Why Plagarism Is A Crime--And How You Are Supporting It (UPDATE-Pg 6).

napstermonster thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

Why exactly do you think we writers who post online for you to enjoy our fan fictions, one shorts, short stories etc. do what we do? Post to you on this forum? Why do you think we do it? And what makes us update those stories? Maybe you think its because we are needy. Absolutely correct. We need to share our ideas, our thoughts, we absolutely need you. We need you, the audience, who are our sisters and friends and strangers and well wishers, haters too, we need you all. We are creative types, all addicted to the same show you watch. Difference is, we have to mess with what we see, meddle a little, flesh out characters, imagine new situations for them. We show our love for them by killing them, having them go on adventures, taking them to bed, making them hook up with the "wrong" brother, giving them backgrounds of royalty and pushing them into bullets and danger.

Us fiction writers ko mann bhara nahi, screen ki scenes se, toh word document khula aur khud hi koi aur scene, koi aur intensity create kar diya. But you read it, when it comes up, and for 3 minutes, or 30, we take you to that place in our heads with us, and we say, dekh lo, yeh bhi ho sakhta hai! And you laugh, or yawn, or politely agree, or thoroughly hate it and go back to other posts. But those fictions-- It's a form of art though right? And if we have done our job right, you, when you click on our post, and read it, you sigh after you read our creation, and say "..Wah! That feels right, that is a good one, now that is a scene worth imagining" ...or you say "Eekkk! How bad, Napstermonster, yeh tune kya kiya, joh hai sceen pei, who hi accha hai, aisi ghatiya likhawat na kar, yaah..." but my point is-- you react.

Again, I say, those of us who write, in our small way, in our own way, are also trying to create a kind of art--- and good or bad, art is whatever that makes you have a reaction. Gets you to feel something even for a second, whether that is excitement, whether that is disgust, or even a lump in you throat, and tears in your eyes. If it is particularly good, or particularly disturbing it may even get you to comment, to share with the writer, and your other audience members--- that you felt something, too.

So that's why we write. We would probably do it if we have one person reading (ourselves) or if we are famous fan fiction creaters who's every work brings over a 1000 responses in an hour (smitar comes to mind). But we write for us, and as we share it, the truth is, we write for you. Its like chocolate--- the more you share, the faster the sweetness spreads.. and the smiles, and the friendships. That's why we write.

So you are thinking a "Accha, good. Go napstermonster. Go write, since you like it so much." Mujhe write karni hi hai, yaar. Wait karo, update ke liye. Likh dunga. But before I go, please do me a favor. If you are not a writer, if you are just a reader, or a casual Ishqbaazian reading this post, I have a small task for you.

Go to Microsoft Word, open a page, and type in a word. Any word. Then think how much time it will take you, to develop that one word, into 6-8 pages of that document. Times new roman, 12 font, please. Your audience will not accept 500 words from you just because its in 24 font pink comic sans serif (IPKKND forum ki inside joke). I mean, you will have to post at least 2000 words, to get a decent story done. You will have to make sense. It cannot be outlandish stuff.

No gods and monsters here. You are writing for many people. It will have to make sense to the tired executive wasting office time on India Forums, the student checking posts between classes, the housewife who just wants a break and her coffee with a bit of light hearted fun. It will have to reach them all--- so it has to be human emotions, delivered through fictional characters we all love. Shivaay, Anika, Om, Rudra. Tej, or Janvi. Ishana too.

You will have to be funny, or romantic, or emotional, or sexy. Or all of them, if you can manage it. Oh, yeah, you have to have a point, yeah? A story, or a message, a "raaz" to reveal, or a concept to establish. That element of connection must be there, running like a thread, throughout each paragraph, each new character, each new situation you are writing.

Still with me? That word doc still open? Good, now come up with a plot. Make sure it makes sense, okay? Small tip, to help you deal with inevitable frustration--- you will have at least 13 excellent ideas that actually lead to nothing and finally you will have a moderately decent plotline ready, and your story can begin.

Okay, done? Now for characters, then scenes, then description. How many ways can you say the word "Eye" without saying the word "eye," for example? Don't make the language too hard though, or too easy, or
too too anything. Remember, you are writing for characters who people love, who others besides just you invite into their living room and their laptops every day. Now write, and dont forget, a fan fiction or a story means you have an unspoken, but no less binding contract with your reader, so this 6-8 pages will be done, again and again, until you or the serial, gives up. So write.

Done? Now post it. Just that one chapter or one shot you wrote was at least 6-8 hours of your life, of your blood, sweat and tears. Of frustration, endless cups of coffee, in between your life, your actual work, your family your kids, in-laws, friends, dates, love making, college, dealing with your angry mother and helping to cook dinner. Now its done, and its you, on that page. Now post it. Publish it. Love it. You have given birth to it, and good or bad, it is your own
mehnat, your own ideas. That perfect phrase that came to you when you were driving, and you jotted down before it vanished. It has that description your honey calls you, late at night, as he stares into your eyes, and you use for your heroine. It has your humor, your jokes, your ideas, things you wish your guy said or did, or things you wish you were, or could be. It contains you, dripping through the pages, even though the names are those of your characters, it is you. And your life, your people, and your creative mind.

BOOM.


I see it, I like it, I cut and paste it. Maybe I change about 10% of what took you so much effort to create, maybe I don't bother. I read it when you put it out, right? So its mine now. Everything you did, everything you created, your effort, your entire creative work. Its MINE, okay? I go ahead. I post it under my name, for my audience. And I say to them as they read it, never knowing you, never knowing what I stole from you, I say "Yeah! There was this book, and I really liked it, and it fits this serial we all watch, so here it is!"

Or I don't even say that much. I just say-- "THANK YOU! I will absolutely update soon! Thank you! I have the next chapter almost done! Love you for your love!"


Lets do that --- those of you who think the plagiarism issue is being blown out of proportion. Who think the person or the people who plagiarize is just a silly kid, who didn't know any better. It DOESNT MATTER. Let's do this thing, where I take your work, and lets see if you think Plagiarism is just a small offence, not a big deal, when the thief (and that is the legal, moral, and absolutely valid word here-- Thief) gets caught. Lets see, once that ONE page has been stolen from you (as I have had fully completed work stolen from me) lets see then how you mirror me, lets see how you writhe with the pain of how it feels. How much of a betrayal it is, a rage, a helpless sense of being assaulted and ripped from your original work, when readers, all without knowing it, compliment a thief over your labor.

Once you are a writer, you wont want the compliments actually--in fact, even after I was plagiarized, I didn't want those tainted compliments being posted unknowingly by my thief's readers, by the way. No person who has been plagiarized is jealous of the compliments the thief is getting under his or her work's wings. Not one of us are feeling jealous.

But I remember those hours in front of the Microsoft word document, and that first joy of writing. And so will you, once it happens to you--and it will happen to you, if more people are not aware of how much of a betrayal it is, how much of a real and painful assault it is.

How important AS A READER it is to say NO. I WILL NOT tolerate it. I WILL NOT excuse it. I WILL end it. How important, as the audience, it is to put aside personal relationships and protest, and report, and say NO.

So yeah. As long as it happens freely, and people I like, the readers, then try to explain or excuse or even deny the damage it has done to the writers who were literally stolen from. When that happens, I remember those hours in front of the Microsoft word document, and the joy of writing I once felt .

And I cry.

Edited by napstermonster - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

65

Views

8.4k

Users

46

Likes

776

Frequent Posters

twerping thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Thank you for this post.
Ever since a certain matter came to light, I have been very disturbed. Being quite new to the experience of sharing my work in a public forum, I have felt quite blessed to have found such a community, that is so welcoming to one's attempts (good or bad) to recreate our favourites characters in one's own fashion. But the fact that someone might want to pass off someone else's work as one's own left me angry, hurt, betrayed and uncertain of how to go about the problem without creating undue ugliness. Your post showed me how. Yes, perhaps we are not all great writers but when we sit for hours thinking over a possible scene, worrying over the details until it seems perfect in our eyes, we put in a part of us in it. And that must be acknowledged and protected.
Edited by twerping - 9 years ago
naddiya26 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
you nailed it mate
stay blessed

i wish and pray people grow up and use their own brain and stop trying to be clever



Edited by naddiya26 - 9 years ago
PenguinBaby thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
I want to hug you so tight right now. Not because I understand what you're saying or because you've had your work stolen, just because I am feeling so in the same boat as you are, as we all writers are. You're right.
I, for myself, may not be the best writer ever, but I do pen away my feelings and wishes on a piece of paper, and give it away for the people to feel it too. And I feel elated when I get the responses, good/bad anything.
So if, God forbid, someone borrows my feelings and portrays it as their own, I will feel more pity than anger. Feel attacked and deceived. And whatever that person is, friend or acquaintance, stranger or family, doesn't remain that. He/she becomes a liar.

I just wanna say this to everyone, including myself most importantly, that if and when you're borrowing something from someone, make sure you're borrowing and not taking. Give credit for even a word or a sentence that you've used, if you want to use it. That person may never notice, but others do. And if you don't want to do that for them, do it for yourself. For your self-respect. It takes only a minute.

So, this is from me🤗

-Sanu
Rachna.KG thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
You are absolutely right and yes if I see someone taking credit for your work, I will do my bit as a reader. But the truth is no one so far has come even close to it. I read a few lines by others and leave.
Rozy77 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Thank you so much for this wonderful post Navin🤗
I guessed you'd react to the issue. I was part of IPKKND Forum too and remember those hellish days of plagiarism all those years ago.
I love how you emphasized on the hours it takes to formulate and write down thoughts. It requires not only tremendous amounts of time, but incredible effort and a passion for this form of Art.
And it makes my blood boil when some people come here to paste the creativity and brainchild of someone else, lap up the compliments and become an Oh so famous writer...
Excuse me for not being lenient here because i find this practice outright disgusting, totally unacceptable and completely unfair to all the genuine, wonderful writers (professional and amateur)
travelholic thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
I hope all is well and you are not that effected by such negativities. It is heart breaking to see your work not respected but remember that 90% of us do appreciate it and are waiting for the next update with a baited breath

Hope it makes u feel better! Lots of love
mblaq thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

This post has compelled me to reply...just to say a massive thank you to anyone who has ever taken the time and put in the effort to present the people on this forum with beautiful stories that gives us so much more from the characters that we all love. I absolutely agree with this post! Plagiarism is not something to take lightly at all...now I am not a writer but I absolutely love reading and I admire the people who can take me places with their words...who can make me feel my life would not be the same without this story...who can give me a new perspective...

So This reply is to anyone who has ever written something from their heart and shared a little bit of themselves with the world... THANK YOU SO MUCH! YOUR HARD WORK IS APPRECIATED

FROM A USUALLY SILENT READER 😊

Pdrover thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Well said & hope these thieves will understand but I wonder these shameless lazy thieves might copy & paste this post too as there own
QueenofGreen thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Excellent post!

I relate to every single word you've written. Having been a victim of plagiarism, I can testify to the grief of having one's labour of love, stolen. It is infuriating, heartbreaking and utterly demotivating. No one should have to suffer it.

I'm baffled by how lightly, forum members are treating the incident. It appears that most people do not understand the gravity of such a heinous act. 'Borrowing,' 'copying,' 'being inspired by,' 'not completely taking the credit for,' are simply euphemistic for the harsh reality - plagiarism is stealing. It is the theft of intellectual property. It does not matter if it is an idea, a couple of words, paragraphs or the whole work - stealing is stealing. It is intentional. It is criminal.
It doesn't matter that no monetary profit is being made from it - if a person is caught to be stealing, they must suffer the consequences. Any member proven to have plagiarised should be banned immediately. Moreover, their name must be added to some sort of site wide register cataloguing such offenders.

Thank you so much for this! It's imperative that we raise awareness in the cyber community. Plagiarism is a crime. Those who plagiarise are thieves: criminals. They have no integrity, morality or respect. Do not support them. Stop trying to defend them. If you cannot raise your voice against them, then please at least do not defend them. If you are passive, weak or a blind supporter, then put yourselves in the shoes of those who have been wronged.

Trust me, you will burn with fury.

Edited by parthianglory. - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".