One Farewell Post :Why IKRS Ended !!!!

Meenakshi-rg thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Friends read many a posts and arguments on why this happened n why that happened , why son so left n why so n so entered. fans of him n fans of her . They ruined this n they ruined that !!!!

I am making this post in General terms with reference to no one in particular

AT the onset let me analyse n put down what i understand. At the peak of the show we were some 72 fans who were active here on forum and probably some silent readers . Out of these more than half live outside India !! So in my pov this number could not n never have an iota of effect on the commercials n the trps and so the show staying or going off air .

So let us not be in thos false notion that my liking so n so star n not liking so n so star made a difference.
Second most important point , eisha singh n few other actors left the show n we noticed that !

What we didnt notice was the entire team of writers n people who conceptualised IKRS had left or had been thrown out !!!
The initial writers , directors , all were gone . shahnawaz khan came for last 15 days on request as no one was ready to end the show !!!!

I strongly want to make a statement n I may be wrong , IKRS failed because of the treatment of makers in terms of script , story writing n characterisation n character growth !!Period !
We all may not accept it but we could all sense it .

Read somewhere that these jstar fans n that star fans caused the harm !!! I think its most childish to even think that .

if that was the case than going by logic sanjeeda was a bigger star with huge fan following .
Didnt see any of her fans turn up . maybe the script n character didnt interest them .
Or they could have made the show a huge hit !!


When ishita fans could come here , so could sanjeeda fans . And I am not writing this in any
negative way !!!
What I am trying to say is neither mishal , nor sanjeeda nor even amitabh bacchan can rise above the script . they can enhance a good script but not salvage a bad bad script

Many must have felt it in mishal's acting too. The disinterest . A badly written script cannot inspire any actor
And so I think he himself said he was waiting for the climax since long. And its a Fact !!

So I think we should stop saying ridiculous things about each other n stars who left or who joined . They did what they had to !!!

Many actors leave shows n many actors replace .
shows with replacement have done wonderfully well . balika vadhu , saathiya , kyunki saas .aand so many others .
there were old n new fans there too.
But what made it work n not work was TEAM EFFORT !!!!!

We become obssesive about actors n shows . We start owning them in our hearts , When the fact is what is there on screen belongs to all. Its there to be scrutinised , analysed , critisised n be praised by one and all . Neither the celebrities nor the show is anybodies personal property

The IKRS Team failed to live up to expectations post leap couldnt getb the numbers n so the show had to be pulled off air as a commercial call ! Period !

Let it end there .





Edited by Meenakshi-rg - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.8k

Users

12

Likes

154

Frequent Posters

titli_314 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
After mishal played the character of dutta in Laagi Tujhse Laagan, fans just used to die for him...
Visit the LTL forum and u will notice a large number of members who are active even today in IF.. their signatures still have "love u Dutta or love u mishal or Laagi rocks".. such kind of lines..
I was stalking a few Sanjeeda fans who really at one time used to be huge fans of the character Durga..
Where are those mishal fans and sanjeeda fans?? Only a handful of members like hammie, rama, tahera are the ex-LTLians who are here in IKRS, watching the show and discussing about it..
So what shall I say?? That those people, not present here are not mishal fans or sanjeeda fans.. Only we are becoz we had watched ikrs from day 1 till the last.?..no absolutely not..

People sit in front of their tv sets to see something good, and when the writers come up with some horrible storyline, how will fans continue watching??
Honestly, after vidha fell in love, I had lost interest from the story.. It was horrible.. Par mujhe 6:30 koi kaam nahi hota tha so I used to watch it to see how mishal was acting thats it.. None of the actors are to be blamed.. Neither eisha nor mish or Sanjeeda.. What will they do if the creative team contains a group of thick headed people who dont know how to make a particular track interesting and give it a proper closure??

Eisha is definitely not to be blamed.. She was just working for FilmFarm.. What will she do if the PH dont want to continue working with her?? Will she sit and cry and not join any other show and not continue with her acting career..??

Same is the case with sanjeeda..she was bashed for no reason... What was her fault??.-she was just doing her work.. She has both name and fame much more than eisha has but still trp did not rise..
The writers were at fault for spoiling our show which had such a sensitive concept.. It could have become a huge hit.. But the writers had made a blunder with every track and failed to attract the viewers...
People blaming mish or eisha or sanjeeda do not have a bit of maturity in them, I must say... The actors/actresses only portray the chatacters, they are not responsible for making any show boring or interesting..


Thanks for a sensible post meenu.. People need to read ur post and stop their non sense right now..

Edited by Barbie_KK9629 - 8 years ago
BBSS11 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
@barbie
I like this
People need to read ur post and stop their non sense right now.. 😆
premparbat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Hey Meenu

Good to see a post from you in a topic that needed to be addressed sooner .

Death of IKRS is only and only coz of its writing which was shaky and weak . No other reason what so ever . Not even trps . As you have pointed out that for the time slot it had above 2 or a high 1 was good enough but the Ph made a big mistakes .

In honesty it's for the makers to analyze how they murdered their own baby . The channel gave them a year which is more than what they give to other prime time shows . The actors are just the face to what happens in the back ground and in that regard Mish and Eisha put in their heart and soul which reflected and shone on our screens.

In was in a conundrum coz on one hand I wanted the show to end coz of the butchering and not coz I did not want to see my fav actor go away . By the end of it no one looked happy ... So this had to happen.

It's time we made peace with it and move ahead with our lives and to the next show that takes our fancy ,

I loved IKRS even with its many flaws and the 72 forum fans . I hope I meet you all again and Pray Mish comes back soon .

Hugs my friend.
anjaliiii thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
very well said meenu..😊
actors are only for initial attraction and rest is the story..
totally i think ikrs slips off because of ph's over ruling..

tahera57 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Many thanks for this post well said, for me it was messed up b4 even Eisha left stopped watching it then came back, I found the witing wasn't strong enough thee were loopholes after loopholes...this show could have gone on for longer if done properly, we could go on forever complaining but one thing for sure the actors did their part giving 100% ... was looking forward to some power packed acting from senior actors at the end , but they weren't given the chance... anyway thanks buddy for giving us much inside info when we were lost and confused with all the goings on.
Thanks for all your posts here , nice having known you maybe Mishal will bring us back together again soon.
Nuttyme thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Hi Meenu... Barbie... Ratna... And everyone else.
Meenu... I think most of the times we in the forum have been blaming the ph vociferously... For the shady writing and characterisation. And it was always them and them. No actor can ever be blamed for ikrs going off air. Even in the last few episodes... Mishal and Sanjeeda created a good chemistry... Way beyond what any other top running show did. That's speaks for the actors caliber...
It's sad that a ph brought the downgrade of its own baby... I still feel from my heart that this is still and cud still be the best show that Indian tv has seen. Unfortunately the expectations were not met.

Meenu... I totally admire you putting it in writing on how the show came to its end, and I don't think anyone will disagree with that.

Love to all of u... As always... Am hoping will meet you all in yet another show... Till then take care girls.
Dolly-heart thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Thank you Meenu for a great post. It is nice to see you here to say so long for now and hope I will run into you soon in another great story...

What attracted me to this show was a unique idea and a good story... I do not have any one particular actor that I follow religiously and so I do not blame any actor for the demise.

I like a finite show anyway and if the P H had kept that in mind and handled the story more than
adding unnecessary stretching of a good story and not gone for the same old tale of ...lets break the pair up and create a dumb heroine and a smart vamp and expect the story to be interesting...

The idea was to show people how Widows were treated and HOW NOT to treat them...but as usual adding "Masala" to an otherwise good story disappointed many...

One can not blame any actor, they only emote what is written , and how the story progresses is done by the P H... if these two are hell bent on ruining something they will and they did...

But in the end I look at the positive side and see that I met many good friends with a great sense of humour in this forum..I had fun with you all and I will miss you all , I hope we all come together for another "Hatke" show with fantastic creative writing and eye opening topic that we can all have fun discussing...

Take care Meenu, wish you all the best in the future ...🤗
Mishfan thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Meenu,
Glad to see ths post...agree with what you say here..
The fact that no actor / actress is above the script is 101% true...
Remember an IV of Mishal's when IKRS just started.
His words..."For any show to be successful, 60% comes from the story & 40% from
actors...that's says it all.
So the writers have a bigger responsibility & that's what screwed up this show.
But it's all over now & let bygones be bygones.
In the end it's we the fans who lost...

Thanks for writing this & hopefully clearing up doubts, if any..
All in all, I had a fun time in the forum with you all & hopefully meet you all soon
In a difft. Forum of Mishal's.
Until then, take care, you all
HUGS TO EVERYONE!!!!!
Meenakshi-rg thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Hey friends so touched to read all your replies .
Barbie ,anjalli,Ratna,sura,nutty,dolly,tahera,mishafan .Thankyou so much

I wrote this post as someone said she was being called names for loving a particular artist n ruining the show.

Friends when an artist performs he or she is up for analysis
Good or bad.
If one says I dont like sanjeeda or ishita or eisha it means i dont like her acting
N not the person .
And when u like a actor u like his or her art


We have all been mostly reasonable n peaceful
We all r here as friends .
And we will all meet in mishal forum .
And live him and bash him n enjoy him.


Edited by Meenakshi-rg - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".