Originally posted by: _Runa_
Yes, I think that he believed Sherlyn over Preeta when he believed those photos. That was exactly the reason he believed that Preeta didn't stop the shaadi as she was bribed. That was the first time he turned into this "always angry Karan".
His first impression of Preeta was bad. But his second, third, forth etc. impressions were good. He knows her family is good.
On contrary, his first impression of Sherlyn was good. But his second, third, forth... every time impressions were bad enough to not believe those photos blindly. He knows exactly who is Sherlyn and what can she do. He knows exactly that she trapped his own brother. How come he didn't check and believed it immediately?
For me it's very very unconvincing. So to continue watching the show I just don't put much thoughts into that Karan's statement "Preeta took money. She is bad". I think the writers should bring some better argument for making Karan to hate Preeta.
This is the most absurd turn of events in my RishTa shipping life span. Uparwala bhi kaise kaise din dikhata hai. Never thought I'd be defending Karan Luthra but here goes.🤣
Karan was not aware that those photos were actually planted by Sherlyn. Karan ko wo tasveerein apne detective se mile the. The fact that he was so offended, wasn't because usne Sherlyn ko Preeta ke saath dekh liya. It was because usne Preeta ko Sherlyn se paise lete huye dekh liya. The issue here is the exchange of money.
Karan is as classist as Kareena. That was the reason he gave her that bundle of money when they first met, and also uspe illzaam lagaya during the MoniRan track that Preeta may have shook hands with Ritwik and Monisha hence Preeta couldn't stop that contract from being signed.
Karan's belief isn't in Sherlyn. Karan's belief stems from his andruni prejudices against Preeta's financial status. Kyunke I don't know if u remember this but Karan hadn't agreed to marry Mahira jabtak usko Alimony wali baat pata nahi chali. Not even for a moment did Karan question whether or not Preeta could be greedy of his property.
Makers ne toh clearly ye dikhaya hai ke Karan ki main issue hi yahi hai. During the diwali episode the way he behaved with Girish was also part of that.
So mere nazariyein no Karan did not believe Sherlyn. In fact when Preeta was recently jailed and Karan was confused about whether or not Preeta had pushed Mahira. It was the fact that the proof against Preeta was brought by Sherlyn was enough proof for Karan that Preeta had nothing to do with pushing Mahira.
Kyunke agar Karan ko wo saboot Sherlyn deti toh wo iss baat pe vishwaas nahi karta ke Preeta had betrayed him. 😌
26