Rajeev Masand Interview: Aish Rejected HNY Lead Role because of AB - Page 4

I loved HNY. I am so not into that the so called Intelligent cinema, I get bored with regional movies. I love masla, so called mindless movies I enjoy😆 Aishwarya is looking so beautiful with that red color and her personality is changing for the better. Thank God she turned down the movie, I liked dp in it

Originally posted by: Mascarpone

Its the opposite for me. I hardly watch interviews and last video of hers I watched may be the US talk shows or Oprah where I found her annoying. So I find her relatable here and can't believe how fast she is talking.

Originally posted by: grumpydwarf

When I was watching it I was wondering where was the dancing?😆 There wasn't enough for something that was suppose to be dancing oriented.

IMO this is going to be controversial but I consider Aish superior to Deepika in terms of acting too. But Aish hasn't proved her mettle in comedy yet. So who knows how the character would have shaped up. Deepika is overrated.

Ash is a disaster in comedy, watch Hum Kisise Kum Kahin, action replay. Would've butchered Mohini with her screechy voice.

Originally posted by: Tasbah

Besides ADHM the last movies I remember watching with Ash were Jodha-Akbar and Dhoom 2 because I took this long break from BW so I don't think I can judge Ash. It's been too long😆

But they say comedy is not easy for actors and Farah's kind of comedy is that kind that can make you cringe and annoy the hell out of you😆The only scene with DP that made me cringe in HNY was the lift scene where their thoughts are heard so I think she did a good job😆

Each has its own strengths. I don't see Deepika doing a taal, raincoat or Jodha like Aish. I found Mastani and Padmavat very mediocre. Again focus was on other actors. I did HNY and she was good. Again a lot of comic affect was added by the accent and the well written lines. But Aish suits Indian roles more. She hasn't proven her mettle in comedy. Meanwhile Deepika has had some success in Chennai Express and HNY. Overall I find her very mechanical still. She hasn't overly impressed me in anything. The way Aish has in certain performances. She receives passing marks by in most of her appreciated performances. Yeah she is more consistent then Aish in passing performances. She can do semi-justice to a wider range of roles.

Good she didn't did as Abhishek had the funniest role and did very well in an otherwise baklol movie.
Plus Deepika is a better choice than Aishu, who knows only two ways of acting hamming or mumbling.

eajy nahin hain Mohini ka dance

Just realised that if Ash would've done HNY, she would've done Lovely too. No thank you. That's Deepika's best dance song according to me and Ash can hardly move these days, looking at Mohabbat. Jo hota hai achhe ke liye hota hai.