24 lost everything... for me... Jai killed Mallick - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

47

Views

4.9k

Users

13

Likes

90

Frequent Posters

mitrajayeeta23 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#41
Their death is a sacrifice and duty...we should be very proud of them...but here is a murder and also noone negotiate with terrorists like this...so it's won't be happen. If they show her death,thn what abt Anil? He is the main hero...he will become the villain,loose respect...so yeh nehin hoga
Supercommandodh thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#42
I have watched all the 9 seasons of original 24..while first season on Indian version is similar to first season of original 24..this season 2 is 95% similar to 3rd season of original 24..there also jack Bauer (anil kapoor character) killed Ryan chappel (shivani mallick character)..and this is a bad news for shivani mallick fans that Ryan chappel actually stayed dead ..there was no trick involved..but as I mentioned this show is not 100% similar to 3rd season (only 95% similarity) so there is still a 5% chance for shivani revival though very minute chance
iluvusakshi thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: Supercommandodh

I have watched all the 9 seasons of original 24..while first season on Indian version is similar to first season of original 24..this season 2 is 95% similar to 3rd season of original 24..there also jack Bauer (anil kapoor character) killed Ryan chappel (shivani mallick character)..and this is a bad news for shivani mallick fans that Ryan chappel actually stayed dead ..there was no trick involved..but as I mentioned this show is not 100% similar to 3rd season (only 95% similarity) so there is still a 5% chance for shivani revival though very minute chance


tfs. god bless you. shibani should be alive.
Navyya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Supercommandodh

I have watched all the 9 seasons of original 24..while first season on Indian version is similar to first season of original 24..this season 2 is 95% similar to 3rd season of original 24..there also jack Bauer (anil kapoor character) killed Ryan chappel (shivani mallick character)..and this is a bad news for shivani mallick fans that Ryan chappel actually stayed dead ..there was no trick involved..but as I mentioned this show is not 100% similar to 3rd season (only 95% similarity) so there is still a 5% chance for shivani revival though very minute chance



Did Ryan have a special child like Kabir ? Did she also see him just before dying ? Does Jack Bauer's son die with virus in that ? And is there someone like Gyan who dies with virus ? Can you pl answer these ?
Edited by NavyaKavya30 - 9 years ago
Supercommandodh thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: NavyaKavya30



Did Ryan have a special child like Kabir ? Did she also see him just before dying ? Does Jack Bauer's son die with virus in that ? And is there someone like Gyan who dies with virus ? Can you pl answer these ?


Not Ryan but season 4 ctu acting chief Erin Driscoll (another character on which shivani character is based) have daughter suffering from schizophrenia (like Kabir) who committed suicide..so there is one change there in the character..

Jack Bauer do not have any son in the show..one daughter played by Elisha Cuthbert

Gyan character is similar to Gael Ortega who died in the hotel after being exposed to virus..earlier everyone thought him to be working for Mexican drug lord salazar brothers (haroon and roshan characters) but later found out that he is part of jack secret mission to infiltrate Mexican drug cartel

I will answer all the questions based on previous 18 episodes but don't ask what will happen to xyz persons as that will be a spoiler for everyone and I don't want to spoil this good Indian remake
Ssophia thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: caraj4u

Mallick cant die. there might be some plan. Jai knows that he cant trust Roshan's word. If she die's then this is going to be a big victory for Roshan. First 400 people on the verge of dead and now Mallick. They cant let the terrorist win. I know it happens in real world, where security officers gets martyred all the time(26/11 attacked on Mumbai, army officers, just happened yesterday at Uri), but this is a fictional show and there has to be some feel good factor for the viewers.


Yes in reality it does happen...
Uri attack is really sooo sad...
But as this is a fictional show i dont think they will go for this end..
Arjun_M thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Supercommandodh


Not Ryan but season 4 ctu acting chief Erin Driscoll (another character on which shivani character is based) have daughter suffering from schizophrenia (like Kabir) who committed suicide..so there is one change there in the character..

Jack Bauer do not have any son in the show..one daughter played by Elisha Cuthbert

Gyan character is similar to Gael Ortega who died in the hotel after being exposed to virus..earlier everyone thought him to be working for Mexican drug lord salazar brothers (haroon and roshan characters) but later found out that he is part of jack secret mission to infiltrate Mexican drug cartel

I will answer all the questions based on previous 18 episodes but don't ask what will happen to xyz persons as that will be a spoiler for everyone and I don't want to spoil this good Indian remake


The Ryan Chappelle of this season is, more or less, Sidharth Sehgal. Shibani is not based on Chappelle at all, but has a special child like Driscoll and is in the same position in ATU as Michelle Dessler.

Gyan, though, is based directly on Gael. That Alzheimer's reference, though, may be a nod to Season 9, where the President's daughter is killed only for the President to say he may not remember her at all.

24:IR has made so many changes to the script in this season, characters split up, mixed, roles overlapping (Raj is Chase on one day, Baker on another, Veer is Michelle Dessler (!) in the hotel, the Sherchan brothers love each other till the end, Maya survives, the virus deal and capture sequence changes completely and Chang annoys the ATU a lot more), that even spoiling the original season will have very little effect. Who would have thought Roshan would last so long, among those who watched the show? Some of us were expecting a disappeared former partner of Jai or even Tejpal Sandhu to be the surprise villain of the second act!

The way they handled the Chase Edmunds character, though, was disappointing. First it's Raj Singh Bhakta (captures Prakash), then Colonel Subir (attempts to capture Jai and Roshan when they're out), then Vedant, who was shaping up as the Tony Almeida of this season.
Supercommandodh thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: Arjun_M


The Ryan Chappelle of this season is, more or less, Sidharth Sehgal. Shibani is not based on Chappelle at all, but has a special child like Driscoll and is in the same position in ATU as Michelle Dessler.

Gyan, though, is based directly on Gael. That Alzheimer's reference, though, may be a nod to Season 9, where the President's daughter is killed only for the President to say he may not remember her at all.

24:IR has made so many changes to the script in this season, characters split up, mixed, roles overlapping (Raj is Chase on one day, Baker on another, Veer is Michelle Dessler (!) in the hotel, the Sherchan brothers love each other till the end, Maya survives, the virus deal and capture sequence changes completely and Chang annoys the ATU a lot more), that even spoiling the original season will have very little effect. Who would have thought Roshan would last so long, among those who watched the show? Some of us were expecting a disappeared former partner of Jai or even Tejpal Sandhu to be the surprise villain of the second act!

The way they handled the Chase Edmunds character, though, was disappointing. First it's Raj Singh Bhakta (captures Prakash), then Colonel Subir (attempts to capture Jai and Roshan when they're out), then Vedant, who was shaping up as the Tony Almeida of this season.


I think mix and match is okay if he story remains interesting which I can say it is..yes earlier I also thought that Ryan chappel suit saigal character better as Ryan told jack before jack killed him that he has no one who will care..similar to saigal character who has no one..but the shivani extra effort on getting roshan history made her nore like Ryan character though she might return as Erin Driscoll..veer is Michael dessler..

When they announced ronit Roy will be part of 24 I immediately thought that this man is suitable for playing ex atu agent and jay Singh nemesis as ronit has required presence and acting skills to carry out strong negative character like Stephen saunders..but they changed the script and keep roshan as primary antagonist

To be fair I still feel they have maintained 95% of the major story line and characters actions similar to foreign season..right from miss.bhowmick past and present to antara rane track..to virus thing and even Balli death in car blast..

All in all..I am satisfied that the Indian version of 24 is a good remake of foreign original ...while the major outlines remained same..the acting the story and the tightness even after indianizing the version remains strong

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".