Didn't like the way Naksh blamed Karthik - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

3k

Users

7

Likes

33

Frequent Posters

janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Apple_Amber

I agree janvi it was not kartik's fault but i wud chose to overlook it because I opine until naira is not found and Naksh is not assured dat Naira is alright everything naksh wud say or shout need to be considered 'heat of the moment'
It was a very normal reaction given his state of mind and the big humiliation dat she underwent.

Ofcourse cvz will give kartik naksh hug scene after dadi apologizes and kartik risks his life in water to save naira.

I loved Naksh.
But I wish tonight they give some screen space to Keerti even if its for 2 scenes.

If Naksh was yelling at the Goenkas and Karthik was present there and Naksh said something to him I would consider that the heat of the moment but Naksh called Karthik and was like listen to me and then said things.
Like I said to a reply in another comment here I understand Naksh is a brother, but am done with Karthik being blamed, mostly by Karthik himself or sometimes by others.
Naira attacked in the flat, Naitik blames Karthik (understand that Naitik is a father and he did apologize later)
Akhilesh and Manish hide about Mansi's truth from Naira but it is Karthik who is shown most guilty, how he would face Naira and all.
Karthik didn't like Kiran's chipku behaviour. He had only wanted to drink a cup of tea with his wife alone so decided to look Kiran for a few minutes. If Naira accidentally got locked instead it wasn't his fault, neither was the short circuit. But in the end it was shown Karthik running behind Kiran for nothing.
Karthik hadn't even known that Manish and Suvarna had a child but at the end blame it on Karthik by saying the child was kept away for him. First Karthik blames himself being like yeh sab mere liye kiya gaya and all, then next day Kirti saying maa ne Karthik ke liye kiya, after that Suvarnas brother on the phone saying Suvarna did it seeing Manish's love for Karthik.
For once creative's spare Karthik, stop blaming that poor guy for everything.
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#12
Yes. If kartik discussed this in the family, dadi would have doubted naira or taunted her .It was probably better than throwing her out like trash in kartik's absence ..Also if the issue was discussed earlier , naira would have told the complete truth to kartik and the family ..

Wth is the problem with naira ? Couldn't she wait outside the house for kartik instead of going for evening walk? Whatever anybody says, till the time her husband has a problem, she has the right in her sasural?


And why should naksh apologize ? Kartik said meaner things to naksh when kirti was involved ..And they will continue to say so when it's the question of their sisters
Edited by _charu_ - 7 years ago
misaki thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#13
I'm sorry Janvi but I completely disagree with the post. I honestly didn't feel that Naksh over reacted at all. It's what I would expect any brother who loves his sister like he does to react in a situation like that.
Firstly, he blames himself for not being there to save his sister. He doesn't know where Naira was, so he had every right to behave the way he did. Kartik would have done the same thing for Keerti too. In fact we have seen him react much worse. Also, he wasn't really wrong in blaming him, was he?(It wasn't uncalled for, unlike so many other situations where Kartik was blamed for no fault of his🤔) If Kartik had already shared what he knew with Naksh, if not his family, he could have kept an eye out for his sister. Whether or not he would have been there to help her out in that moment is secondary. It's natural for a person who cares so much about his sister to blame him in a situation like that. It made me like him more as a brother more than anything else. I loved Naksh for it!🤗

I also agree with another reply here to the post. The CVs really need to make use of the brilliant actors they have in their ensemble cast rather than making the leads do everything like they are superheroes of some sort. I'm glad Naksh was finally able to shine in the recent episodes again. The writers need to seriously make use of all the wonderful characters that they have created themselves instead of turning them into knuckle heads like the Singhanias are right now. Absolutely worth-less. They saw the lady misbehave with their grand daughter and they stood like freaking puppets. What has this show come to!😡
Edited by misaki - 7 years ago
misaki thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: _charu_

Yes. If kartik discussed this in the family, dadi would have doubted naira or taunted her .It was probably better than throwing her out like trash in kartik's absence ..Also if the issue was discussed earlier , naira would have told the complete truth to kartik and the family ..

Wth is the problem with naira ? Couldn't she wait outside the house for kartik instead of going for evening walk? Whatever anybody says, till the time her husband has a problem, she has the right in her sasural?


And why should naksh apologize ? Kartik said meaner things to naksh when kirti was involved ..And they will continue to say so when it's the question of their sisters


@Bold - 🤣🤣🤣

That cracked me up so bad!

Honestly, the show has started to turn into yet another melodramatic saas-bahu saga! No one in their right mind would firstly stand there and see a person you care about be humiliated in her own house that way. Especially an influential rich family like the Singhanias. That was such a W*F moment.

Secondly, a girl who cares so much about family 'maryada' would have never admitted to being pregnant before marriage in front of such huge crowd.

Thirdly, as you already put, would have waited till K came home or at least held on to her own family.

Basically, you are expecting too much "reality" in the overly-dramatized soap that is 'YRKKH' right now😆
Edited by misaki - 7 years ago
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: misaki


@Bold - 🤣🤣🤣

That cracked me up so bad!

Honestly, the show has started to turn into yet another melodramatic saas-bahu saga! No one in their right mind would firstly stand there and see a person you care about be humiliated in her own house that way. Especially an influential rich family like the Singhanias. That was such a W*F moment.

Secondly, a girl who cares so much about family 'maryada' would have never admitted to being pregnant before marriage in front of such huge crowd.

Thirdly, as you already put, would have waited till K came home or at least held on to her own family.

Basically, you are expecting too much "reality" in the overly-dramatized soap that is 'YRKKH' right now😆


Not expecting it to be real 😆 I know telly soaps are not ..I no longer feel for it so I get irritated and anyone can notice that everything is just put up together randomly ..Anyone who is not that fond of the actors will like it ? I doubt 😕
janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: misaki

I'm sorry Janvi but I completely disagree with the post. I honestly didn't feel that Naksh over reacted at all. It's what I would expect any brother who loves his sister like he does to react in a situation like that.

Firstly, he blames himself for not being there to save his sister. He doesn't know where Naira was, so he had every right to behave the way he did. Kartik would have done the same thing for Keerti too. In fact we have seen him react much worse. Also, he wasn't really wrong in blaming him, was he?(It wasn't uncalled for, unlike so many other situations where Kartik was blamed for no fault of his🤔) If Kartik had already shared what he knew with Naksh, if not his family, he could have kept an eye out for his sister. Whether or not he would have been there to help her out in that moment is secondary. It's natural for a person who cares so much about his sister to blame him in a situation like that. It made me like him more as a brother more than anything else. I loved Naksh for it!🤗

I also agree with another reply here to the post. The CVs really need to make use of the brilliant actors they have in their ensemble cast rather than making the leads do everything like they are superheroes of some sort. I'm glad Naksh was finally able to shine in the recent episodes again. The writers need to seriously make use of all the wonderful characters that they have created themselves instead of turning them into knuckle heads like the Singhanias are right now. Absolutely worth-less. They saw the lady misbehave with their grand daughter and they stood like freaking puppets. What has this show come to!😡

Respect your opinion but mine is still the same I have already spoke in the main post and replied to others, so won't repeat.
Let's agree to disagree on this matter 😊

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47

4 months ago

Why is a woman blamed more for an ema?

I saw many comments here and other social platforms character assassinating Charu but the same people are not saying a word against Abhir. Isn't...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: BangBang_Shilpa

1 months ago

What happened to Naksh & Kirti

They perhaps had a son named Krish. Were they ever shown in Gen 3 or later? Naksh would be grandfather by now, and where's Varsha and Jasmeet?...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26

2 months ago

Maira Naira Daksh Naksh - - Makes sense?

not my idea... Bass instagram par dekha and thoda sensible laga... https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ87FNNTech/?igsh=MXBxNXBwMXBsZ2pqaw==

https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ87FNNTech/?igsh=MXBxNXBwMXBsZ2pqaw==
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

6 months ago

Naksh vs Kairav vs Abhir

Though I might don't ask this question but still I wanna know.. Naksh was described ax a real brother of his sister and a real paraller lead vs...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".