What's wrong with YRKKH makers ?

abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Am I the only one who feels that YRKKH has lost its potential to deal with issues properly ?

- Naira unable to conceive was dealt badly, then


- Shubhams death was fast paced and a huge mockery of medical profession.


- And today we saw them mocking law. From the start of this divorce issue, the lawyers looked like clowns and the way they have shown the whole process was SHEER Stupidity.


What is wrong with YRKKH Cv's ? Where did that accuracy and realistic way of handling things has gone. Is this the effect of the show running from past 10 years ? In the name of handling things in a new way are YRKKH makers bending towards other serial ways of dealing or are the writers changed ?


Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

4.1k

Users

7

Likes

26

Frequent Posters

A HUGE FAN thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Not to mention Akshara's death was handled poorly and forgotten as well as Naitik's health issues.
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
I think most of the focus is on kaira most of the time as they are all what people care about to be honest
so they just gloss over everything else
abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: A HUGE FAN

Not to mention Akshara's death was handled poorly and forgotten as well as Naitik's health issues.


I did not watch that part, so no idea.
abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I think most of the focus is on kaira most of the time as they are all what people care about to be honest

so they just gloss over everything else


But atleast they should show it properly, like this divorce case, this was Kaira track, so it could have been handled properly..


When did 2 parties meet at same office for consulting their lawyers, then what is the use of hiring 2 lawyers, just hire the same lawyer and finish off.


And from when did high profile lawyers started running around and behaving like clowns - in reality fools. These 2 lawyers are behaving like those cheap lawyers who has got their careers first case.


And from.when did divorce started being branded at the drop of hat.
Pinkangel1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
I've been having the same thought about YRKKH
It has lost its charm it isn't the same like it used to be when I started watching it. Before they used to focus on everyone's lives in the show, From Dadajii to Anshuman (Akshara's cousin)
Now its not the same thing
They completely forgot about Gayu,Mishti and Karishma they're no where to be found or mentioned about in the show.
No offense to Kaira lovers but this show has become only about them. I guess lot of actors left YRKKH because of this reason because ever since Naira and Karthik got married its always about Goenkas and nothing else.
Everything is being handled poorly and effortlessly.
The CV are just going with flow.
How I wish they do something to bring back the charm in this show like it was before.
A HUGE FAN thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I think most of the focus is on kaira most of the time as they are all what people care about to be honest

so they just gloss over everything else


True, but these are the same writers (mostly anyways) who did well with Naitik and Akshara journey which was realistic and well storylines.
reima thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Pinkangel1

I've been having the same thought about YRKKH
It has lost its charm it isn't the same like it used to be when I started watching it. Before they used to focus on everyone's lives in the show, From Dadajii to Anshuman (Akshara's cousin)
Now its not the same thing
They completely forgot about Gayu,Mishti and Karishma they're no where to be found or mentioned about in the show.
No offense to Kaira lovers but this show has become only about them. I guess lot of actors left YRKKH because of this reason because ever since Naira and Karthik got married its always about Goenkas and nothing else.
Everything is being handled poorly and effortlessly.
The CV are just going with flow.
How I wish they do something to bring back the charm in this show like it was before.



I fully agree although I would say that the focus on Naira Kartik is central like Akshara and Naitik-
The beauty of this show is its positive depiction of relationships- where did that go one wonders. Why is Suwarna shown as a negative character all of a sudden when she was so fond of Naira and had stepped into the space left by Akshara. No mother in law is like that- inconsistent.
They have indeed forgotten about Gayu, Mishti, Kuhu? . this show has taken on rough language which it did not prefer earlier, scenes that are supposedly sensational [for my maids at least] and this sensationalism is no better than those shown in other shows where the woman changes her face [how does that happen] etc., totally unrealistic versions of everyday life are being shown with no adequate attention and justice done to any particular track. We would like to see how Naitk copes with his health, but they have forgotten that he is depressed- this event should have led him to take a drastic action, if depicted properly, but he is shown as very calm, taking it matter of fact. Looks like logic has been sacrificed for TRPs. The show will lose its faithful followers.
Apple_Amber thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I think most of the focus is on kaira most of the time as they are all what people care about to be honest

so they just gloss over everything else


Agree that people love Kaira and they have a great fan following.

Also agree that there exist many fans who want to see Kiara together come what may, irrespective of what is going in the story! Even if Naira is abused by Karthik!

But plot and plot handling also matters. I for one not comfortable with the change that the topic maker has expressed.

Yeh Rishta is loosing its quintessence slowly ..may be because they are exhausted.

But still its number one show on Indian telly in my opinion.
I loved the way the leap started. But was disappointed with some of the characters ie Dadi (Same selfish hypocrite) Singhnaiyas (With their almost Zero Self respect) Naksh ( a character who suffered a total undoing) Though I liked Devyani and Manish.

Manish's outburst was good! Equally good were Devyani's one liners but I hope she was given some more fury! Did not like the entry of Nani...found it so uncalled for. All of a sudden they started putting Kaira together in the same folly frame, whereas in actuality it was Karthik who humiliated Naira, but was never questioned!

I am not liking the amalgamation of flashbacks with the present reality its overdone! and the weird juxtaposition of Karthik's aggression with some stupid comic scene in the next episode, it sound giddy more than comic to me.

I feel what ruined the mood after a perfect start was missing aggression of Naksh and Singhnaiyas post leap! While we got spoilers that there would be rivalry between families post leap. Dadi's character was not changed, rather they made her duly depressing, first by making her the same Hitler for Naira and Singhnaiyas and second by making her docile and submissive for Suwrana. Karthik playing a confused victim card was ridiculous. Certain things cvz failed in miserably ie On the day of cremation he was searching for Niara and literary said I asked her to leave for the time being! While he never second his mom when she kept shouting she can't comeback to her house?

He got the reason that she was injured but then he comes to stand One! You killed my brother so l can't forgive/forget! Then what wa sthat sentence , I asked her to leave for the time being?


Rest is okay!


This is the only show that I have been watching since its inception.

I love Jennifer Winget so sometimes I catch a glimpse of Bepannah. But I have not watched that either after Zoya started handling her husband's business. I am a huge fan of Pakistani shows like Kankar, Zindagi Gulzaar hai, Humsafar, Mere Harzai, Mere Humdum, Feriha mere dost and literary every pak show. They make me feel positive about the role of tv in shaping positive attitudes.

I hope they show a guilty Karthik. He should realize the gravity of his irrational aggression and teh damage that it has caused to Naira and Singhnaiyas. Plus the cvz should stop equating Naira and Karthik when it comes to share the blame game of committing 'mistake' what Karthik did was not a mistake it was harassment!

TO my view Naira is not at fault its just that she did not try harder (which cud have translated into compromising with her self esteem) but that was because Karthik failed her and broke her completely. But even if she did not try to mend it she neither tried to disgrace it, In fact she ended it gracefully but he and his puppet clan of hypocrites had problems with that too.

Karthik was set at a high pedestal and I think its the high time that the cvz take him down to the pit . for my sanity at least.

Last as I said earlier I am happy with the divorce. But I want to see Niara emerging stronger and Karthik falling miserably bursting Suwarna;'s bubble. I beg cvz to end the flashbacks they make no sense and consume all the time. In the last episode they kept walking and walking which was annoying.

Cvz can show Suwarna now. She can come up with Aashis's alliance. But plz dont drag Naira in it. Otherwise we will ahve to bear Karthik playing victim again, you cant understand me you thought I wud remarry and bla bla...Rather it should be from Niara-''Why should I understand you, we are divorced am not liable to you!''

Plz keep both tracks separate Niara's college and Kaashi track! Don't mix! Dont want Nani to add more stupidity in pushing Naira to beg Karthik to mend .

Nnai and Keerti making silly plans trying to trouble Aashi and her mom wud be creepiest of creep thing if it happens. I was not happy with Nani's entry, but when it was confirmed I hoped she wud be aggressive like Devyani but hell she is the same old Karthik worshiper.
Did not say a single word to Suwrana but she had the guts to accuse Dadi and Manish lol So she too knows who is the boss!
Pinkangel1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: reima




I fully agree although I would say that the focus on Naira Kartik is central like Akshara and Naitik-
The beauty of this show is its positive depiction of relationships- where did that go one wonders. Why is Suwarna shown as a negative character all of a sudden when she was so fond of Naira and had stepped into the space left by Akshara. No mother in law is like that- inconsistent.
They have indeed forgotten about Gayu, Mishti, Kuhu? . this show has taken on rough language which it did not prefer earlier, scenes that are supposedly sensational [for my maids at least] and this sensationalism is no better than those shown in other shows where the woman changes her face [how does that happen] etc., totally unrealistic versions of everyday life are being shown with no adequate attention and justice done to any particular track. We would like to see how Naitk copes with his health, but they have forgotten that he is depressed- this event should have led him to take a drastic action, if depicted properly, but he is shown as very calm, taking it matter of fact. Looks like logic has been sacrificed for TRPs. The show will lose its faithful followers.



Very well said. Swarna no one really knows what has happened to her character. So much negativity. I saw Rajan Shahi interview where he stated that Kaira are representing this generation life (2018) I don't think there's anything realistic about that. Both Naira and Karthik use harsh words for each other. If they do go back off course they would, How are they gonna face each other because I know if they are representing 2018 generation it's gonna be difficult for them to go back to living same old normal life.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26 · 2 months ago

I watched a scene where DoormatBhira calls AbhiMaan perfect couple and they aim to make Nibbiara and Abhir same? Seriously? Do makers really...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima · 1 years ago

Welcome to the YRKKH Weekly TRP thread! This will be the official thread to post and discuss about the weekly online and offline TRPs of Yeh...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Arziya · 1 months ago

YRKKH SM updates, BTS and Spoilers Thread #128

Hello everyone! Welcome to the YRKKH BTS and Spoilers Thread! Please share any clips about upcoming story arcs or Behind the Scenes clips that...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01 · 1 months ago

Akshara’s father owned multiple 5-star hotels, and Akshara obviously inherited that wealth. She also worked in a diamond business with Naitik —...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: .StarryPhoenix · 9 years ago

!! Warm Welcome to All Dear Friends !! Here You all can post all ur creations related to Y e h R i sht a Ky a K e hl a t a H a i c r e a t i o n

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".