Firstly thank you for writing an analysis post. I was starving for one on this forum!
I have recently started watching the show so I am still catching up on the previous episodes. I am going to give my two bits on the couple dynamics because the relationship of the brothers would probably take a hit when the new entries happen so...yeah!
Shivaay-Anika: The pros of these two characters are that both of them are strong headed and stubborn. Anika doesn't take every insult lying down. Sometimes she brushes them off but when the insults cut really deep, she internalizes it and doesn't react immediately. I want to see this contrast more because these scenes have more potential to bring out the differences in the character. Surbhi can do nuanced and subtle pretty well from what i saw in Qubool Hai and the PH needs to bring in her strengths to play to Anika. The character way too much of comic timing in some scenes that can be played with subtle actions.
Shivaay comes from a privileged background and even though he is hardworking, he didnt build an empire from nothing like the PH's previous leads, i.e, Arnav and Asad. They need to play a lot more in developing his narcissism since he believes in family status more than monetary. Nakul does have the potential to play a character tethering on the edge of being nauseatingly narcissistic yet redeemable. But I wouldn't want the character to be absolutely redeemed because that would kill the essence of the character.
Next is Omkara and Ishana. The first scene between them where Om says he is an excellent listener was pretty good. I definitely need more scenes between them talking about the complexities and meaning of life. I think Ishana's character development could be through these conversations. I am still deciding if is a con artist by will or force because sometimes she's deliberating her actions but at other times she isn't worried about it being on conscience. The PH wasted Rehan's character in Qubool Hai and I really don't want it to happen to Om. By far he is the most intelligent and clear headed of the three brothers. They really do need more screen time for themselves and not commenting on Shivika's relationship. Also Om's history of depression and substance abuse needs to be addressed as well as his relationship development with his parents.
Rudra and Soumya remind me of Miley Jab Hum Tum! College, alter egos. Add layers to their characters PH! They aren't just suppose to be all about comedy and laughter. I do enjoy it for sure but I loved how empathetic Soumya was at the hospital when Rudra was bawling. Bringing the partner at a vulnerable point in the other's life is a good idea only if the PH decides to continue the effect. They've reduced them squabbling kittens!
I am confused as to if the PH is trying to develop each love story one by one and how the couples affect each others' stories, if so, there needs to more clarity. The characters are strong in their own way so using them as fillers is wasting their potential.
I am glad the Svetlana angle got disposed of today. There are two many intricacies in the household already with two leads having existing partners to deal with another triangle. As always I love Dadi's character and it makes me miss Nani of IPK! Priyanka is really cute but more screen time for her please. When you bring in a character who's weak and protected please develop those characters because it does impact people who are watching the shows.
I think that the PH is taking digs at their previous shows is a bold move, especially since its extremely popular and dedicated fanbases. I am hoping Ishqbaaz goes a long way as well!
I miss the buzz of the IPK forum and their detailed analyses and lively discussions after the episodes were aired. So a shoutout to everyone who was a part to the forum 😃 You are truly missed!
Edited by peppygeek - 9 years ago
Health and Fitness
Fan Fictions
