Neil: The one-track-mind cop!

Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
In these past two episodes, neil has annoyed me quite a lot. The reason being is that in scenes from yesterday and today, such as the phone tapping scene, and today's nanno scene with her revealing about the gunshot, and the madhvi scene, he really disappointed me with his reaction, or should I say, lack of.

In both of these scenes, his mind and his ears are solely focused on finding out more about ananya/ avni. In both scenes, where nanno reveals about daya shooting avni in the chest, and madhvi saying that ananya/ avni has suffered so much and has a gunshot wound since 15 years, each time, his reaction was next to none. His mind is only on suspecting ananya, finding out about ananya, confirming whether ananya is avni, but never once did I see or feel that he feels remorse for judging and hating ananya, or him feeling sorry when he is being told about the sufferings of avni/ ananya, or even once think about daya's involvement.

In the phone tapping scene, he didn't look in the slightest bit effected by hearing ananya's trust in him and hearing how she keeps him in high regard. Neither did he seem much effected when madhvi told him how she has gone through so much and has a gunshot wound. Even there he looked serious and was only thinking that his suspicion against ananya planning things against mehta's is confirmed. For god sake, ask yourself whether the mehta's are really good or question himself about daya for once.

During those convos between nanno and then madhvi, I expected him to feel sorry hearing what she has gone though or at least think that she must have gone through a lot. And the two things that annoyed me the most is that serious, suspicious cop look that he kept displaying even when being told these sad facts, as if just collecting the facts and investigating matter to him, and not the pain of the person involved. Sometimes neil fails to show human compassion towards ananya or avni, and only shows suspicion and hatred when trying to know more about her.

Then there is the second thing that annoys me. Even after hearing all this, he keeps looking as if he still considers the girl a criminal despite everything he has heard and doesn't seem to even think about daya's involvement in all this. Never once has he been shown suspecting or thinking that maybe daya has wronged avni or ananya, or thinking at least whether daya did shoot avni. He just keeps questioning himself about ananya/ avni's reality rather than questioning daya's reality. He needs to be shown with a little more human emotion, and needs to be shown actually wondering whether daya is as innocent or good as she seems, otherwise he is starting to get annoying and ignorant looking to me.
Edited by sammy17 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

1.2k

Users

6

Likes

12

Frequent Posters

Ashiprat thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
so True .also i am confused why he wants to marry ria when his own mother is against this wedding ?
he does not love her .
He keeps on overlooking all the faults of mehta's .only trying to prove ananya is criminal . There is no introspection regarding ananya about the facts he learned from nanno and madhavi ?


Ooolalala thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
I don't think Neil is one track mind cop or he is insensitive. He clearly said if Dayawanti Mehta is culprit, his hands would not shake while punishing her. He would get justice for Ayesha jee and Avni.
Then Madhavi came and he said at the end that Ananya is Avni. The episode ended on that. We would see his reaction tom. Neil is a mysterious character and that makes him so unique. He has a hidden motive and he is getting to facts. When he was talking to Nanoo, you could feel that he was feeling pain. He even said that I understand your pain.

Precap was a just a dream. He is not against Avni. He will be her biggest support.
IshyMishy thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Sam,
I agree with u. He came up to share the pain of Nannu. as a genuine cop, he is ready to get justice for Nannu and Avni, as an intelligent cop he could connect the dots to analyze Ananya is Avni but he failed to contemplate / feel Avni's pain. Madhavi Tai could feel Avni's pain but not Neil..

I hope at least in future tracks he will remorse ...
IshyMishy thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Saraa.

I don't think Neil is one track mind cop or he is insensitive. He clearly said if Dayawanti Mehta is culprit, his hands would not shake while punishing her. He would get justice for Ayesha jee and Avni.

Then Madhavi came and he said at the end that Ananya is Avni. The episode ended on that. We would see his reaction tom. Neil is a mysterious character and that makes him so unique. He has a hidden motive and he is getting to facts. When he was talking to Nanoo, you could feel that he was feeling pain. He even said that I understand your pain.

Precap was a just a dream. He is not against Avni. He will be her biggest support.



Sara,
Neil being a cop investigating the case a is fair enough.
When Neil can share the pain of Nannu, For Ananya he could at leastsympathize as a friend as good heart person .

Edited by IshyMishy - 8 years ago
prathe thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
I don't knowknow am weirdweird one I guess 😆 I saw some sort of emotion in Neil face when madhvi tai spoke abt avni a subtle one 😆 shayad Zain ka asar 😆
A_for_Arpita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
😆

Well there was a dialogue in my most favourite show Tashan E Ishq there was a dialogue, I would like to mention that because I think THAT will give you the answer of your this doubts on Neil 😉

"Nazar bhar k dekhne mein time lagta hai, jo foron tareef karte hain woh jhoote hote hain" [It takes time to watch someone properly, those who praise instantly are liars] 😳
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Arpimugfan

😆

Well there was a dialogue in my most favourite show Tashan E Ishq there was a dialogue, I would like to mention that because I think THAT will give you the answer of your this doubts on Neil 😉

"Nazar bhar k dekhne mein time lagta hai, jo foron tareef karte hain woh jhoote hote hain" [It takes time to watch someone properly, those who praise instantly are liars] 😳



I remember that line...It was said by kunj to twinkle 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".