Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

3.3k

Users

13

Likes

93

Frequent Posters

rsnarula67 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#31
@Maleficarum

Whoops! I seem to have stepped on it ...

But, my dear, I have given up on UN's writing completely and am not seriously tuned in to MK.

However, when I drop in now, I try (okay, try is just the operative word) viewing it all from the prism of UN (per his nari shakti dialogues etc etc and all the comments with regard to women's empowerment! blah blah). Basically, the setting of the narrative into the 21st century (!🥱) with regard to equality of the sexes etc etc, but then you suddenly have dialogues which are very regressive. Makes you question ...especially the dialogues ... So I put out my thoughts. If that is complaining ... so be it.😊

with regard to folk tales - I did not infer in anyway that they are below or above.
After all, a belief is a belief: Na maano tho pathar, maano tho bhagwan.

I know that folk tales try to put things in everyday situations of humans - sometimes banal, sometimes not. Depends on the origins/orator/history/geography and so much else ... Everybody knows this ... whatever the beliefs.

Frankly speaking, it is only when I question that I can expect someone with knowledge to enlighten me - which I think is the main purpose of all Puranic and belief oriented stories. Questioning is a must ...

Here of course, the case is more of consistency

With regard to the Annapoorna story and Matangi story - both are really beautiful. I can imagine Pooja Sharma in both avatars with the wonderful known story, and she would do a great job. Sigh, opportunity lost ...
=============


Of course if this was a historical (recently viewed a couple of epis of a historical and laughed myself silly at the storyline, timeline of the characters- in view of known and documented history😆); I would not really comment there. I would just laugh it off, as I did!!
=============
Edited by rsnarula67 - 7 years ago
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#32
@ Reena
Agree with every line you said. Just perfect.
Questioning is the right of every individual be it in daily life or in India forums.

Nobody can take away that right from us. If we feel bad we can express on this plot form. Let those who enjoy Shiv falling in after consuming poison . like and applaud. .I won't..and I stick to my take. If it is there in Sakteya tales..let it be. I won't buy that ever. Certainly not because some writer adopted that and some people endorse that.. I won't change my opinion.


Yes I believe Epics .. Nothing comes even remotely closer to my Ramayan Mahabharat Bhagawat Shiv Puran and other Puranas.. Folk tales ...I won't get fascinated neither do I believe..This is strictly my view and I stand by it.

Annapurna,Matangi Kamala..beautiful stories we have..but I have least expectations.

Finally don't ever curb your questioning spirit. You have every right to do so.

If we like an episode we say it otherwise we criticise.. As simple as that

I always loved your write ups that involved genuine queries and very honest expression of thought. Do continue as always



Lakshmi
rsnarula67 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#33
Hi Lakshmi, Thanks.☺️

I now airdrop in and out of the show -basically channel surfing😛, but I find even from UN's own construct (women's empowerment etc etc), things are awry. So naturally, I do have questions...
====

This Mohini example I have come across so many times. But whether DKDM or MK, the whole construct is on the "Shiv Shakti" oneness and "made only for each other" theme. How can they then bring in Ganga (where there are some beliefs that she is wife no.2) and Mohini vis-a-vis Shiva. The construct of the show is understood and accepted.
ALthough - the Mohini aspect, I have read some stories in which it is said to be a Maya of Narayan and the Goddess together. I don't recall completely. Have to re-read it ...

====

I was missing the DKDM group and still do. Meenakshi was the DT there too (occassionally, she used to really shawl mein lapetke jhoota maro us😆, when we got too OTT). But it was such an enjoyable experience, that I came back to IF when MK started... but ...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".