janvi0513 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Manna ke she is an expert
Manna ke criticism help improvement
But saying she wouldn't teach Naira because she is not good enough doesn't make sense. If Naira was completely perfect why would she ask help.

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

1.7k

Users

5

Likes

17

Frequent Posters

anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
An answer regarding indian serials on quora says.. yeh rishta kya kehlata hai is a story of two rich families with no actual problems but create some for themselves n later solve themselves..
Hence proved..😆
rose2015 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
I respectfully don't agree.
The problem was Akshara/Naira in this situation and I blame writers for that.

Disrupting a kathak class because you feel your daughters needs are more important than the Guru teaching her class is wrong. You don't interrupt someone when they are teaching. Just because it is your fathers dream that you open a dance school doesn't mean the world stops for everyone else and that everyone should comply with your demands. Naira needs to learn accountability and responsibility. For example she is getting this opportunity because of Karthik making efforts to submit her form. You can make any goal for yourself but you have to go through the obstacles to achieve it. You have to put in the efforts to be successful.

Writers are messing up Akshara's character. The whole dialogue in that scene was wrong. The teacher was saying right.
Classical dance teachers are strict and you need to respect their rules. They hold their art in high regards and want serious students who want to learn for the right reasons. They will clearly say that if you are not serious it is better you join a Bollywood class to learn the latest item song instead of pursuing classical.
For example in my daughters class you don't come in pants you have to wear a suit and have your hair tied back. Parents are not allowed in the room when teaching is going on because it disrupts the class and we see Akshara interferes when Naira falls. It is good that the teacher is strict because I think Naira needs to learn to respect others and their rules. With this teacher she is not going to have freedom to do as she pleases. She will have to respect the teachers rules and work hard towards her goals of becoming a good dancer. It is better to learn from your mistakes now and have them corrected than to keep making the same mistake. They are showing Akshara very weak which I don't like. Show her as a strong person. Besides being a mother and wife she needs to make her own identity.
Edited by rose2015 - 9 years ago
harivij thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
I also found it weird wearing pants and leaving ur hair loose actually they have dress code in a class. But yesterday we can excuse because they went to just ask permission from guru maa but guru maa insisted to start the class then itself.
Akshara as a mother should be little strong but sometimes Naira is too arrogant. Please cvs don't portray Naira like that. Akshara cannot be the reason for all obstacles in Naira s life. It is too much. Naira needs to be little toned down which guru maa will do. Parents cannot see the flaws in a child that y we have teachers in life.
Joshua_TANHA thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: harivij

I also found it weird wearing pants and leaving ur hair loose actually they have dress code in a class. But yesterday we can excuse because they went to just ask permission from guru maa but guru maa insisted to start the class then itself.

Akshara as a mother should be little strong but sometimes Naira is too arrogant. Please cvs don't portray Naira like that. Akshara cannot be the reason for all obstacles in Naira s life. It is too much. Naira needs to be little toned down which guru maa will do. Parents cannot see the flaws in a child that y we have teachers in life.

Naira cannt be toned down when it comes to Akshara. she blames AK for leaving home the struggle for her survival so it is obvious that she would be arrogant towards AK though I feel for AK.
As Guruma she was rude to them at home too😃😆
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
No dance teacher is as rude as they show here.. they are strict but never rude..as to wearing pants .. yeah there is always a dress code.. in south its more strictly followed.
And here i feel its not naira but akshara who shpuld b toned down.. she cant always be portrayed the mahaan atma ..
Anyways when it gomes to pursuing classical dance or music parents should never talk when child is being questioned ..parents need to giv that space to teacher-student ..
The 16years i.learnt carnatic music, parents were never allowed to talk to the teacher except for paying fees or asking them how we are singing.. and nothing more than that..
Who will make a display of all trophies when ur teacher comes home.. did naira ask.. ? No..that says it all
janvi0513 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: rose2015

I respectfully don't agree.
The problem was Akshara/Naira in this situation and I blame writers for that.

Disrupting a kathak class because you feel your daughters needs are more important than the Guru teaching her class is wrong. You don't interrupt someone when they are teaching. Just because it is your fathers dream that you open a dance school doesn't mean the world stops for everyone else and that everyone should comply with your demands. Naira needs to learn accountability and responsibility. For example she is getting this opportunity because of Karthik making efforts to submit her form. You can make any goal for yourself but you have to go through the obstacles to achieve it. You have to put in the efforts to be successful.

Writers are messing up Akshara's character. The whole dialogue in that scene was wrong. The teacher was saying right.
Classical dance teachers are strict and you need to respect their rules. They hold their art in high regards and want serious students who want to learn for the right reasons. They will clearly say that if you are not serious it is better you join a Bollywood class to learn the latest item song instead of pursuing classical.
For example in my daughters class you don't come in pants you have to wear a suit and have your hair tied back. Parents are not allowed in the room when teaching is going on because it disrupts the class and we see Akshara interferes when Naira falls. It is good that the teacher is strict because I think Naira needs to learn to respect others and their rules. With this teacher she is not going to have freedom to do as she pleases. She will have to respect the teachers rules and work hard towards her goals of becoming a good dancer. It is better to learn from your mistakes now and have them corrected than to keep making the same mistake. They are showing Akshara very weak which I don't like. Show her as a strong person. Besides being a mother and wife she needs to make her own identity.


Just so you I made this post before yesterday's episode aired for day before yesterday's episode.
harivij thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Actually guru maa had the attitude and arrogance in her. A guru needs to be strict but polite. Display of trophies and wanted to show videos y they want to learn from guru maa then y portray they achieved so much . Everyone were wrong there.these serials are there only to portray unnecessary drama.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".