Misunderstanding and silence. *Edited* Reply on page 5 - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

37

Views

4.3k

Users

24

Likes

245

Frequent Posters

933191 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#31
@Anu with all due respect to your opinion Vividha is not Ramakant 2 they are poles apart they were victims of forced marriage but Vividha never compromised on her love.
I understand Atharv's insecurity, I really do especially after yesterday's episode and I am very dissappointed with Vivi as well but that in no way justifies Atharv pretending. His insecurity is justified but the way he is going about itself is very un charcateristic of the Atharv Sujatha that we were introduced to! This man hates lies and he is going to willingly live one even if it is for few days!
For me what yesterday's epiosde did was understand where & Why Atharv's sacrifice drama was coming from, in that I truly empathise with him. because If I was treated the way he was yesterday my reaction would have been worse.
#Peace
whispa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: baubles

WhispaaašŸ¤— I'm pretty late, but had to comment.

Firstly, wonderful post. Thanks for being among the few who see both sides of the story, cos all I have been seeing since yesterday's episode is Vividha being bashed.

With no offence to anyone, I just have to say this because I literally have seen this everyday. People see Atharv's pain, his hurt even if it's little. The few days when I found him wrong and spoke a word against him, the number of people who came in his defense is unimaginable.
And their justifications were- Atharv is human, he can't read Vividha's mind to know what's going on in there, he has flaws. And I agree.

But none of this is considered for Vividha which is sad.
Vividha doesn't see Atharv's insecurity cos she had done all she can to erase it. All she sees now is DISTRUST. She sees him doubting her and her love, not his insecurity cos she can't read minds either.
Insecurity makes you want to correct it, take that extra effort to reassure that person you are theirs. But distrust hurts, makes you angry cos your love is suddenly being doubted after everything you've done. And it's the distrust Vividha sees from his side that makes her angry and unbothered. 'If he can't trust my love, I can't prove myself again and again' is perfectly normal.

Having said that, yes she should have spoken yesterday. She isn't a showpiece to be praised by people around her.
And going by the heat thing the other day, the normalcy with which Vividha reacted the next morning...if Atharv feels she would take that big a thing so normally while she isn't sure of her love for him then he's being an ass too.

So the fault is on both sides for me and they are right in their own ways too. And I sincerely wish I could see Vividha defendes the way people defend Atharv..the bias is HUGE!


SoumušŸ¤—

I knew out of everyone you would understand my viewpoint.

I love Atharv but I like you feel that his mistakes are easily forgiven and overlooked all the time. When Vividha makes a mistake, all her previous actions are ignored and she is judged on that one thing and is expected to atone for it before she is forgiven.

The bias is huge.
whispa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#33
Thank you so much everyone for your replies. I really do appreciate the time you all took to write your reviews.

I know that no one(except Soumu) agreed with my review yesterday but I still stand by Vividha. But of course you are all entitled to your opinions and everyone's views are respected.😳

I'm just going to address a couple of things.

Yesterday, in the jeep scene many of you have taken issue that Vividha looked after Ravish instead of Atharv. For this I'm definitely going to blame the cv's as it was a way of keeping the dead 'triangle' alive. I guess it didn't bother me as much as it did most people.(A lolipop as Julie would say).

After Vivi had settled Ravish in the front, the first thing she did was look at Atharv but he avoided her eye. Perhaps, maybe she wanted to say something to him or even for him to say something to her but he didn't even look at her. Again, when they both sat in the jeep she looked at him but he looked away. I think we've all been in the situation where we've wanted to say something to someone and maybe explain, but they've just ignored you, so you refrain from saying something either. I felt Vivi was in that position yesterday.

And then when they arrived and were bombarded by questions from journalists, again the first thing Vividha did was look at Atharv. She was as shocked as he by all the questioning. Can you imagine travelling all night, you're tired, you're not thinking straight and you arrive home to all this drama and then have a microphone thrust in your face. Anyone would be rendered speechless. Ravish and Suman are used to dealing with the media, ViTharv aren't.

And I feel(even though I know you all don't agree), Vividha was absoultely right in keeping quiet. The reporters are all about sensationalising news. Can you imagine the tamasha if Vividha had grabbed Atharv's hand right there and told everyone she was engaged to him! What Vivi did had dignity. She kept quiet because it was no one's business but hers, Atharv's and the family's. None of us want to air our laundry in public because it's no ones business what happens in our own home except ours. I'm sure Vividha will address how she feels in the privacy of their own home.

Atharv right now is misunderstanding every act and gesture of Vividha. Vividha doesn't know about the letter and she can't understand why Atharv is misunderstanding her and doubting her love for him when she 's told him she loves only him.

Like I said before in my review, I understand both Atharv and Vividha's point of view. They are both right and both wrong and I don't feel it's right to blame either one of them because they have both clammed up and are not letting the other know how they feel.

This is not the ViTharv we know but all the circumstances of the last three months have brought them to this point where they are reacting to what they see, rather then relying on what's in their heart like they used to.

Again, I'm not expecting anyone to change their mind but I do hope people will give Vivi the kindness and understanding that's always given to Atharv regardless of his mistakes.






Edited by whispa - 9 years ago
SerialLoverr thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: whispa

Thank you so much everyone for your replies. I really do appreciate the time you all took to write your reviews.

I know that no one(except Soumu) agreed with my review yesterday but I still stand by Vividha. But of course you are all entitled to your opinions and everyone's views are respected.😳

I'm just going to address a couple of things.

Yesterday, in the jeep scene many of you have taken issue that Vividha looked after Ravish instead of Atharv. For this I'm definitely going to blame the cv's as it was a way of keeping the dead 'triangle' alive. I guess it didn't bother me as much as it did most people.(A lolipop as Julie would say).

After Vivi had settled Ravish in the front, the first thing she did was look at Atharv but he avoided her eye. Perhaps, maybe she wanted to say something to him or even for him to say something to her but he didn't even look at her. Again, when they both sat in the jeep she looked at him but he looked away. I think we've all been in the situation where we've wanted to say something to someone and maybe explain, but they've just ignored you, so you refrain from saying something either. I felt Vivi was in that position yesterday.

And then when they arrived and were bombarded by questions from journalists, again the first thing Vividha did was look at Atharv. She was as shocked as he by all the questioning. Can you imagine travelling all night, you're tired, you're not thinking straight and you arrive home to all this drama and then have a microphone thrust in your face. Anyone would be rendered speechless. Ravish and Suman are used to dealing with the media, ViTharv aren't.

And I feel(even though I know you all don't agree), Vividha was absoultely right in keeping quiet. The reporters are all about sensationalising news. Can you imagine the tamasha if Vividha had grabbed Atharv's hand right there and told everyone she was engaged to him! What Vivi did had dignity. She kept quiet because it was no one's business but hers, Atharv's and the family's. None of us want to air our laundry in public because it's no ones business what happens in our own home except ours. I'm sure Vividha will address how she feels in the privacy of their own home.

Atharv right now is misunderstanding every act and gesture of Vividha. Vividha doesn't know about the letter and she can't understand why Atharv is misunderstanding her and doubting her love for him when she 's told him she loves only him.

Like I said before in my review, I understand both Atharv and Vividha's point of view. They are both right and both wrong and I don't feel it's right to blame either one of them because they have both clammed up and are not letting the other know how they feel.

This is not the ViTharv we know but all the circumstances of the last three months have brought them to this point where they are reacting to what they see, rather then relying on what's in their heart like they used to.

Again, I'm not expecting anyone to change their mind but I do hope people will give Vivi the kindness and understanding that's always given to Atharv regardless of his mistakes.







You are right. Previously without listening to vividha, ATHARV doubt her , is him fault. Now vividha's actions are confusing like her caring for ravish in jeep scene, but not concern about Atharv's being shot also and be silent, is her fault. It's ok, if she don't speak anything beacuse ATHARV ignoring her , but she should take care of injured ATHARV, by putting aside her anger. And she doesn't speak infront of media is right , she avoid unnecessary drama by that. But in jeep scene , I think she is at fault.

So now both are at fault. So both sides are balanced. Now they can blast each otheršŸ˜†.

I think " Tali kabhi ak hath se nahi bajti" .So they both are at fault, they can't blame each other. Only need is to solve their MU by mutual understanding Or by blasting on each other and confrontation...

Dono maise koi dudh ka dhula nahi hain because they are also human, not god. Both are right at their place, but both are wrong beacuse they are trying to ignore situation and think that with time , everything will be ok.
Khushi.... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#35
Your replies always give me a bit of hope for Vitharv.
Thing that got to me was the car scene. It's not realistic for Vividha to not care for Atharva after he has just been shot at, no matter how he is behaving. And then she walks out beside Ravish, why? I didn't get that. I also think she shouldn't have let Atharva get sidelined. The media will create a big drama whenever the truth comes out.

The other thing is though if Atharva behaved the way Vividha is, with an ex wife of his, I don't think you'd need all the planted evidence to make her feel insecure, just his behaviour alone would be enough. Can you imagine being shot at and your husband is instead busy taking care of his ex wife, not bothering that you could've died? I don't think a woman would be ok with their husband being that close to their ex wife. Would Vividha be ok with it? I don't think so.

Both Atharva and Vividha have made mistakes, and each time I have been against what they were doing at that point. But for me Vividha has stayed silent one too many times, she has behaved as Ravish's wife far too many times, and at the end of the day Ravish is her ex husband, and in reality I don't think a woman would do so much for an ex husband, sidelining her fiance, and that is why I'm not liking Vividha. If Atharva was in Vividha's place, I would dislike him too.

-JC- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#36
i had promised to give an honest reply after watching the video. And having done that I do agree with what you said about Vividha's silence yesterday. She did look for an opportunity to talk to Atharv but he was being a crabster and it was dignified of Vivs to not discuss her personal life in front of media..but I don't even think it was a deliberate choice she made. They were bombarded and she was naturally at a loss.
baubles thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: whispa

Thank you so much everyone for your replies. I really do appreciate the time you all took to write your reviews.

I know that no one(except Soumu) agreed with my review yesterday but I still stand by Vividha. But of course you are all entitled to your opinions and everyone's views are respected.😳

I'm just going to address a couple of things.

Yesterday, in the jeep scene many of you have taken issue that Vividha looked after Ravish instead of Atharv. For this I'm definitely going to blame the cv's as it was a way of keeping the dead 'triangle' alive. I guess it didn't bother me as much as it did most people.(A lolipop as Julie would say).

After Vivi had settled Ravish in the front, the first thing she did was look at Atharv but he avoided her eye. Perhaps, maybe she wanted to say something to him or even for him to say something to her but he didn't even look at her. Again, when they both sat in the jeep she looked at him but he looked away. I think we've all been in the situation where we've wanted to say something to someone and maybe explain, but they've just ignored you, so you refrain from saying something either. I felt Vivi was in that position yesterday.

And then when they arrived and were bombarded by questions from journalists, again the first thing Vividha did was look at Atharv. She was as shocked as he by all the questioning. Can you imagine travelling all night, you're tired, you're not thinking straight and you arrive home to all this drama and then have a microphone thrust in your face. Anyone would be rendered speechless. Ravish and Suman are used to dealing with the media, ViTharv aren't.

And I feel(even though I know you all don't agree), Vividha was absoultely right in keeping quiet. The reporters are all about sensationalising news. Can you imagine the tamasha if Vividha had grabbed Atharv's hand right there and told everyone she was engaged to him! What Vivi did had dignity. She kept quiet because it was no one's business but hers, Atharv's and the family's. None of us want to air our laundry in public because it's no ones business what happens in our own home except ours. I'm sure Vividha will address how she feels in the privacy of their own home.

Atharv right now is misunderstanding every act and gesture of Vividha. Vividha doesn't know about the letter and she can't understand why Atharv is misunderstanding her and doubting her love for him when she 's told him she loves only him.

Like I said before in my review, I understand both Atharv and Vividha's point of view. They are both right and both wrong and I don't feel it's right to blame either one of them because they have both clammed up and are not letting the other know how they feel.

This is not the ViTharv we know but all the circumstances of the last three months have brought them to this point where they are reacting to what they see, rather then relying on what's in their heart like they used to.

Again, I'm not expecting anyone to change their mind but I do hope people will give Vivi the kindness and understanding that's always given to Atharv regardless of his mistakes.






And I love you again Whisp!šŸ¤— You've put it so well.

@Vaish, @Shweta- I did say they are making her look like a show piece. But again, we look at it from Atharv's perspective cos we saw how it would have probably lessened his insecurity of she had said something, cos we know what he's feeling. But not once has he shared that with Vividha.
Looking at it from Vividha's side, like Whisp said she doesn't know how to deal with this madness. Plus the two main people being questioned- R and Suman are screaming out how she's the bahu and a fauji's wife. Firstly, completely contradicting them would have been shameful to all of them and second, she doesn't see Atharv's insecurity..I don't think she saw the need to even talk about her personal life in public.

Had she realised it's insecurity she would have made that effort to explain and tried ways to get rid of it. But doubt and distrust is like an accusation...she feels accused when after all the times she has said she loves only him and a lot more, he keeps telling her she loves R. It's only anger and stubbornness that comes in then.

So this isn't blind defending..I even said BOTH are being idiots. What saddened me was the bashing Vividha got for something Atharv probably wouldn't have to this extent. I saw too many accusations and extreme hatred just based on yesterday's silence, which she definitely didn't deserve.

P.S. I talk too muchšŸ˜†šŸ˜†šŸ˜† And this is why I don't get time for IF..I'll end up living herešŸ˜†
JazzyM thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#38
Well said. Separation seems to be the main track in this serial...😭

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".