04/19 Highlights: Prakash learns the truth ; Mowgli Runs Away - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.7k

Users

6

Likes

33

Frequent Posters

mayad thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#11
I'm not sure of the age group of the previous or new writers and I'm at a cultural disadvantage so my take may be misunderstood or thought of as being harsh assuming this were a real life issue. But as an elder on the Forum maybe my opinion might help to put things into perspective or treated as simply just another POV.

As I mentioned sometime ago Avni has a lot of insecurities. She has been through a lot but Aeysa and Neela were her "security blanket" her confidant, her moral compass. Neela more so. She lost both as a result of violent crimes. I won't go into all the atrocities she experienced as a child sufficient to say it has scared her for life. Understandable so. Having said that, Avni never should have taken charge of orphaned children nor should she have taken Mishti with her. The idea of devoting your life to any cause is admirable but only if you have the knowledge and experience to undertake the task. More harm is sometimes done with good intentions. Avni, bless her needs help and that was more evident after Neela's death. So the whole Neelangela angle has really been a case where the character can hide from reality. I'm not sure how these writers came up with that story unless they never intended to have Avni & Neil reunite. They could have shown her as a single mother, with a new indentity, struggling to bring up her child. That would have been more palpable that the orphan angle. I have a friend whose mother pretend to be his sister and he died and never forgave her. A mother is a central figure in your life and to withhold that from a child is very, very, difficult no matter the reasons.

Nonetheless, we are at a point were we cannot change what's happened but moving forward this story can only be written by people who have the experience in dealing with physical and mental trauma and the impact it has on your spouse, family and friends. Avni has made poor choices and continues to make them because she's not dealing with her trust issues and the tunnel vision she's developed. We know why she's this way and our hearts bleed for her but listen to her words " she's bad luck, she only causes pain" etc etc. So how can she make sensible choices? What's the answer?

Having lived thru a lifetime of personal trauma, helping abused women and counselling young children, all I can suggest, assuming this were real, is to get professional help or have the people closest to you know everything so they can help you. Honesty is the only answer. The writers could try having Avni disclose everything to Bebe. Shweta's no use, she says she loves Avni, but , as we've seen, not at the expenses of Neil and for the life of me I cannot understand her obsession with Mitali. Her son needs help and some space to come to terms with his life Avni cannot disclose all of this to Neil without the proper support . It just will not work. Again if it were real.

Neil. Neil could handle the grief of her death, because death brings with it a certain pain that cuts so deep that to just wake up each morning takes all your strength, so you focus on all the good memories to help you carry on. We saw that all to well after the 10 year leap.
Now to suddenly realize that it was all a sham is very difficult to accept. That much the writers got correct. Now to know that you have a 9 year old child! I just don't know how they will spin that!

I don't support the view of character assignation because we are all flawed. So to say the character is being "assinated" is saying that they we're perfect in the first place. It means you are putting these characters up on a pedestal and expecting perfection - rise coloured glasses comes to mind!

At the end of the day, this is what makes this show special! We can all relate to a lot in this show regardless of age or nationality. The main characters are beautifully acted and we have them in our hearts. We want them to "work" because that means hope for us.

Mandy, I took this time to respond because you have invested so much into this show and remain upbeat and positive. I respect that and I thank you for your hard work! We know this story will end well but it will break our hearts until that point. I hope the writers can do justice to this situation. Stay positive and bless you dear child for always taking a few moments fior this oldie!


Rainz thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: .Mandy.

I believe Avni raised her child as an orphan because she couldn't give him those rights he deserved, when Avni had her son her family was still in danger. Fast forward to now Vidyut is dead but now things are much more complicated because once Mowgli knows the truth he does get entangled in Neil and Avni's problems it would be a tug of war between them and in Avni's mind Neil would only stay with her out of obligation for their son.



I guess I'm struggling to understand why she didn't raise him as Nilanjana's son, if not Avni's son and the Khannas heir. Mowgli didn't need to know what family he belonged to, but it seems cruel to deny him the right to know his own mother when she's right there, and instead teach him to view her as a sister. As I rack my brain for an explanation, the only one I can think of is that perhaps Avni denied herself motherhood to punish herself - if Neil couldn't know the joy of being a father then she wouldn't allow herself to feel the joy of being a mother. I think I could somewhat understand that, even though it meant poor Mowgli still suffered. Or maybe it's as simple as Avni believing herself to be so manhoos that she was afraid to even have her own son be tainted by her. Which would be incredibly sad but would maybe help Neil understand how deep her scars go.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".