If Shilpa isn't a bully, then neither is Priyank... - Page 4

Originally posted by: astha36

+1

Originally posted by: xPalkix

Post is about ABC but yall decide to bring in 123.

Originally posted by: denver_diva

Shilpa is an actor.She is showcasing her acting talent, wit and comic timing using her rivarly as plot. It does seem the rivalry is fake as Vikas seems to be a part of this deal. The TV producers who are upset are the ones who wont anyways give her work...they didnt give her work before BB either.

Yes - i agreed with you both Shilpa and Priyank are poking another person. I did not deny that. I did not once say that Priyank is wrong. He can do anything within rules to play his game. I only tried to say Priyank is copying Shilpa and Shilpa is original.Also, Shilpa has a plot, Priyank has no plot to fight so he is coming out as not-quite-convincing. Plus there is absolutely no doubt that Shilpa is a far better actor than Priyank which is why she is entertaining many ...including Salman, while Priyank is anything but entertaining. Also, in Shilpa's case, the fights are so smooth and well executed that it seems like Vikas is involved in her drama and their fight is scripted-- so the question of bullying is questionable.Whereas in Priyank's case- there is no way that was a scripted fight between him and Arshi.

Shilpa has come to the show with a strategy and is following just that- she is not doing it suddenly without a reason just to get footage like Priyank.

I never said Priyank is wrong and Shilpa is right. I said Priyank is copying Shilpa but he is doing a bad job out of it. I did not say he should be reprimanded.I think you misunderstood what I said.

Neither one should be reprimanded. But I am sorry I cannot appreciate both because one performed far better than the other.Like when two people paint the same picture (say a tree) - we dont have to give both the same grades because they both made the same tree...The tree that looks more realistic and better gets more grades. Its a skill based thing...its not mathematical.

Originally posted by: nehlove

I understood what you'r saying and I agree with you that if we only look at this as a scripted performance then Shilpa came out on the top. But is Vikas such a good actor jo victim hone ki itni acchi acting kar li? Maybe the verbal arguments were scripted but the throwing of the bottle and rod did not seem very scripted to me.

But anyway, performance wise I agree that Shilpa played a better poker/annoyer than Priyank. Accordingly, those who think Priyank was bullying Arshi should then reprimand Shilpa for being a bully as well because she was better at it. My point is keeping their "performance" aside, their actions were very similar so one shouldn't be blamed and other goes scot-free.

Anyway, whether or not the Shikas fight was scripted is debatable so let's just agree to disagree and leave it at that.

Originally posted by: denver_diva

No, IMO Vikas is not a great actor and that is what gave it away...had Vikas been a great actor...then their story would have been flawlessly executed. Shilpa did great.The bottle dropping or blanket touching with the rod etc. seem spontaneous acts...but in-keeping with the pre-decided storyline. I like Shikas...I am not their fan tho. I think Vikas overdid the crying and running away bit...or it was going very natural..However I am still enjoying the screenplay between Shikas. Vikas is a very sharp-brained person who can anticipate reactions and acts accordingly. It is impossible for me to believe that he is helpless before a woman's crazy gimmicks. Priyank's fight with Arshi was too bland !

I agree with you that neither Shilpa nor Priyank should be reprimanded because this is a game and both are playing within rules.

Bigg Boss is not a place to come and live how you normally would.It is a game of survival within certain rules.It is a show for forgotten celebs and commoners to come and showcase their talents and strategize. If they were to come and do only morally and ethically correct things, and surya namaskar and bhajan kirtan then this show would be on Astha channel. We audience need to understand that this is just a reality show and not real life..The people on the show cannot be 100% real or 100% fake. There will be times they are being real, there will be times they will be fake. Everyone is playing...some play well, some dont and look lost.

Hina's game is to decorate herself and be present everywhere.

Some come unprepared but find a plot as the game proceeds.Some fail to find a plot...like Shaggy, Luv, Meh, Sapna

Originally posted by: nehlove

Word! 👍🏼

The only person who seems to have found a hold in the house without any real angle is Hiten. I am not counting the Arshi thing here because it is very one sided. I am unable to understand what his "game" is if there is any at all.

Originally posted by: denver_diva

I really like Hiten. He is the only person out there that I could be friends with. I really liked him as Karan Virani and Pratham Mittal.

IMO he has sailed through BB so far because he has a pretty clean-past image,good fan-support from past work and because hasnt really done anything wrong on the show. He is the best on the show by elimination method--The others are all going so wrong that he is gaining from that. To be honest, I am disappointed in him as I feel he lacks empathy for others but that doesnt make him an evil person.Now, imagine having 5 Hitens on the show! Would we want to watch the show? Ummm ..😳

He is not adding much to the show for me. Removing him will not change the dynamics of the show in the slightest way. Career-wise,I am not sure if he is eventually going to gain much, after BB .