-Rabbave-- thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

This show is clearly obsessed with joint families from the moment it began. But WHY? I ask why is it glorifying such a regressive mentality which is why in India boys are preferred over girls and so many girls are killed before they are even born. Why is it always that the joint family is with the guy's family? Why can't they show a progressive and refreshing change for once that there is nothing wrong in living with the girl's parents.


In this show, it was COMPLETELY UNREALISTIC that Naira wanted to live in a joint family, especially with a old-fashioned, backwards member in the family like dadi who thinks that girls and bahus have no value in the family, who herself said that they are daughter in laws and not daughters. And what is up with this always asking for permission to do everything?? Naira is an adult who can take decisions by herself. Instead, they show her asking dadi for every small thing. Who in their RIGHT MIND would leave their cut little home with their husband, where both of them can live privately and independently for a jail like goenka family's house. If they want to show the going back, at least make it worth living there, instead of showing utter stupidity.

In America, if you look at mormon families, they value family and relationships at the utmost level. However, couples always stay separately with the kids until the kids are ready to be married. But does that mean that the grandparents can never see their children or grandchildren? No. Of course not. They take time out from their lives to spend special moments with the family, while the couples have their own privacy. They are considered one of the most happiest groups of people and there has to be a reason for that. There is a reason why there is always so much drama in Indian families. Because so many people have to stay together in one roof and because of that, the mind goes to trivial matters instead of focusing on important stuff.

In today's day and age, when so many people are watching this show, makers should show progressive things and how this backwards mentality is NOT OKAY and how Indian society should CHANGE IT'S VIEWS. Instead, from the show, they are releasing the hidden message that it is okay to treat daughter in laws like how they are treated in India, you need to have sons in the family (not one family is the show has solely daughters in the house), no matter what joint families are the way to go 🤢, even if the husband wants to stay separately for whatever reason, the dumb wife brings him back to the family circus to live, Instead of focusing on their relationship and their life and growing together as a couple, instead they have to focus on family drama and have other backwards and regressive people make big issues over trivial things because they have nothing better to do because of their lack of education. WOW! WHAT AMAZING CONTENT 🥱

And for anyone supporters of regressive content that will try and be over smart asking me why I watch the show if I don't support this stupid mentality, the answer is, I don't. However, a few members of my family do and it is on in my house enough for me to know what it going on.
Edited by -Rabbave-- - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

1k

Users

6

Likes

20

Frequent Posters

beatsdongandy thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
firstly,try to b polite when u r posting sumthing generally on a public platform.u r restricting ppl's opinion with the tag "over smart" even before they express it.so plz if u hv freedom of speech others also hv.. now,coming to the main point...i m myself from a joint family myself n thr is nothing regressive in it.regressive n progressive these terms come with ur soch,ur way of thinking abt things.when a lot of ppl stay together under one roof with diff mentality yes fights,missunderstanding happens at the same time when u ll b in trouble they ll b the 1st person to help u out coz of that fact they r joint "family" ..didnt understand ur point of how living with family becomes regressive..since they r part of our life.n here its not like kartik wanted to live seperately for privacy he had prob with his fam thats y left..dadi is one annoying woman but she has been like this all her life nobody came to stop her or chnge things which is happening now due to naira..she obviously ll need time n proper way to get used to such new things.still goenka stay together for each other at times of prob..they arent showing family is cause of ur bad times rather showing family is the cause for which u come out of bad times.they hv that unity thats y for naira's dance academy dadi felt bad or kartik helped MG in business.if this show is regressive u wont find anything to watch on indian tv.this is one show which promotes all the positivity n progressive thoughts b it a girl's career after marriage or a guy respecting his women of life or showing a marriage or love story close to reality n with love n many more.
Peacelover15 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: beatsdongandy

firstly,try to b polite when u r posting sumthing generally on a public platform.u r restricting ppl's opinion with the tag "over smart" even before they express it.so plz if u hv freedom of speech others also hv.. now,coming to the main point...i m myself from a joint family myself n thr is nothing regressive in it.regressive n progressive these terms come with ur soch,ur way of thinking abt things.when a lot of ppl stay together under one roof with diff mentality yes fights,missunderstanding happens at the same time when u ll b in trouble they ll b the 1st person to help u out coz of that fact they r joint "family" ..didnt understand ur point of how living with family becomes regressive..since they r part of our life.n here its not like kartik wanted to live seperately for privacy he had prob with his fam thats y left..dadi is one annoying woman but she has been like this all her life nobody came to stop her or chnge things which is happening now due to naira..she obviously ll need time n proper way to get used to such new things.still goenka stay together for each other at times of prob..they arent showing family is cause of ur bad times rather showing family is the cause for which u come out of bad times.they hv that unity thats y for naira's dance academy dadi felt bad or kartik helped MG in business.if this show is regressive u wont find anything to watch on indian tv.this is one show which promotes all the positivity n progressive thoughts b it a girl's career after marriage or a guy respecting his women of life or showing a marriage or love story close to reality n with love n many more.

So very well said can't agree more.
janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: beatsdongandy

firstly,try to b polite when u r posting sumthing generally on a public platform.u r restricting ppl's opinion with the tag "over smart" even before they express it.so plz if u hv freedom of speech others also hv.. now,coming to the main point...i m myself from a joint family myself n thr is nothing regressive in it.regressive n progressive these terms come with ur soch,ur way of thinking abt things.when a lot of ppl stay together under one roof with diff mentality yes fights,missunderstanding happens at the same time when u ll b in trouble they ll b the 1st person to help u out coz of that fact they r joint "family" ..didnt understand ur point of how living with family becomes regressive..since they r part of our life.n here its not like kartik wanted to live seperately for privacy he had prob with his fam thats y left..dadi is one annoying woman but she has been like this all her life nobody came to stop her or chnge things which is happening now due to naira..she obviously ll need time n proper way to get used to such new things.still goenka stay together for each other at times of prob..they arent showing family is cause of ur bad times rather showing family is the cause for which u come out of bad times.they hv that unity thats y for naira's dance academy dadi felt bad or kartik helped MG in business.if this show is regressive u wont find anything to watch on indian tv.this is one show which promotes all the positivity n progressive thoughts b it a girl's career after marriage or a guy respecting his women of life or showing a marriage or love story close to reality n with love n many more.

Well said 👏
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: beatsdongandy

firstly,try to b polite when u r posting sumthing generally on a public platform.u r restricting ppl's opinion with the tag "over smart" even before they express it.so plz if u hv freedom of speech others also hv.. now,coming to the main point...i m myself from a joint family myself n thr is nothing regressive in it.regressive n progressive these terms come with ur soch,ur way of thinking abt things.when a lot of ppl stay together under one roof with diff mentality yes fights,missunderstanding happens at the same time when u ll b in trouble they ll b the 1st person to help u out coz of that fact they r joint "family" ..didnt understand ur point of how living with family becomes regressive..since they r part of our life.n here its not like kartik wanted to live seperately for privacy he had prob with his fam thats y left..dadi is one annoying woman but she has been like this all her life nobody came to stop her or chnge things which is happening now due to naira..she obviously ll need time n proper way to get used to such new things.still goenka stay together for each other at times of prob..they arent showing family is cause of ur bad times rather showing family is the cause for which u come out of bad times.they hv that unity thats y for naira's dance academy dadi felt bad or kartik helped MG in business.if this show is regressive u wont find anything to watch on indian tv.this is one show which promotes all the positivity n progressive thoughts b it a girl's career after marriage or a guy respecting his women of life or showing a marriage or love story close to reality n with love n many more.

#
This is my exact answer to this topic. I live in England, and live in a separate house with my parents and siblings, but I also have loads of my relatives and family members who live in houses very close to us and we come over a lot to each other's houses and celebrate together, and although we don't live under one roof, but because we all live so close together in the same neighbourhoods, we have all the drama of joint families too, but there is nothing regressive about joint families, when they are the first people to come to help you when you need it the most. There are pros and cons to all family structures, but that doesn't make one any less or more regressive than another.
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
I think choosing to.live in joint families isn't actually bad..and the show is promoting a lot of good stuff..u sound like a frustrated fan.of gul's sado-masochistic male.leads.. and u made a whole.new account just to post an essay. Wow

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Mehersudha

29 days ago

HIDDEN TRUTHS 13.7

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMB2UVNzZJi/?img_index=2 igsh=cWl2NXZwMzNkcXdm Dimbri wants to meet ar in their place to talk. Dadi comes warns not...

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMB2UVNzZJi/?img_index=2
Expand â–Ľ
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".