Spineless Bollywood? - Page 4

Originally posted by: niyati13

True..same problem here in my city..why should a country bear the burden of foreigners who live here, earn here and send the money to their relatives in their country? And then we complain of unemployment and poverty for our citizens ..itna hi unemployment hai to why r these people coming here to earn? Why do they say life here is better than there

Aaj yeh hua hai Kal bologe Up Bihar walonko Mumbai se hatao, bihariyonko West Bengal se hatao kyunki unemployment badh Raha hai

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

West Bengal too has the same problem. Mamta Didi gets Bangladeshis here so that her vote bank increases. So? Government should make sure immigration is halted from all fronts then. Why target only the Muslim immigrants? All they want is to counter the growing population of Muslims in India by giving citizenship to more all other religious immigrants. Population control measures? Zero. Immigration stricter laws? Zero. They are just in the business of turning muslims into second class citizens. Why should a Muslim immigrant who has lived a good civil life in India following all rules not get the same benefit as a Hindu or any other religious immigrant.

they should they obviously should........but i am sure the government will not be able to take any biased decisions......

Illegal immigrants hatana hain toh sapko hatao. Sirf non Muslims ko citizenship dena- I wish our government was subtle in its anti-Muslim rhetoric.

That is it.

It’s Christmas time and I was feeling bored. Thanks for this topic. I gotta read both POVs and details from pro and anti side. Bring it on all debaters. Be civil though!

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

Criticism of Islam can exist simultaneously with Islamophobia. When you deny someone something others will get just because they are Muslim. That's islamophobic.

And India is an amalgamation of many cultures. Its not 'culturally' Hindu. You can't erase the others just like that. And even if you want to,sure. But the constitution is all that matters. Its secular and this Bill is islamophobic.

India is an amalgamation of many cultures, but 80% of it is Hindu-inspired or related to Hindu culture. Everything associated with 'Indian culture' is related to Hindu belief systems in some way. In foreign countries, when people talk about 'Indian culture', they are talking about mainly Hindu culture i.e. weddings, rituals, art, music (a major part of Indian art and music has roots in Hindu scriptures and practices). So yes, India is culturally Hindu whether you like it or not.

Originally posted by: Twinklingmoon

Aaj yeh hua hai Kal bologe Up Bihar walonko Mumbai se hatao, bihariyonko West Bengal se hatao kyunki unemployment badh Raha hai

Dost, UP-Bihari's ko mumbai se hataana nahi hai.........but isn't it sad that the government of UP And Bihar doesnt do anything for their state's development and the youth have to move to other cities leaving their families, sometimes even newly wedded spouse to earn money.......... most of the times the guys live here and the family is in their native place forever......whole life is spend living separately...... is it right for anyone to be forced into such a situation ?

And then cause of this surge in laborers, employee-job ratio also goes for a toss in mumbai... so the locals are also jobless......... how is it an ideal situation and why does politics have to come in this scenario............ it should be plain simple that those who want to move can move but those who want to live in UP-Bihar, should have good growth options there itself........

Originally posted by: Twinklingmoon

Aaj yeh hua hai Kal bologe Up Bihar walonko Mumbai se hatao, bihariyonko West Bengal se hatao kyunki unemployment badh Raha hai

But they are Indian citizens. U r comparing illegal foreigners with fake documents with real indian citizens. Not a same thing at all

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

What about Muslims immigrants who have come here from religious persecution themselves? Where should they go. If they are illegally staying in this country when things are great for them in their home country then fine they can go back. But what about the ones who are facing persecution in their home countries? Why don't they get the same benefits as well. India mein toh Muslims are still a minority compared to the majority so why not add them to the list as well. Where will they go? Should they go back and get killed in their homeland?

We can give citizenship to Ahmadiyas and Baloch Muslims who are being prosecuted. But NOT to Bangladeshi illegals or Rohingya. Bangladesh which has taken in 80% of the Rohingya, is majorly regretting it. The Muslim religious leaders who had campaigned for Rohingyas have themselves turned against them.

Ronhigya are a human explosion bomb, they literally multiply like rabbits. It's a very serious issue for Bangladesh at the moment; the exploding Rohingya population and where to keep them. Also, they are a major security threat to India since they are prone to radicalisation.

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

Illegal immigrants hatana hain toh sapko hatao. Sirf non Muslims ko citizenship dena- I wish our government was subtle in its anti-Muslim rhetoric.

I agree.....sab ko hatana chahiye......

Originally posted by: anjs

they should they obviously should........but i am sure the government will not be able to take any biased decisions......

How are you so sure? People are already suffering due to this. Several deaths reported.