ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

I promise I will never leave you. Even if you leave me!

No doubt Sona was fantastic today but for me she kept her promise, even if Dev cannot.

I will never leave you even if you do doesn't mean I will stalk you - Dev style

Neither does it mean, I will emotionally blackmail or hound you - Ishwari style

It simply means, I will respect your decision but will not abandon you even when it hurts me.

She knows Dev. Even if he cannot think of going against his Mother, she has no doubt he loves her.
She was his only Friend. She knows how lonely he is and how much in pain he
will be now.

The break up is hurting real bad but she respects Dev's decision even if she doesn't agree and
takes the effort to know he's ok. That's all she wants to know.

For me, she just kept her promise of never abandoning him and by visiting his house in his absence,
she respected his decision.

The lady then goes one step further and calls Dev out on the creepiness of stalking. But more
importantly, 'what do you want? Why don't you go ask your Mother what you want?. Grow up Mr. Dixit'

This woman doesn't hate Mr. Dixit; quite the contrary...

Sometimes showing the mirror is a much stronger part of loving that person - Make someone see the mirror that he will be pushed to 'want to see a better reflection'. Wasn't it Dev who
once said, 'you make me want to be a better person' ??!!

This lady will make both Dev & Ishwari (many moons later) want to be better people!

Asha Bose has taught her Daughter just right. Her anecdote about letting the kids jump on the sofa & fall. Trust them enough to make their own mistakes, learn and get up stronger -
I saw Sona doing just that. 'Call him out on what he's doing wrong and leave
him to think. Trust him enough to know your words will have an impact.

No sit-down discussion about relationships, balances etc can make Dev see the wrong in what
he's done because he thinks he's doing right for his Mother! Only when he Man's
up (or grows up as Sona said) can he see that every relationship has its own
respectful place.

This lady loves her Man to the moon & back. She might be caught up in the moving on mission but
she's nowhere close to ready & neither will she be able to (although she has all the right)...

There are plenty ways of moving on but the makers chose a rebound marriage. The only purpose this serves is closing the walls on Dev and pushing him to act... For me, I do not like
the idea of involving another person when Sona is clearly not ready... It's marriage
not child's play...

But am not writing this story.

AND

Ritwik -

Good boy, Good family!

What is it about damsels in distress that makes you instantly want to be the knight in shining armour?

Oh wait, there are 2 types of guys - one who marry a girl who shares their vision of the future so
they can look forward to building it together, then there are those who see a
heart bleeding for someone else and prescribe rebound marriage as the best medicine.
Ah right! He's a doctor!

"This girl is sweet. Clearly in love
with someone else. Pining for someone else. Feels unlucky that she's not with
her ex (actually wishes her ex was her present). But she wants to marry me. Let
me heal her."

'She said she is not ready today, not tomm, maybe not even day after. She's asked me to wait & help her heal. In fact, she's crying on my shoulder and I can see the hurt is so
raw'

I am not sure why someone would willingly, wholeheartedly marry someone who is clearly in love
with another? Is this the right base for a good marriage?

As the makers are great at causing confusion, am reserving my comment on the doctor in shining
armor until I know what's going on here.

No one put a gun to Sona's head and pushed her for this alliance. In fact, the Boses were
justifiably apprehensive that this might be too soon. While this is a great
trigger for Dev, am lost why another family needs to be dragged in!

Fantastic episode & a FL who has much to teach the Dixits without the need for being Mahaan!

Am still lost on where everything is headed overall. Some episodes show the same
spark of earlier days then there are those that totally frustrate... Guess I
will just leave the makers to their creative liberties and appreciate what I
can...while I can...!



Edited: New Promo
Love Bengal Tigress!! Love a strong FL ... BUT ...
So Ishwari & Dev control Sona's life and our firebrand Sona decides to control Ritwik's!
Where does that leave Ritwik?
Oh maybe, there are 2 types of people - one who are in love and the other who want to fall in love, then there's Ritwik with the healing touch 😊

But Marriage!!!

I will just hold all judgement. This promise will be broken or go the Devdas way, I don't know... Am not writing the story 😃

Edited by ARCH21 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.6k

Users

8

Likes

110

Frequent Posters

enchanted23 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2

I agree with you on Ritwik completely - helping someone to move on' when one can clearly see that she still chants and breaths her ex every living moment, should be indication enough that she needs to get on a firmer surface before she can even attempt to move, anyone in their right sense of mind would provide the support she sought when they first met - by giving the much needed time and space! One doesn't need to meet every day and ask every detail to provide support! I disagree with this third angle completely apart from putting pressure in hope to stimulate the sleeping grey cells of Dev's brain which hardly had any chance to unravel their emotional side with exception of last three months!

Sona's presence in Ishwari Niwas was as much herself as for Dev - She wanted to know from his mother (in his words his God) if he was ok - it was important for her to know from Ishwari, after all she always claimed to know her son like back of her hand, she expected a little bit of guilt, remorse even having put him through so much pain but alas! What she saw disappointed her and filled her with empathy towards her love-he had lost everything in those few seconds of devotion and his god didn't even have guts to acknowledge the sacrifice - yes the loss was his entirely his!!

I haven't come across many shows where FL is portrayed as strong, practical, brave, feisty, intelligent, career-oriented and supremely confident, down-to-earth, lively, mature and amazingly caring - Sonakshi is so real and I am hoping they do not spoil her!

gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Arch21
Fantastic post..couldn't have said it better.
In my opinion Sona has kept her promise and will continue to do so even is she marries someone else the reason I am saying it love is unconditional she told him she will be there for him even if he leaves her which she is still doing in my opinion she cares for him deeply wants only the best for him and wants him to be happy in my book she has kept her promise. Regarding her moving on she is heartbroken and needs a non involved person to help her heal by that what I mean is her family is too involved in her hurt...in comes Ritik to this day I find him to be a matured and sorted person a stark contrast to Dev. Sometimes in life it is not abour the red roses and candles it is someone who will stick by you no matter what and Ritik seems at least for now wants to do that...the cvs have chosen a Doctor...doctors do heal in this case maybe he is just what Sona needs and I maybe in the minority but I am rooting for them if Dev doesn't man up
Edited by gemini54 - 9 years ago
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Excellent points and you are absolutely right about Sona... She grew up in a family where her decisions are respected because they love her. So Sona is respecting Dev's decision because she loves him.
ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: enchanted23

I agree with you on Ritwik completely - helping someone to move on' when one can clearly see that she still chants and breaths her ex every living moment, should be indication enough that she needs to get on a firmer surface before she can even attempt to move, anyone in their right sense of mind would provide the support she sought when they first met - by giving the much needed time and space! One doesn't need to meet every day and ask every detail to provide support! I disagree with this third angle completely apart from putting pressure in hope to stimulate the sleeping grey cells of Dev's brain which hardly had any chance to unravel their emotional side with exception of last three months!

Sona's presence in Ishwari Niwas was as much herself as for Dev - She wanted to know from his mother (in his words his God) if he was ok - it was important for her to know from Ishwari, after all she always claimed to know her son like back of her hand, she expected a little bit of guilt, remorse even having put him through so much pain but alas! What she saw disappointed her and filled her with empathy towards her love-he had lost everything in those few seconds of devotion and his god didn't even have guts to acknowledge the sacrifice - yes the loss was his entirely his!!

I haven't come across many shows where FL is portrayed as strong, practical, brave, feisty, intelligent, career-oriented and supremely confident, down-to-earth, lively, mature and amazingly caring - Sonakshi is so real and I am hoping they do not spoil her!


Right there with you. I am not sure where all this leaves Ritwik and anyone knows that marrying when you are so hung up on another is calling for disaster. Its a lifetime bond, I thought.

Sona couldn't have just walked into a new life without knowing Dev was ok. Although, she had seen another side of Ishwari as well but she trusted that when it comes to her Son, this mother knows what she's doing - she was proven wrong & how! Her disappointment at seeing the callous attitude towards something that was/is so precious to the Son would have increased her worry for the Son multifold.
She stood up for herself & Dev! She stood up for the love they felt and the relationship they built. Irrespective of what happens, she kept her promise and stood with Dev all the way...

The loss is entirely his and she doesn't doubt it for one second.

I just felt her walking up to Dev and calling him out on many things wrong was her way of 'tough love'... 'We cant be together but I need to see you fine. I cant be with you so you need to grow up and be strong... If you spiral out of control, I can never stay happy'
Push him to the wall and trust him enough that he will find a way out... or at least wake up...!

@Bold: Agree with you...
Push-pull thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Beautiful!!! Very well written dear..👏

Only adding a garnish to your very well made special item..😳

The basis could have been in a complete different direction.. But but but...

Just like they took the drama route for Ishhuuu (smoking stove till sleeping pills😆) to loudly call out her stand in the love story, Ritik is only yet another route taken by the makers to bring out the love birds' stand for their own story... Is drama only a copyrighted material for Isshh🤪? We two are capable of pulling out a drama too.. tadaaa.. Riti becomes the smoking stove in between these two...😉😆

In any other way, the poor to-be-MILs will be upset with Dev, if he decides to support Sona.. And try convincing mommy...😉😆


Edited by Push-pull - 8 years ago
LiveLife321 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
With you on everything above said👏🤗
Sona was amazing, fantastic and she didn't leave any one y'day while showing mirror but who will show her mirror that one shouldn't take life changing decisions in hasty & anger esp when you are not clear about your priorities and your decision is going to involve others future. She has every right to move on after going through all this mess because of Dev but she doesn't have right to spoil another guy's life in this process. So true...Its marriage not child's play but i think for indian tv makers its a child'd play. We cant do anything on this aspect since we dont hold the control of this story.

Even i am not able to understand this Doc, when he clearly witnessing the depth of her love for Dev then why he is going ahead with this marriage?

No one put a gun to Sona's head and pushed her for this alliance. In fact, the Boses were
justifiably apprehensive that this might be too soon. While this is a great
trigger for Dev, am lost why another family needs to be dragged in!
Bang on...Yes. No one is forcing her in to marriage not even her family. I didn't get why Eri is saying again and again in the recent segments that Sona is going ahead with this marriage because of her family. I feel she is loosing her sense in anger and want to prove Dev that she can move on and he cant control or decide her life decisions. Both need a reality check and need to understand that they cant run away from their feelings and each other.😊

Lets wait and watch. Any way now a days i am taking one episode at a time & watching it without any expectations from the makers.😊
Edited by LiveLife321 - 8 years ago
ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: gemini54

Arch21

Fantastic post..couldn't have said it better.
In my opinion Sona has kept her promise and will continue to do so even is she marries someone else the reason I am saying it love is unconditional she told him she will be there for him even if he leaves her which she is still doing in my opinion she cares for him deeply wants only the best for him and wants him to be happy in my book she has kept her promise. Regarding her moving on she is heartbroken and needs a non involved person to help her heal by that what I mean is her family is too involved in her hurt...in comes Ritik to this day I find him to be a matured and sorted person a stark contrast to Dev. Sometimes in life it is not abour the red roses and candles it is someone who will stick by you no matter what and Ritik seems at least for now wants to do that...the cvs have chosen a Doctor...doctors do heal in this case maybe he is just what Sona needs and I maybe in the minority but I am rooting for them if Dev doesn't man up


Thank you ...also for sharing your feedback...

Honestly, I don't know where they want to take the story but I agree Sona needs a non-involved person... but isn't a 'would-be' husband the most involved person???? You would end up spending a life with this guy and you know you are so caught up in your ex ...
She has all the right to move on and there are many ways of doing so but they have chosen this route ... well, to squeeze Dev some more... but maybe its just me, but I wouldn't base a marriage on rebound and involve another person because he provides stability... what about this other person? Will I love him? Will he be ok with all this in the long run? The healing is ok for now but marriage is lifelong...

and again maybe its just me but Sona needs to heal and come back to herself. Why does a woman always need a man to provide the stability & completeness... She is complete in herself!

If Dev Man's up, will she leave Ritwik?

AND as Jai said in one of his interviews, for all we know he might be a VET 😃
ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Thank you 😊
Curlyhairdiary thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Fantastic post Arch😃👏👏
I'm completely with you on all of the points you mentioned. It takes great strength to do what Sonakshi is doing. I seriously feel the roles are reversed in this serial. Sonakshi is the hero who gets things done and Dev is the stereotypical heroine of daily soaps who mops around and cries all the time, without taking any real decision.
You gave me a very different perspective on Ritwik.. something to think about.. The fact that he's a doctor and his first instinct is to heal - what a beautiful inference.
Like you said, even I'm a little lost on where exactly the show is going, the Devdas route or possessive obsession route or something else entirely. Sometimes I feel the makers take one idea and then get carried away with it. They took this idea of Ishwari being very attached to her first born, and then they went overboard and turned her into a pyscho.
I feel something similar happening with Dev, though not as bad as Ishwari. I hope it doesn't go the same way it did with Ishwari.
Alas, like you said, we aren't the ones writing the script :)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".