Doesn't Veer deserve a thought?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

FruitToasty

@FruitToasty

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: chicksoup

So then according to your logic, she is leading everyone on with this act. Even Radhika with her also arnav confusion when she is doing everything with a clear idea.

What is stopping her from dreaming about him after that? Your description of Mishti here is more like Komolika only. 😆 She let her hair open, daringly caressed his shirt so he could catch her doing that...

No. You are the one who said Mishti went there knowing Ruhaan is there, so my reasoning was that if she knew he was there, she would obviously not put herself in an embarassing situation...
Your example of thief cant be applied here because it makes no sense Mishti would enter Ruhaan's room. Clearly she thought no one was there, so we cant reason that she should expect him there. With what motive in.mind would she go if she expected him there?

@Bold - Please quote my reply where I said that Mishti went to Ruhaan's room knowing he was there. Kuch bhi.

You wrote in your first post -

"Mishti had no idea Ruhaan was there in the room obviously ."

Then you spoke about woman letting her hair down

My reply was -

"I think chances of finding Ruhaan in Ruhaan's bedroom are really good."

Mishti had no idea doesn't make sense because there are more chances of finding Ruhaan in Ruhaan's bedroom than not finding Ruhaan in Ruhaan's bedroom.

From the beginning of this conversation I have not insinuated that Mishti knew Ruhaan was there or she went to entice him, I was talking about what she did in his room.

A person is going to someone's bedroom, opening her hair because he likes it that way, caressing his shirt and she has no idea, what she was doing?

Ruhaan caught her is a different matter

Quote

chicksoup

@chicksoup

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 6 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: FruitToasty

@Bold - Please quote my reply where I said that Mishti went to Ruhaan's room knowing he was there. Kuch bhi.

You wrote in your first post -
"Mishti had no idea Ruhaan was there in the room obviously ."

Then you spoke about woman letting her hair down

My reply was -
"I think chances of finding Ruhaan in Ruhaan's bedroom are really good."

Mishti had no idea doesn't make sense because there are more chances of finding Ruhaan in Ruhaan's bedroom than not finding Ruhaan in Ruhaan's bedroom.

From the beginning of this conversation I have not insinuated that Mishti knew Ruhaan was there or she went to entice him, I was talking about what she did in his room.

A person is going to someone's bedroom, opening her hair because he likes it that way, caressing his shirt and she has no idea, what she was doing?

Ruhaan caught her is a different matter

Chances of finding Ruhaan in Ruhaan's bedroom are really good-

My only question is this. Did she go thinking he'd be there?

What is the relevance of that statement? Ruhaan spends all his time in his bedroom? He doesn't go out? So chances of him being there is very high and if so, why would Mishti go there knowing he would be there?

You said you can't buy she did this unknowingly.

I said she must have because obviously she is not a fool to walk into a guy's room knowing he'd catch her in an embarrassing situation .

Point is, she was not herself.

Or at least she was not behaving the way she would in her best frame of mind.

This is what the monologue in the next episode says also. She says clearly- this is not me. She doesn't want to be there, apologises to Veer for not being her usual self. She thinks she feels closer to Ruhaan because he lives in her house now. That is Mishti thinking clearly. The way she was in Ruhaan's room was not in her clear thinking state.

That is all I am trying to explain to you.

How can just leaving the hair open be intentional and everything else she did unintentional. Her behaviour was abnormal as a whole...

If I remember right, Pari let her hair down too when she dressed up for Ruhaan... She didn't even have a hair opening sequence with him. This is not to start another comparison between the sisters- just to point out that letting hair loose is symbolic of freedom.

Pari realised too that her behaviour was abnormal and ran away. She is free to day dream on anyone or fall in love with anyone.

Here, Mishti realises what she is doing is wrong because she is committed. She apologises to Veer and tries to make it up.

Let the story build up now. As of now, Mishti feels she has sinned in her heart, she feels horrible about it.