Is this legal? - Page 7

Originally posted by: notaquitter

I am not even talking about the plot. All I am saying is whoever does it without her mother’s permission is at fault legally. Be it ML or FL. Currently it’s the FL eloping, so kaku can get marriage invalidated if they are going to be legally correct in the show.

Originally posted by: Jiarao

Absolutely. This is not about sai or Virat. This is about mental health and law of the land.

@bold. Which can go to hell for all itv cares🤣 itv don't give damn about anything other than drama, more drama, illogical drama🤣

Originally posted by: Jiarao

This is what bothering me the most. One doctor and one medical student are trying to cure a mental disease with marriage🤦‍♀️. Hope makers have some sense to show the effects of events on Devyanis health.

Devi will get cured after marriage with rahasya maye tarike se🤪

Originally posted by: 404_NotFound

There is a huge difference. In case of Virat , he was getting Devi married in presence of her mother . He never had plans to get a Devkit married secretly . Even if Kaku was not in favour she would not oppose openly or take legal actions to stop the marriage. In case of Sai , it’s not the same . She has helped Devi elope and it can be termed as kidnapping.

The question of the thread topic was isn’t getting Devi married illegal at her state.

We don’t know how kaku would react if Virat has gotten them married. But what we do know is she is against the marriage. So that means legal guardian denies the permission .

So even without all the kidnapping nonsense they showed, kaku could still have invalidated the marriage.

only talking about the legal aspects, whether it’s shown correctly or not, even Virat said that they are off age and we can get them married without elders consent ( legally this statement is wrong based on the discussion of this theeas). Secondly he compared it to sairat marriage which is not the case here because of devis mental health.

Ofcourse,Sai is not right in eloping Devi and getting her married and there is definitely legal repercussions . I am just saying if what sai is doing is wrong now, Virat’s above statement( in the above paragraph ) is Also wrong legally , even though he went against the marriage for a different reason

Thai is my point. I rest my case. I made my point here.

The makers should watch out on how they write the dialogues and do some research.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4539879/

okay I was reading on this and came across this article..

according to the Indian psychiatry journal these laws are archaic. They were passed in the 1950s when treatment for mental illness weren’t as available as they are today...

In today’s date mental illness is treatable.. yes bhavani is Devi’s guardian but you cannot ignore that she is the one who has caused this. Now if they are to go to court and counter this the court can allot an appointed psychiatrist which will work under their surveillance to see whether devyanis condition improves or not...

just because she has a mental illness doesn’t not mean she doesn’t have the right to marry. There are many loopholes.. if through dna testing pulkit proves devyani to be the mother and that the child was snatched from the mother it makes a sting basis for devyani to be with pulkit...

the whole thing has many many loopholes.. now some might counter that they can bribe the people etc, but we shouldn’t forget that pulkit himself is a doctor (no matter how spineless he might be) he knows about taking care of such patients and has been trained...

also devyani remembers her marriage and gets panic attacks when something happens to pulkit or something is against pulkit..

there are many ways of proving what bhavani and gang have done..

but basing the argument on the basis that she is mentally unstable is not fair because she hasn’t been given proper medical help... we don’t know what medication and what kind of treatment and whether there is a treatment devyani is being provided.

The cause is clear. It was the shock of losing the child and husband which probably drove her to lose her mental stability but her mother has not helped her recover why because she knows if she recovers she will let the truth out and will go back to pulkit which bhavani doesn’t want...

Originally posted by: Bechain_Bulbul

@bold. Which can go to hell for all itv cares🤣 itv don't give damn about anything other than drama, more drama, illogical drama🤣

Originally posted by: notaquitter

The question of the thread topic was isn’t getting Devi married illegal at her state.

We don’t know how kaku would react if Virat has gotten them married. But what we do know is she is against the marriage. So that means legal guardian denies the permission .

So even without all the kidnapping nonsense they showed, kaku could still have invalidated the marriage.

only talking about the legal aspects, whether it’s shown correctly or not, even Virat said that they are off age and we can get them married without elders consent ( legally this statement is wrong based on the discussion of this theeas). Secondly he compared it to sairat marriage which is not the case here because of devis mental health.

Ofcourse,Sai is not right in eloping Devi and getting her married and there is definitely legal repercussions . I am just saying if what sai is doing is wrong now, Virat’s above statement( in the above paragraph ) is Also wrong legally , even though he went against the marriage for a different reason

Thai is my point. I rest my case. I made my point here.

The makers should watch out on how they write the dialogues and do some research.

Secondly, yes that dialogue of Virat was wrong and I agree CVs should have researched more about the laws of the land .

To answer the question: No, it's illegal.

Same as the trio beating up pulkit to drive him away, stealing devi tai baby and put it for adoption, torturing her to the point she lost her mental stability, bribing clerk to falsify pulkit docs, kidnapping pulkit among others.

It's better to keep logic aside watching this show else it will induce mental stress instead of entertaining.

Originally posted by: Svt611

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4539879/

okay I was reading on this and came across this article..

according to the Indian psychiatry journal these laws are archaic. They were passed in the 1950s when treatment for mental illness weren’t as available as they are today...

In today’s date mental illness is treatable.. yes bhavani is Devi’s guardian but you cannot ignore that she is the one who has caused this. Now if they are to go to court and counter this the court can allot an appointed psychiatrist which will work under their surveillance to see whether devyanis condition improves or not...

just because she has a mental illness doesn’t not mean she doesn’t have the right to marry. There are many loopholes.. if through dna testing pulkit proves devyani to be the mother and that the child was snatched from the mother it makes a sting basis for devyani to be with pulkit...

the whole thing has many many loopholes.. now some might counter that they can bribe the people etc, but we shouldn’t forget that pulkit himself is a doctor (no matter how spineless he might be) he knows about taking care of such patients and has been trained...

also devyani remembers her marriage and gets panic attacks when something happens to pulkit or something is against pulkit..

there are many ways of proving what bhavani and gang have done..

but basing the argument on the basis that she is mentally unstable is not fair because she hasn’t been given proper medical help... we don’t know what medication and what kind of treatment and whether there is a treatment devyani is being provided.

The cause is clear. It was the shock of losing the child and husband which probably drove her to lose her mental stability but her mother has not helped her recover why because she knows if she recovers she will let the truth out and will go back to pulkit which bhavani doesn’t want...

To add to this

Devi tai clearly mentions if I go with Pulkit they will kill us... now even if someone is mentally unstable a statement like this is strongly worded.. no one just out of the blue says they will kill us..

The mind is strong and even though tai doesn’t not have the ability to make sound decisions her subconscious mind has memory of these aspects..

secondly, bhavani will never go to court because that would mean a case forming in public and her reputation at stake..

it is also said that some mentally unstable ( I don’t have a better word for this hence using it but I don’t like using this term) prove to be better in marriages.. clearly Pulkit loves Devyani and there is no doubt that he will treat her well...

if this whole situation is to go to court, it will be Chavan family facing the brunt because the court will force a proper investigation into the case and no Virat cannot investigate the case..

I’m sure bhavani doesn’t want to wash her dirty linen in public

Also if Devyani feels threatened in any way in Chavan niwas is a big thing to prove in court which Devyani does... she constantly reminds Sai that ninad and Omkar will kill pulkit and her mother will do some thing to her...

She is clearly at high risk staying under the same roof as bhavani Omkar and ninad.. it’s unfortunate that her guardian is the one who is doing this.. it would have been different if her father would be alive...

Originally posted by: Svt611

To add to this

Devi tai clearly mentions if I go with Pulkit they will kill us... now even if someone is mentally unstable a statement like this is strongly worded.. no one just out of the blue says they will kill us..

The mind is strong and even though tai doesn’t not have the ability to make sound decisions her subconscious mind has memory of these aspects..

secondly, bhavani will never go to court because that would mean a case forming in public and her reputation at stake..

it is also said that some mentally unstable ( I don’t have a better word for this hence using it but I don’t like using this term) prove to be better in marriages.. clearly Pulkit loves Devyani and there is no doubt that he will treat her badly...

if this whole situation is to go to court, it will be Chavan family facing the brunt because the court will force a proper investigation into the case and no Virat cannot investigate the case..

I’m sure bhavani doesn’t want to wash her dirty linen in public

Also if Devyani feels threatened in any way in Chavan niwas is a big thing to prove in court which Devyani does... she constantly reminds Sai that ninad and Omkar will kill pulkit and her mother will do some thing to her...

She is clearly at high risk staying under the same roof as bhavani Omkar and ninad.. it’s unfortunate that her guardian is the one who is doing this.. it would have been different if her father would be alive...

Is case sai ko police ko involve karna parega still she can't prove what she did is right . Which she don't feel necessary

Saj ke pass koi proof nhi hain apne logic ko sabit karne ka .

Infact she is risking devi's life by this marriage recently devi health got worsen , sai dint consulted Devi's doctor, what if devi again get a panick attack.. devi will get to know about harini which is another shock for her . Currently devi is not in such condition that she can handle such things .

Sai logic ek baar shaadi ho gayi to sab manjayene wali hain , she said to devi when they were leaving d house today devi told about missing Ashwani.

https://youtu.be/3wCoLLeMwbE

Shaadi ke baad konsa jaadu hi jayega aajtak kaku dint accepted sai what made sai think this.