Didn't like the way Naksh blamed Karthik

Page

Next Last

janvi0513

@janvi0513

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

I loved the way Naksh stood up for Naira in front of Goenkas. Loved his powerful dialogues against them. Reminded me of the Naksh at KV time who had supported Naira at name change. The real Naksh whose identity is supposed to be Naira's brother. I would have really loved him after today but then the last two minutes he lost whatever good things I felt for him by blaming Karthik for hiding about knowing the matter.

What would have happened if Karthik told the matter earlier. Dadi would still be against Naira, only difference she might have not thrown her out, but any chance Dadi would get behind Karthik's back she would taunt Naira daily. Another possibility if Karthik spoke up Naksh would then accuse Karthik of mistrusting his sister saying bought the topic up because he doubted Naira and wants answers. And if Naksh has to blame people for hiding the truth then Naira and Karthik both hid equally.

Though should it matter who hid what, even if Naira had actually had an abortion being treated like trash for hiding it was absurd. So what was Naksh trying to say that if everyone knew the truth earlier. What would have happened best everyone would get to know the real truth. So does that mean he thinks if Naira was wrong was that treatment was fair according to him.

I understand that he was supposed to be in his brother form today, so he was angry, but when he phoned Karthik he was calm and he himself said to listen to him clearly and then blamed Karthik, so I didn't find it anything like heat of the moment. He blamed Karthik completely unfairly. Poor Karthik his face when Naksh put everything on his head. Really want a scene where Naksh apologizes to Karthik.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Zara

@Zara151

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

I didn't like that either, that definitely was unfair. Kartik didn't deserve that. I agree with what you have said Janvi.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

janvi0513

@janvi0513

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: Zara151
I didn't like that either, that definitely was unfair. Kartik didn't deserve that. I agree with what you have said Janvi.

What I fear most is Karthik going on a guilt trip. I often noticed Karthik loves blaming himself. I want Karthik yelling at both families and taking care of Naira and if because of Naksh's words we get Karthik blaming himself instead of the families who did wrong am going to be so mad at Naksh

Quote

Zara

@Zara151

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: janvi0513

What I fear most is Karthik going on a guilt trip. I often noticed Karthik loves blaming himself. I want Karthik yelling at both families and taking care of Naira and if because of Naksh's words we get Karthik blaming himself instead of the families who did wrong am going to be so mad at Naksh

Poor Kartik 😭, can't see him in guilt trip again 😭

Quote

janvi0513

@janvi0513

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: Zara151

Poor Kartik 😭, can't see him in guilt trip again 😭

Want to see Karthik blasting like a volcano on the wrong doers, not himself drown in the fire of guilt. I hope we get Karthik standing up strongly against the rest.

Quote

sigrid

@sigrid

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 7 years ago

I agree with you on most points..but I am ok with Nakash saying what to Karthik. He is Naira's brother. If he would have told Nakash at least he would have been there to protect her when Karthik went away. It was brother's love and instinct.

Karthik is going to give good to Dadi for sure...let us see how it plays out. Cvs,so far have done great job..they will do so now too.

Edited by sigrid - 7 years ago

Quote

janvi0513

@janvi0513

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: sigrid
I agree with you on most points..but I am ok with Nakash saying what to Karthik. He is Naira's brother. If he would have told Nakash at least he would have been there to protect her when Karthik went away. It was brother's love and instinct.
Karthik is going to give good to Dadi for sure...let us see how it plays out. Cvs,so far have done great job..they will do so.

I agree he is Naira's brother but I was so happy with him since yesterday that when he just goes and blames Karthik at the end I can't help but feel angry. Plus Karthik's guilt am scared that Karthik will think he is wrong when he isn't.

Quote

A HUGE FAN

@A HUGE FAN

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: sigrid
I agree with you on most points..but I am ok with Nakash saying what to Karthik. He is Naira's brother. If he would have told Nakash at least he would have been there to protect her when Karthik went away. It was brother's love and instinct.
Karthik is going to give good to Dadi for sure...let us see how it plays out. Cvs,so far have done great job..they will do so now too.

This I agree with. Karthik could've informed Naksh so Naira's brother could have saved her. From a brother's side, it is natural feeling as Naksh was hurt that he couldn't save his sister. If the tables were turned and Karthik was in Naksh's place, he would've done the same as well. This is where CVs are lacking in, not having family scenes and dialogues and having leads do everything, not using supportive cast properly. IMO

Edited by A HUGE FAN - 7 years ago

Quote

Amberpreet Maan

@Apple_Amber

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

I agree janvi it was not kartik's fault but i wud chose to overlook it because I opine until naira is not found and Naksh is not assured dat Naira is alright everything naksh wud say or shout need to be considered 'heat of the moment'
It was a very normal reaction given his state of mind and the big humiliation dat she underwent.

Ofcourse cvz will give kartik naksh hug scene after dadi apologizes and kartik risks his life in water to save naira.

I loved Naksh.
But I wish tonight they give some screen space to Keerti even if its for 2 scenes.

Quote

janvi0513

@janvi0513

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: A HUGE FAN

This I agree with. Karthik could've informed Naksh so Naira's brother could have saved her. From a brother's side, it is natural feeling as Naksh was hurt that he couldn't save his sister. If the tables were turned and Karthik was in Naksh's place, he would've done the same as well. This is where CVs are lacking in, not having family scenes and dialogues and having leads do everything, not using supportive cast properly. IMO

As Naira's brother he could have saved her? (I don't get the logic much but) Okay

The best which could have happened is the matter would have got solved. Everyone would have come to know the entire truth.

Still how does that makes Karthik most wrong. The matter is Naira being thrown out and missing. Hiding about PMS is not that big an issue that a person be thrown out, so whether the family knew the truth, didn't know the truth, like I had said on Friday, whether Naira is to say yes or no on Monday Dadi throwing her was wrong. In Naira being thrown out the mistake is only of the families, Kaira hiding or for that matter Sakshi lying has nothing to do with Naira being treated wrong. Even if what Dadi believed was true the treatment was absurd and harsh. In their usual attempt to blame Karthik anyhow creatives have indirectly and unintentionally promoted a regressive thinking through Naksh.

Plus those words coming from Naksh to Karthik was weird. Naksh himself had lied to Karthik's sister and family that he had feelings for Kirti, as he thought his doing good for Naira. For his own sister he kept Karthik's sister/family in the dark would have done it till the end if yash hadn't told Naira, Karthik hadn't seen the video and Kirti didn't step in the room when Karthik spoke the truth, Naksh himself told the the truth, neither made one good attempt to tell the truth. Now when Karthik to protect Naira itself kept everything under wraps he is lecturing him. It is like Ulta chor kotwal ko datte.

Though I understand what you mean by he is Naira's brother that is why am just very disappointed, otherwise I would have been raging with anger, I have had enough of Karthik being blaming/blaming himself for almost everything.

Quote

1 2

Karthik

Didn't like the way Naksh blamed Karthik

Related Topics

Explore Topics