Originally posted by: janecastle
Aliya hates Pragya because all her plans fail because of Pragya. Also in her mind, Pragya was the one who united Purab-Bulbul and later Purab-Disha. Basically, she wanted someone to pin all the blame for her messed up plans and life.
And there is no justification for Rhea's actions. She tried to harm Prachi multiple times. And what for... because Prachi hurt her ego? Then she became more envious because of Abhi's affection and Ranbir's love for Prachi. Again that doesn't make any sense because she herself was enjoying Pragya's love and attention. If Pragya abandoned Rhea, then she should hurt Pragya, not Prachi. Prachi herself was an infant then. What exactly is Prachi's fault in all this. And Rhea is not 5 year old that Aliya can manipulate easily. Rhea did everything with her own free will. That makes her even more dangerous than Aliya because the people she hurt are her own mother, father and sister.
And Rhea's obsession for Ranbir is another joke. When Ranbir proposed her, she pushed him towards Prachi. Used him to get her petty revenge from Prachi. And when Ranbir fell in love with Prachi, when he chose Prachi over her, that airhead couldn't stand rejection. And that has led to all the mess that followed, starting with the fake molestation charges to Prachi's accident. Rhea is a pathetic character who want the world to revolve around. And for that she is ready to hurt anyone, be it her own family or anyone else. Aliya is also a criminal who has done multiple crimes. Both of them deserve to be rotting in jail for the crimes they did. Rhea's mummy issues are not an excuse for the crimes she committed.
Rhea definitely has no excuses for what she has done and the same goes for aliya is what I meant. I feel like they are both equally bad because whatever rhea is doing to pranbir is something Aliya has done to abhigya and purab and others multiple times. She bribed the fans to to throw stones at her brother in his concert because she was angry. She is more than willing to hurt Prachi and Pragya even now. The only difference in Aliya and Rhea is Aliya consciously made all those choices without anyone playing or manipulating her while Rhea has an excuse there even though it's no excuse in the court of law.
Aliya never once even thought of doing the right thing let alone actually do it. The only redemption was Kiara but now even that's nowhere to be shown. And technically she brought tanu and Nikhil into their lives and made so many plans so indirectly she is also a part of of big scheme of things that got Kiara (her niece) killed. Then she convinced bulbul to commit suicide when she failed her plan of killing Pragya using a chandelier. So,both rhea and Aliya just want everything for themselves and go according to them and no punishment is really enough for them.
And Rhea is Aliya 2.0 which means Aliya is the progenitor. There was literally a scene initially where rhea did something bad to Prachi as usual and Meera yelled at her and Rhea said Meera is like her mom so she has the rights to slap her etc. And then after she left she tells Aliya that she only did that because that's what Meera wanted to hear and Aliya calls her the best student.
I just feel that Aliya was messed once she was grown and became horrible while they know her reputation and still Abhi gave her the right to be close to rhea and teach her the world which she did but from her perspective which is very twisted. It's one thing to just have bad perspectives but it's another thing to be around and raised by someone who should have been locked up or sent to an institution and who saw even a baby who is her blood and her niece as some pawn she can use to keep Abhi and purab close to her and send Pragya away. That's a dangerous person to give a baby to and yes there's other good people but what does a child know about who is good and bad? She can make a choice when she grew up which she didn't so who rhea/Aliya choose to hurt of how doesn't matter as long as there are crimes and schemes that affected people. I feel like Aliya should be in jail. While rhea should first be cut off with no money and home and that'd show what value she has without the Mehra tag and then jailed. Whenever this show is ending more than the romances I care about how these two evil people pay for their mistakes. But though we both disagree on if they are equally evil or one is worse than the other I think we can agree on one thing,that is they'll be let go easily. They'll be forgiven easily. Like one episode of Rhona dhona and one episode of them doing something like leaving the house or suicide again and everyone will be back to hugs and kisses like nothing happened. Just like how nice Ranbir is to rhea.
CID
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2
316