My take on the leap! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

3.2k

Users

10

Likes

80

Frequent Posters

Free_Rein thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: SRKisLove



I was wondering whether I should comment or not bur well, whatever. This isn't to do with this show particularly, just what I think about the maker's post (I haven't read the rest of the comments!)


Okay I have watched three (four, if you count DBO separately) Gul shows now. My fav was and will always be QH season 1. ❤️

So, when KSG quit QH as Asad, we all boycotted the show. ( I am not a KSG fan but I loved his portrayal of Asad). Even the trps sank badly, because for both tv and online audience, KSG was Asad. The new guy just couldn't gel in.
So, the makers quickly ended that season, and took a generation leap. Surbhi Jyoti was retained as Zoya's twin daughters, Sanam and Seher, while rest everyone changed.
The new pairing of Surbhi and KVB was a hit too, I liked it too, though not as much as Asya.


What I am trying to demonstrate is that if the makers replace some other actress as Annika, then it would definitely not work, because the audience connects SC's face to Annika, no one else can be Annika for them. There is no Annika, without Surbhi.

But there can be IB without her, just as there was QH without Asad/Zoya, replaced with Aahil/Sanam.


If they change the storyline altogether, and get a new CHARACTER pairing then it might work. Because Nakuul's face will no longer be associated with Shivaay, in the new pairing. It will be the face for some other character, his son I guess, then.


I know online audience is all about pairings and ships. But honestly trp audience doesn't care for that. They care for characters. If they cared for actors, then shows with the best actors or most popular actors would have done well, but that is not the case.

For the tv audience, Shivika's story would be over, and they will move on to the next generation's story. If the Gen next story is told well, then who knows, IB might rebound on the trp list (from where it has been expunged since a month or more). And trp is all that matters for Star


This is nothing new, its being done several times on tv and films before.

If they get a famous actress opposite NM like Drashti or someone, then their pairing will be huge too, just like KVB brought his own fanbase to QH.

Thats just how industry works. *shrugs*



QH was aired in Zee channel which doesn't scrap the shows so quickly even when the trps are bad but star plus is not like that.The channel already gave enough chance for IB by providing 1 hour episodes for almost 4 months which was for the first time in the Indian Tv history for a daily soap.I didn't know any info about QH but i think KSG was not stayed in the show for 2.5 yrs long like Surbhi chandna before being chucked out/quit.


And one more point,trp viewers are women,so they connect more with FL than ML,so KSG like male character doesn't impact the viewers to such an extent a FL would impact.


And the most important thing is Writers of the show will be sufficient to make this leap a disaster.Mark my words.


As you mentioned the name Drasti,i tell you her role was hated by many viewers in other show for whatever reasons we know.so it needs some time for viewers to forget that character played by her,so if suppose she took the role as FL in the show which was already established and is ready to end,there is very less chance of people liking her character that too after they chucked out such iconic character like Anika and with a crap writer like Harneet.


@bold
You are contradicting your own statements,First you are telling trp viewers doesn't see actors popular or not and then again you are saying if they get famous actor like Drasti,the pairing will be huge too??
SRKisLove thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#12



Lol yeah, just realized. 😆


DD was just an example. DD's character in the other show was the most pathetic she's ever played.

If she plays a good character like she did in Madhubala, then the show might work. Just an example, there are plenty of other actresses in the industry.


Popular actors don't make a difference if the characters don't connect to the audience. But if the character is good, then popular actors add to it.


Also, KSG's exit did impact QH very badly. Thats why they had to end Asad and Zoya's story, and start with a fresh story with new generation. Thats the point I made. Read completely. 🥱

If it worked for QH with the same production (4Lions), it can work with IB too. I guess. Lets see. Annika's character is ending. Shivaay's character is ending. Its not like they are getting a new girl for Shivaay, then it would have been a problem.


And its a little presumptuous to think that Nakuul cannot have good chemistry with anyone else. 😆
I am not a Nakuul fan, you know, but he has only worked with two actress (for a long time) till now. There are 20 other actresses lined up. Who is to say that a new actor or character can't work?


Chill guys!
Surbhi was getting wasted in this show, doing the same thing over and over again.
Personally I want to see her doing some other good show. Maybe try a negative character this time.
IB would make her do the same shiz. The audience is also exhausted now.



TDLR: No one is taking Annika's place, that is always Surbhi. The character and Shivika as a ship will end in the show, to be replaced by another. So, there is no reason why it should not work (I mean if forced wedding trope can work in all Gul shows, irrespective of couples/actors, then this is also a kind of trope, isme kya kami hai?)


Edited by SRKisLove - 7 years ago
Free_Rein thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: SRKisLove




Lol yeah, just realized. 😆


DD was just an example. DD's character in the other show was the most pathetic she's ever played.

If she plays a good character like she did in Madhubala, then the show might work. Just an example, there are plenty of other actresses in the industry.


Popular actors don't make a difference if the characters don't connect to the audience. But if the character is good, then popular actors add to it.


Also, KSG's exit did impact QH very badly. Thats why they had to end Asad and Zoya's story, and start with a fresh story with new generation. Thats the point I made. Read completely. 🥱

If it worked for QH with the same production (4Lions), it can work with IB too. I guess. Lets see. Annika's character is ending. Shivaay's character is ending. Its not like they are getting a new girl for Shivaay, then it would have been a problem.


And its a little presumptuous to think that Nakuul cannot have good chemistry with anyone else. 😆
I am not a Nakuul fan, you know, but he has only worked with two actress (for a long time) till now. There are 20 other actresses lined up. Who is to say that a new actor or character can't work?


Chill guys!
Surbhi was getting wasted in this show, doing the same thing over and over again.
Personally I want to see her doing some other good show. Maybe try a negative character this time.
IB would make her do the same shiz. The audience is also exhausted now.



TDLR: No one is taking Annika's place, that is always Surbhi. The character and Shivika as a ship will end in the show, to be replaced by another. So, there is no reason why it should not work (I mean if forced wedding trope can work in all Gul shows, irrespective of couples/actors, then this is also a kind of trope, isme kya kami hai?)



When did i say KSG leaving dint impact the audience??😕I told FL leaving would have more impact than the ML leaving on trp women.


Nakuul can having good chemistry with other actresses idk,but i am confident on the writers for one more disaster like IPK3.


Surbhi is getting wasted for what reason?Isn't the crappy writing the reason??So the ideal option would be changing the writer and show some creativity without showing repetitive stuff on the talented actors!!

@TDLR

Forced shadis work in different shows but not in the same shows when it is repeated again and again.Yeah lets see what happens.But before forced shadis itself the shows like IPk and IB worked with trp viewers.So it depends on how the story would attract the viewers and continue to sustain with trps atleast until forced shadi track starts.I think they doesn't start forced shadi as first track itself after leap to sustain the trps lets see😆
Edited by ...Nihara... - 7 years ago
Naju2388 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#14
Whatever is happening I wish nakul Mehta shaves his beard off!
Then my obsession for ishqbaaz will well truly be over!
Hriju321 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Naju2388

Whatever is happening I wish nakul Mehta shaves his beard off!

Then my obsession for ishqbaaz will well truly be over!


🤣

I agree totally,wholeheartedly!

Come on NM! Shave and release me from the bondage!😆
1097129 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#16
Whoa seeing at few comments seems like they r more intereste to discredit surbhi for everything she did in past 2.5 yes & bash her as they have an opportunity .no doubt I see whose fans comments r those.
ithihaas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Hriju321


🤣

I agree totally,wholeheartedly!

Come on NM! Shave and release me from the bondage!😆


No...Let me drool over him offscreen...😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".