Finally, some straightforward talk - Page 8

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Wait....AD tweeted that there is going to be a good HS-Mini scene before the final goodbye? Oh wow....should I also start hoping now? LOL bhai phir se popat na ban jaaye humara😆

I do think he's going to take Mini's side in the end and say he understands why she needs to leave....the signs so far are pointing to that only.....he will let go.

But if we get one great final conversation and scene b/w these two, shaayad dil ko thoda sukoon milega despite the lost potential otherwise.

Popat to banega hi, as usual! LOL!

Yes, please one final conversation. Signs ka pata nahin par 3-4 minute ka scene bhi de de to uss mein bhi AD and AK kamaal kar denge.

He will let go whether or not they have a fallout because what right does he have to make her stay back anyway? And will Minnie really leave without her parents' consent and just say, I'm leaving and walk out? Doesn't seem like it, but who knows? I'd rather she express her wishes about going and talk to HS about it at least, but if Babita is pissed off she might just say 'go ahead and leave me, be like your father, etc' and then Minnie will feel as if she would have no option but to walk out unhappily.

I had always hoped there would be a scene that would refer to the one where he said a father always wants his daughter to do better than him and advised her to never stop dreaming. This would be a good time as any to bring it up and let Minnie realize that she can fly high but he would still hold on to the spool.

I'm referring to this, and since the clothes are the same I assume it's in that scene. Well, he said wonderful so I'm not sure if he meant that the scene was a happy one or that the performance/dialogues were great. 😆

https://twitter.com/aniruddh_dave/status/1189626269073203200

Originally posted by: inlieu

I had always hoped there would be a scene that would refer to the one where he said a father always wants his daughter to do better than him and advised her to never stop dreaming. This would be a good time as any to bring it up and let Minnie realize that she can fly high but he would still hold on to the spool.

I'm referring to this, and since the clothes are the same I assume it's in that scene. Well, he said wonderful so I'm not sure if he meant that the scene was a happy one or that the performance/dialogues were great. 😆

https://twitter.com/aniruddh_dave/status/1189626269073203200

Oh this pic ....given the clothes they are wearing....this toh looks like it's going to be in continuation of this argument about Ashok's letter....is this going to be their last convo together? I was hoping for something seperate when everyone had calmed down....lol not sure how much of a scene they will have from the Manali shoot either.....ah well.

Chalo jitna bhi mile, hum cherish karenge.....these two have performed fantastically together and the joy they take in working on their scenes instinctively clearly shows up on screen👏

Aww that scene when he told her to never stop dreaming.....one of my all time favs.....wish we could have gotten more convos like that but shaadi ke rush mein whole balance went for a toss.....sigh.

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Oh this pic ....given the clothes they are wearing....this toh looks like it's going to be in continuation of this argument about Ashok's letter....is this going to be their last convo together? I was hoping for something seperate when everyone had calmed down....lol not sure how much of a scene they will have from the Manali shoot either.....ah well.

Chalo jitna bhi mile, hum cherish karenge.....these two have performed fantastically together and the joy they take in working on their scenes instinctively clearly shows up on screen👏

Aww that scene when he told her to never stop dreaming.....one of my all time favs.....wish we could have gotten more convos like that but shaadi ke rush mein whole balance went for a toss.....sigh.

Yes, they have performed fantastically and I have a feeling they will end up working together again. Maybe in 15-20 years' time when AD is ready to play full-on dad roles and she can actually play his daughter. 🤣

Jokes apart, I will cherish whatever I get because these two have brilliant chemistry, ever since the first meeting at the police station. I was watching that just now and am still in aww of the way he pulled the chair out of Minnie's grasp with just one had and set it down, then seamless put his foot on the chair. Brilliant!

Yes, that conversation was where he told her what he expected of her, the discipline, etc. His dreams of raising her to become successful and to watch as she achieved great things in her profession. He was beaming with fatherly pride. I would have wanted them to show this at the end of season 2 at least but I don't know if that's going to happen. The only line that comes to mind is when he told her 'meri photo kheechegi ek din'. That's what I thought Manali would be about but I guess not.

I really hope this isn't their last scene together and that there's a farewell one at some point but it's more likely she will storm off to NB's place and leave from there.

AarYaar

No KK and RS cannot stop Paridth or Ariduth from speaking the truth about why they were axed, and I think that since the manner in which it happened is unprofessional by a PH to openly favour there new star - Ashnoor at the expense of 2 talented stars is not right and has left negative ideas etc. About the leads is not right and RS needs to come clean about it and explain properly instead of talking about a finite story nonsense.

For example there are a lot on this site who are constantly criticising Babita for her Character as being poor etc and totally forgetting that and are having a memory loss like the writers as well in that all the Characters are written by KK, RS and the writers and not by Paridth, who played the Characters so well. With whatever rubbish that RS told her to play, hats off to her. All this will surely upset Paridth who had left Jodha Akbar on a high and RS has spoiled Paridth good name with this nonsense, which surely was not in the script given to her etc.

Ashnoor if She is honest enough to admit to being in the know and plotting behind your Co stars backs to be in the lead for Season 2, instead of hiding behind RS, no comment nonsense. Be honest and admit it, than at least people will accept what we know, instead of lying as Season 2 or whatever name or yarn they want to spin to justify it.

People who conspire like this never last long, there is a lesson about dictators and puppets littered all over history.

With RS trying to be Exta Kapoor, with her flop progressive show and now season 2, with even more unrealistic progressive show with a 15/16 trying to be the queen of the jungle, only time will tell if life panes out this way.

Originally posted by: AreYaar

The very fact that she's still stuck on just showing off to Ashok literally reduces her character to zero in my eyes. Iska kuch nahin ho sakta.....even if she faces some setback in life, she will cry for a bit and then repeat the same thing. If she can't learn anything after all she went through, after both HS and Mini tried to explain to her nicely so many times, then there is no other way left to learn.....life tried to teach her, that also didn't work for her......hopeless cause.

As for not wanting to be alone....again, the way she talks about relationships just makes her look pathetic....no matter how insecure or lonely someone is, when one talks about not being able to even spend 7 days without someone, it just shows one's inability to fundamentally comprehend life and relationships. No relationship can sustain by constantly clinging to each other 24/7 in the name of "love" and "haq". People get suffocated and fall apart.

Anyways, her comprehension was in the minus in every scene today. The way she twisted HS ka "pyar mein haq maangna chahiye tha" logic was just hilarious......she seriously suffers a comprehension problem....ya toh samajhna nahin chahti or she uses twisted interpretations as excuses because she fundamentally doesn't understand relationships.

Agree with everything!

@bold forward spiral ko backward bana diya in writers ne

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Just finished making these....here you go.

Some superb acting from AD in this scene....and so many undercurrents to read. What was HS thinking as he thought back to the contents of the letter and watched Mini? Did he feel the pain behind her smile as he thought about the lines from the letter where Ashok spoke of the fact that hating him all this time has left a world of hurt inside Mini too......or was HS again briefly feeling overcome by those fatherly emotions that Mini evokes in him? It felt like a mix of the two....he felt for the child who's father had hurt her.....and he again wished, despite himself, that he could be the father to her that he wanted to be.

I was so touched by the bit when he simply admits that just watching her made him emotional just like that...."jee bhar gaya mhaara"....that exchange between them said so much of what they know is between them and yet somehow is unable to reach its culmination.

Mini knows he cares a lot for her.....she's read the emotions in his eyes many times and she could in this scene also......but who knows how the chips will fall once the letter rears its head.

Still, a touching scene. They've left behind a good body of work to cherish.

Thank you so much for this 😳

I literally had to search the thread for these gifs 😆 but it was worth it!!

@bold my most fav part too especially after knowing that both these actors and characters are going to part away from themselves and from us very soon 😭

Ok so I managed to watch the episode and babita did really say that she wanted to get PB reach heights only to show ashok and now that she has HS and mini with her it's a slap on ashoks face.🤔 That is why mini right fully asked that she was with her all along when did she go to ashok. HS seemed equally disappointed. I dont know if mini now feels that hers and ashoks relation was ruined because of the divorce and she supporting babita. I mean she stood like a rock with babita even if it meant loosing out on a father and here babita dosent even respect it. Does babita realise that it was minis strength that she moved out of the house with her and struggled with her , maybe another child would have chosen safety and comfort and stayed in ashoks house with grandparents or gone off to study in some other city in a hostel leaving all the mess behind. I dont like it how babita thinks that whatever mini did for her was her duty where as it should have been other way round. I also dont like it the way she keeps telling it was majboori. As far as I know she decided to earn to take minis responsibility and for her education. Was mini a majboori for her then that given the chance she wants to get free from it. IDK how mini would feel about it whenever she says this.

I understand babitas pain of having to live without HS just after marriage. But that dint mean she had to spoil the happy moment of his. The way he threw away the letter on the table in disappointment, he wasn't even allowed to be happy for sometime. And all babita could do was think only about herself. The way she immediately blamed him that he wants to leave her and go she only thinks of her feelings not others. She could have brought this up after sometime

I dont know how HS babita marriage is going to survive like this. And why should HS be the one having to think of babita and putting her first always. I wish he just walks out, if mini walks out on a bad note

Originally posted by: naq5

I dont know how HS babita marriage is going to survive like this. And why should HS be the one having to think of babita and putting her first always. I wish he just walks out, if mini walks out on a bad note

I don't think HS will walk out, uska bas dum ghut ta rahega. Slow death. It will be a shell of a marriage. Empty.

It's not even about who's right or wrong. They clearly have completely different perspectives about life so one person has to compromise in order for this marriage to 'survive' but is that all that marriage is about? Survival?

Originally posted by: inlieu

Yes, they have performed fantastically and I have a feeling they will end up working together again. Maybe in 15-20 years' time when AD is ready to play full-on dad roles and she can actually play his daughter. 🤣

Yes, that conversation was where he told her what he expected of her, the discipline, etc. His dreams of raising her to become successful and to watch as she achieved great things in her profession. He was beaming with fatherly pride. I would have wanted them to show this at the end of season 2 at least but I don't know if that's going to happen. The only line that comes to mind is when he told her 'meri photo kheechegi ek din'. That's what I thought Manali would be about but I guess not.

I really hope this isn't their last scene together and that there's a farewell one at some point but it's more likely she will storm off to NB's place and leave from there.

LOL you know, when NBT aired, Ashnoor was half this height and just a kiddo.....back then toh I was just wishing for her and Kunal to be cast together again someday because they had phenomenal chemistry together.....she could have played his daughter or even just an unconventional friend/family equation again....but it never came to pass......and she just grew up so fast, so tall....lol....surprisingly they did have some small reunions in Season 2 through flashback or imagination scenes, so that was nice. The PH did value their dynamic and chemistry enough to bring them back for some scenes together.

Now her and AD together have painted a whole new world for us, a whole new kind of chemistry with her as a teenager and now this makes me wish for her and AD to be cast together again as well.....but who knows where life will take them from here.

By the time they all manage to work together again, who knows how much more Ashnoor would have grown😆.....I would still love to see her re-cast with either Kunal or AD again. That instinctual acting that AD spoke of.....Ashnoor has it with both him and Kunal.

Aww@ the "meri photo kheechegi ek din" line....I guess all the photos she clicked of him during the wedding will be where they will leave it....lol....Manali mein photoshoot hone ka chance lagta nahin khaas.....haha

Originally posted by: AreYaar

LOL you know, when NBT aired, Ashnoor was half this height and just a kiddo.....back then toh I was just wishing for her and Kunal to be cast together again someday because they had phenomenal chemistry together.....she could have played his daughter or even just an unconventional friend/family equation again....but it never came to pass......and she just grew up so fast, so tall....lol....surprisingly they did have some small reunions in Season 2 through flashback or imagination scenes, so that was nice. The PH did value their dynamic and chemistry enough to bring them back for some scenes together.

Now her and AD together have painted a whole new world for us, a whole new kind of chemistry with her as a teenager and now this makes me wish for her and AD to be cast together again as well.....but who knows where life will take them from here.

By the time they all manage to work together again, who knows how much more Ashnoor would have grown😆.....I would still love to see her re-cast with either Kunal or AD again. That instinctual acting that AD spoke of.....Ashnoor has it with both him and Kunal.

Aww@ the "meri photo kheechegi ek din" line....I guess all the photos she clicked of him during the wedding will be where they will leave it....lol....Manali mein photoshoot hone ka chance lagta nahin khaas.....haha

@bold exactly! and the PH did give them some reconcilliation even though Nanhi had grown up...yaha toh mujhe lagta nahi woh milega even though its Ashnoor only. so it would have been so much more special