Completely nonsense post and complete false blames on Roop I don't understand what are you trying to prove and what you want to achieve through misleading serial and wrongly bashing Roop with such false blames ? .If you are frustrated with Ishika and don't want to see her with Roop then express it like others do I too hate Ishika Its justified to hate her I too think she is not worthy of Roop and can never be but its not right to falsely blame and bash Roop If you want to see Wagehlas not Patels then express it to makers but why falsely blaming Roop and bashing him ? Its not your opinion or my opinion when you are completely misleading the serial and totally falsely blaming Roop just to bash him
Shashank can play villains according to you but he should not play Roop? Why ?Roop is worse than villains too ? Why? What wrong he has ever done ?You are showering false praises on Shamsher who is actually very wrong in the way he behaves with his wife and children but bashing Roop by falsely blaming him , misleading the serial All your blames on him are completely false and i don't understand why you keep falsely blaming Roop ?You really think people havent watched the serial? In one of your previous posts you were falsely blaming him as obsessive and stalking Ishika ? Neither he is ever shown obsessive nor he stalked her so it was complete false blame by you misleading the serial In another post you were saying he abandoned his family Dads always have aspirations from their children it does not mean children should abandon them ?Seriously ? In which scene of the serial it is shown Roop abandoned his dad because his dad had some aspirations from him? It is Shamsher who brutally abandoned him abusing him he is not worthy of being his son Shamsher threw Roop out of the house just because Roop does not want to be police officer He never talked to Roop with love and respect after Roop refused to take admission in military science in college but chose hotel management and shamsher from then on is always being abusive to Roop , mistreating Roop and insulting him inside and outside the house both. Inviting outsiders to insult his own son He still tried to force Roop to be a police officer but when Roop refused at the interview He brutally abandoned him and threw him out of the house and allowed him in only because of sick Kamla that too after taking rent from him Shamsher did not even let Roop meet with his sick mother at hospital before taking money from him This is the so called great father and great husband you are praising and saying he needs to sort out Roop ?When actually its Shamsher who needs to be sorted out by Roop, Shamsher needs to redeem but even Roop cannot sort him out until Shamsher himself does not want to change himself You cannot force anyone to change when the person himself does not want to change and Shamsher does not want to change right now no matter what Roop does
Now too its Shamsher who brutally disowned , discarded , abandoned and dumped Roop in front of all because he married Ishika Roop never abandoned him and his family so your post should be targeted to Shamsher Abandonment is the worst form of humanity because this is what Shamsher did, brutally abandoned , discarded , dumped his own son just for his fake ego but you are bashing Roop by falsely blaming him he brutally abandoned his loving dad and family ? Please tell me the scene where Roop brutally abandoned his family saying this useless family is not worthy being of being my family ?Its this worst father Shamsher who brutally abandoned him abusing him in front of all and rejected him as his son saying he is not worthy of being his son so why are you blaming Roop?When did Roop even think Shamsher is not a worthy father?
Shamsher loves no one more than himself and his ego He loves himself and his conservative norms and his big ego more than anyone Whats the use of loving his son and his family in the corner of his heart when he mistreats them so much and hurts them so much ?Just because he is a father it does not give him license to mistreat his children He never try to understand his wife and children , never give them freedom to take decisions of their lives and wants to make them his slaves Whatever Shamsher says they should do bowing their heads down and he brutally abandoned , disowned his only son whom he claims to the love the most and his eldest daughter Himani only because they dared to go against him and take decisions of their lives He does not wish to even see his son in law Himanshu's face just because he supports his wife who is Shamsher's daughter because in Shamsher s regressive and conservative mentality women should only stay at home and serve their husbands they cannot study and do job This is not a how a good man , a loving father behaves . You are saying Roop never fulfilled any of his dad's wish This is totally wrong Roop has always fulfilled Shamsher's justified and right wishes but he does not fulfill Shamsher's wrong wishes Why Roop should fulfill his father's wrong wishes ?When parents are wrong its children's duty to show them right path and this is what Roop is always doing since childhood Making his father realize where he is wrong but Shamsher does not want to understand. One day he might but right now he is too stubborn
Shamsher wishes to make his son male chauvinist but Roop does not want to be , Roop believes in equality between men and women and can't mistreat women to show his manhood and shamsher hates this Do you count this Roop's fault he is not fulfilling his dad s wish and not being an MCP as his father wishes him to be ?Because you are blaming Roop he never fulfilled his loving dad's any wish ? Then this is what Shamsher's wishes Roop should be a male chauvinist ,a misogynist because this is what is definition of Asli Mard for shamsher Shamsher hates the fact Roop is very caring and protective towards his mom and sisters He hates the fact that since childhood Roop loves to help his mom in the kitchen ,he loves cooking , loves to apply mehendi on his mom's and sisters hands ,loves to comb their hairs and make their pigtails , loves to play with his sisters so do you make that Roop' s fault he is such a bad son,he is inhumane ,a coward , not a worthy hero because he is not fulfilling dad's wish by not doing all these things ? Shamsher hates the fact Roop stops him from mistreating his mom and sisters Shamsher hates Roop s best friend is a girl ( Palak ) Should Roop break his friendship with Palak to fulfill his dad's wish because Shamsher is not very fond of Palak nor likes Roop's friendship with a girl ?Roop has always been a topper in his school and making his dad proud but shamsher just could not digest his closeness with his mother and sisters and send him away from them to military school and Roop did not disappoint him in military school he made him proud of him by standing first in everything and winning every trophy and medal but Shamsher cannot digest Roop does not want to be a police officer Shamsher started mistreating Roop after he chose to study hotel management instead of military science Shamsher refused to pay for his college fees and Roop started working at a garage to pay for his fees and Shamsher hates it How dare he He is tarnishing the reputation of mahaan DSP by working as mechanic Neither he wants to pay for Roop's fees himself neither he is happy if Roop is working hard and paying for his expenses himself If he is loving father he should be proud that his son is not dependent on him for his expenses and works hard and is paying for his all expenses himself But for shamsher is fake ego is everything He insults Roop in front of every tom , dick and harry as a shame for him and not a worthy son just because Roop does not wishes to be a police officer and wants to have a career in hotel management which according to shamsher is a cheap profession Its not wrong of Shamsher to dream for his son but its wrong to force his son to fulfill his dream and trying to shatter to his son's dreams for his dream A good parent support the dreams of his children but Shamsher planned and plotted to shatter the dreams of his son , tried to force the principal to rusticate Roop from college by putting any false blame on him tarnishing his son's reputation Loving father ?Is this how a loving father behaves ? Shamsher was extremely angry when principal's conscience woke up and he refused to throw Roop out of college Shamsher cannot see his son is brilliant student at his college Pride of the college The college's principal is so proud him but Shamsher does not care because he is mad at Roop for not fulfilling his unjustified wishes Shamsher wishes to Roop to boycott Himani just because she became a police officer and Roop is not boycotting her Shamsher hates this Shamsher wishes to send Jigna to her abuser husband and her abusive in laws Roop is standing with Jigna and not letting Shamsher send her back to that abuser and Shamsher is angry at Roop for this and blames him for ruining his reputation These are wishes of shamsher How can you even blame Roop for not fulfilling such wrong wishes of his father ?
You are falsely blaming Roop for not seeing tears in father's eyes Really ? Its his father who cannot see the tears in his son's eyes that how much his brutal behavior hurts his son The father who does not respect his children does not deserve respect but Shamsher is so lucky he blessed with such children who still respect him even after he never respects them He is lucky to have such son who loves and respect him even after he does not respect him and insults him every time everywhere for not being worthy of his son
Shamsher is not wrong to hate Ishika He is totally justified What he said about Ishika is true except she did not let Roop be a police officer No its not because of her It was Roop's own choice but Shamsher is right to be angry at Ishika and hate her for doing drama at police recruitment interview insulting both father and son because she was desperate to defame Roop to please her evilness but Shamsher is wrong totally wrong the way he behaved with Roop How brutally he abused him as Nikamma , Nakara , sharabi and disowned him in front of everyone he is not my son From shamsher's action it was quite clear he does not want Roop and Ishika in his house and Roop cannot force him to accept him with Ishika so it was right for him to move out Roop did not misbehave with his father nor he abandoned his father He knows somewhere in his heart his father loves him thats why he said i will come when you call me i have faith one day you will so i don't understand why you are bashing Roop ? Roop neither abandoned his mom and sisters They themselves want him to be with Ishika
Roop's mind did not think about marrying Ishika in college He did not marry her because he was dying to marry her Its selfish parents of Ishika who begged to him so much to force him to marry her That pathetic selfish mean Rupesh used his critical condition and begged to Roop so much to force Roop to marry Ishika Ishika is the one who gave her consent first and begged to Roop to marry her but Roop did not took her hand immediately he looked at her mother who was standing with hands folded begging to him Roop's intention was only to give a new life to dying man and save this family and his yes actually gave Rupesh a new life otherwise he was dying with his drama for this marriage Rupesh and Kanchan are wrong here They did injustice with Roop They only cared to make and secure the life of their good for nothing , useless daughter Ishika They don't care for Roop. Ishika she cheated Roop just to give her father temporary happiness till he recovers. Rupesh Kanchan and Ishika are extremely wrong They are using Roop for their personal gain None of them care for Roop I totally agree with @Candycanemissy on this Roop is shown to be the victim of Ishika and her parents selfishness but there is no fault of Roop in this so its wrong to bash him What he could do ?Storm out of the ICU and let Rupesh get another heart attack and die Ishika is the one who agreed first but she cheated him
Again you are wrong in saying he staying in patels only to be a house bride , slave No He is only temporary staying there because right now Rupesh and Kanchan need him to be there If Vaishnavi would not have called him then Mota Kaka and his sons would have very easily threw a sick and helpless Rupesh and his wife out of the house and taken control of all the whole house Roop saved them Ishika did not marry him from her heart , she lied but Roop did not lie even though he was forced to marry her but he accepted this marriage He did not lie and did fake marriage so he cannot leave Rupesh and Kanchan in helpless condition when they need so much The fact he cannot leave Ishika there alone as well because she cannot handle anything She herself wants Roop to stay there till her father recovers She is using him to protect her parents He will move out once Rupesh recovers and he is secure in the house .
I too want Roop Ishika's marriage to end because Ishika does not deserve him She continues to mistreat him Rupesh and Kanchan did wrong with Roop to make their pathetic daughter's life and release themselves from her responsibility but they ruined his life but this does not mean you should start bashing Roop for no fault for his Your all blames on him are wrong and unjustified
Edited by Mehek134 - 6 years ago
Rules & Announcements
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2
