her right, if not wifely right, at-least financial assistance to raise Imlie; she choose not to. She respected his choice to leave her and more than that she respected herself enough to raise Imlie alone.
I can only imagine the hell she must have faced. The shame, the mockery. Today, even NN took a moral high ground because according to her, she is just a thief but Mithi is worse than her. Mithi never let her experience with Dev or any of the taunts or shame embitter her. She continues to show only love and respect to people around her, no matter how undeserving they are. If this is not strength, i dont know what is.
Her sweet nature shines through all these clouds of shame that try to engulf her. She brought up imlie as a symbol of her love for a man, not as proof of shame everyone made her to be. Mithi gave Imlie the one thing she herself lacked - education - So that imlie can make informed choices in life; Knows her rights and has strength to fight for them.
It is mithi's strength that shines in imlie, her love for others reflects in imlie's selfless actions and her pride and self respect when Imlie chose to walk away from Aditya because he insulted her beliefs.
It's a shame that malini does not have capability to self reflect. If she did, her conversation with Mithi would have been a highly educational experience to her. She will continue to believe that she is doing imlie a great favor by making D accept that Imlie is his daughter. Imlie never needed a man's name before she wont need in future. Thats the beauty of her character.