Raazi: Alia Bhatt a miscast?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Male-Chauvinist-Pig

@Ur-Miserable

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 7 years ago

#31

@Moon: Maybe we are from different school of acting analysis as I respectfully disagree about Shraddha. She did a terrible job in Haseena Parker. She was not in Kaminey, that had PC, she was in Haider where she was passable.
Also this Kjo guiding thing is a what if. We cannot say what would have happened if it was Disha, Kriti or Parineeti in her place. Discrediting Alia of everything is like saying Arjun was nothing because Lord Krishna orchestrated everything to help him.
While Parineeti would have done the acting part well, but looks wise, she is most blah looking actress in the industry.
Parineeti can blame herself for her slow growth when she rejected a script like Piku.

Quote

MoonOrchid

@MoonOrchid

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: U_R_MY_BITCH
@Moon: Maybe we are from different school of acting analysis as I respectfully disagree about Shraddha. She did a terrible job in Haseena Parker. She was not in Kaminey, that had PC, she was in Haider where she was passable.
Also this Kjo guiding thing is a what if. We cannot say what would have happened if it was Disha, Kriti or Parineeti in her place. Discrediting Alia of everything is like saying Arjun was nothing because Lord Krishna orchestrated everything to help him.
While Parineeti would have done the acting part well, but looks wise, she is most blah looking actress in the industry.
Parineeti can blame herself for her slow growth when she rejected a script like Piku.

URMB: glad we can chat :)

I like it when we can compare different views and we don't all have to always agree (as long as I don't have some IF fans screaming rude words over pages, I can manage a debate 😆).

Sraddha: Yepp... my bad sorry ..meant Haider. Haseena ..IMO..she didn't get enough guidance ..or role wan't well fleshed. I get what you say but I could see the talent beyond the role.

She has 'gravitas'. You feel she is ..embodying the character. (I am very interested to see what she does with her movie with Prabhas.)

Pari - to me- seems she got SO great start then everyone lumped her with 'giggly girl'.. again not enough 'meat' in roles to help her build reputation. Cannot believe she rejected Piku. Oh well..she really needs advice in role choice.

I feel the same about Radhika, Bhumi and others that don't get a lot of good roles... so it's not just Pari.

I wasn't discrediting Alia. Read again.I said she was good many times. I just don't feel that this is her best. Heck I loved her more in UP - now THAT was a great, great role. To me, her best to date.

True, the KJO/guiding is a what if...Wish they did darn auditions in BW..so everyone got fair chances and roles went to suitable people..

I probably doubt a lot of castings because of that.

And also feel a bit sad because I know there are countless other actresses out there that could pull such roles and are not getting them

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Shaitaan Haiwan

@Shaitan-Haiwan

Stunner

+ 8

Posted: 7 years ago

#33

Shraddha reminds me of the pre-Cocktail Deepika - looks good but no other skill and flat voice ( Deepika still does sound monotone) perhaps SLB is the only person who could mold Shrddha , because I personally feel Shraddhas best performance is still Aashiqui-2! She did quite well there. But she needs to work like 100 times harder to be where Alia is. Shraddha dances well too like in Sun Saathiya - but again I don't think she's worth investing in. I rather see if Jahnvi or Sara can act instead of waiting for Shraddha to improve

And sorry... there is no way Parineeti could do a Raazi. She's only good for her loud mouth North Indian characters. She couldn't even pull off that item song with did with Varun. She is completely useless

Edited by Shaitan-Haiwan - 7 years ago

Quote

return_to_hades

@return_to_hades

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 7 years ago

#34

She's supposed to be a very naive twenty-something college girl. I don't think there are many others who could genuinely pass of as that young or innocent. Sure Alia is not the only actor and they could have done a casting call for auditions. But with such a female lead centric script and off beat plot - a newcomer would be too much of a risk. Why not bank on Alia's starpower to cover risks.

Quote

Male-Chauvinist-Pig

@Ur-Miserable

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 7 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: MoonOrchid

URMB: glad we can chat :)
I like it when we can compare different views and we don't all have to always agree (as long as I don't have some IF fans screaming rude words over pages, I can manage a debate😆).

😊

Sraddha: Yepp... my bad sorry ..meant Haider. Haseena ..IMO..she didn't get enough guidance ..or role wan't well fleshed. I get what you say but I could see the talent beyond the role.
She has 'gravitas'. You feel she is ..embodying the character. (I am very interested to see what she does with her movie with Prabhas.)

well end results matter, no matter how hard she tried and so on, if she cannot deliver, than she is not worth it. And I don't see any acting bone in Shraddha, maybe someday a director good enough to restraint her and give her a role suited for her skills. But until than she is not going to do much.Well if the female role is anything like Bahubaali, than it will be good for her. But than again, it had Anushka, comparing Anushka and Shraddha Kapoor is like comparing Xavi with Henderson. IMO Shraddha should stick to the commercial movies and not try her hand in something she cannot do. At one time she was having hits after hits with youngsters and than she thought of starting to act and her downfall started.

Pari - to me- seems she got SO great start then everyone lumped her with 'giggly girl'.. again not enough 'meat' in roles to help her build reputation. Cannot believe she rejected Piku. Oh well..she really needs advice in role choice.

Parineeti is a goner.She is not a star quality, she does not have the hotness of Shraddha nor has the school girl charm of Alia. Hence she at most can be a supporting artist.

I feel the same about Radhika, Bhumi and others that don't get a lot of good roles... so it's not just Pari.

Radhika cannot be a big star, firstly age is not in side. Secondly she is not a commercial star.

Bhumi has 100% record with three hits. She had a meaty role despite being in a Akki movie, doing as much as him in the movie which is rare. Only Amy Jackson in recent years can compare to it.

Her career is on good track.

I wasn't discrediting Alia. Read again.I said she was good many times. I just don't feel that this is her best. Heck I loved her more in UP - now THAT was a great, great role. To me, her best to date.
True, the KJO/guiding is a what if...Wish they did darn auditions in BW..so everyone got fair chances and roles went to suitable people..
I probably doubt a lot of castings because of that.
And also feel a bit sad because I know there are countless other actresses out there that could pull such roles and are not getting them

They may have pulled the role, but would movie have garner box office success?? I doubt.
People harp about Kriti giving BKB, forgetting it was not a hit, and also had Ayushmann who has a decent box office pull.
BKB was a very good movie and I really admire's organic growth, but people tend to overrate her to undermine Alia, who frankly is currently on another level.

Edited by U_R_MY_BITCH - 7 years ago

Quote

448368

Suspended

Posted: 7 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: MoonOrchid

Everywhere I've checked it says Adity is 31. (let's say she is 32, or 33, she looks young anyway)
Where is this 'touching 40' coming from?

Pls do a bit of research, wiki is not a valid source. No way would Aditi look a 20 yr old, she is pretty and I like her but a college going girl lol no.

Edited by Piyatrix - 7 years ago