The Dixits - Beautiful people who are so broken inside

Buzzinnn... thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

Many of us know that this is not a typical mother-son relationship. Both of them are highly dysfunctional people. They're so co-dependent on each other. And this co-dependency has made Dev overly responsible. He doesn't seem to be able to get out of it. Ishwari because of her situation was forced to put the entire responsibility of the family on Dev's shoulders when he was very young. And Dev became a parent long before he was ready to be one. We've seen Ishwari telling Mamaji, that she herself wasn't sure who the parent was & who was the child. Dev, with the kind of upbringing he's had, the only thing he's learnt to do is to shower unconditional love & support to his mother & his sisters. He has always ended up sacrificing & dedicating his life by putting his family's needs first than his very own needs. And finally, we saw a Dev breaking out from that hold when he fell in love with Sona. All those feelings were completely new to him. Sona is a breath of fresh air in Dev's life. His confession was brilliant, the way he's been cornering & lingering around her gave us all goosebumps..and those amazing dialogues. But amidst all this, his attention to his mother & sisters had diminished little bit. He never ignored them, it's just that he didn't give them top priority & attention. But if you think about it, just like how Ishwari gives full attention & priority to Dev, in the same way he was giving full attention & priority to Sona... I see no difference in them at all. He was transferring the same importance & value that his mother has for him into his relationship as well. Well, you can't blame him for that, because that's what he's learnt from his mother till now... Just like how Ishwari needed Dev all for herself, he was beginning to need Sona all for himself. Like mother, like son! There's no balance at all here. I want Dev to first take care of himself as a separate independent person, without the help of Ishwari or Sona. And when the time comes for Dev & Sona to part ways, I want Dev to yearn for her, not in the obsessive possessive way. But in a way where he experiences a sense of emptiness, longing & the lack of having his true friend.

At the same time, we've Ishwari who has begun to notice that Dev can actually make decisions without sharing it with her first & we can clearly see her discomfort. She can't confront him & say I'm a possessive, insecure needy mother.. Can she? Instead she's using manipulative ways & guilt. She says, "If you spend time with me, I'll be perfectly fine". Isn't she putting the responsibility of her distress on his shoulder again?? And how does Dev react to all this?? He's doesn't know anything else, other than always pleasing his mother. So he just ends up being silent/blank whenever she says anything. This is such a complex situation. And why should we blame Ishwari?? She was young, when her husband died & she was left with four children to look after. What could she have possibly done? She worked, ended up thrusting the family's responsibility on Dev & ended up making Neha the mother of two kids. Was there any other way she could see things work out for her & her children without the presence of a husband & a father? This was the sensible option then but the kind of damage it's done to Dev & Neha is disastrous. Yes, what Dev brought home at the end of the day was only profitable & quantifiable for her & the family and whereas she completely turned a blind eye to recognize Neha's efforts. Just to clarify..were there any flash back scenes where Ishwari was present around Neha when she was looking after Riya & Nikki?? I agree that she didn't equally appreciate the efforts of Dev & Neha & I want her to realize that as the story progresses. A mother's unconditional love & her emotional availability are the most significant & important necessities for a child. And Dev got that in too much abundance from his mother & Neha didn't get half as much Dev did. If the spoilers are true & if Neha comes back... It just proves my point. She cannot function without the support of her family. She's highly dependent on her brother. And in the same way, Dev cannot function without Ishwari & vice versa. Ishwari, Dev & Neha all have flaws & they are so deeply rooted. It's going to be difficult but all of them have to work together to bring about the change in themselves. One person changing alone will not work. It's really sad to see such beautiful people so deeply broken inside. Don't blame Ishwari yet, am sure there's more to her side of her story. And we've got to wait...Khatriji is still hanging in the air... And if Ishwari is going to take out her anger on Sona for the way in which her son is behaving...then yes, please go ahead & blame her. She has no right to do that to Sona. Sona doesn't deserve her wrath. And where does Sona come into this?? Her upbringing says everything about her. Her family is so different, so normal. We've always wondered why they keep showing scenes of the Bose family. They are not mere fillers. They are an example of a happy normal family (Period). It'll be Sona who will be facing this complicated, dysfunctional family. Poor girl. Sona will be broken, but she will pick up the pieces & walk with her head held high. And if she needs to share her feelings with anyone, her entire family will be there for her. Yes, each of them will have their own opinions & suggestions but all of that shows the aspect of moving forward in life. Whereas, the Dixit's don't seem to want to move forward at all.

This was my supposed to be my weekend rant..😕 Kinda late...but never too late to rant I guess.. Hope I don't sound confusing at all. I may be completely wrong in looking at things...This mother son duo has definitely gotten me a little rattled...😕

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.3k

Users

9

Likes

60

Frequent Posters

Loveforlife thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
The past has affected the Dixit family in a big way. Mentally they all are still stuck in the past. It is true that one should never forget ones humble beginnings because that is what keeps us grounded, but it's also true that one must not let ones past colour every aspect of ones present and future. Past should reflect in our thinking and less in our actions.
In the past Dev used to finish the halwa Ishwari used to make, he loved and loves the halwa she makes. But now Dev is grown up, he decided to eat less of the halwa for health's sake but Ishwari was offended that he did not finish the halwa as he used to in the past. The mental thought that Dev Loves the halwa she makes is not enough for her. She wants Dev to keep proving his love for her in actions.

Dev too keeps thinking about buying gifts for everyone to show his love. But he does not realise how wrong it is. His intentions are right.. He loves his family but his past colours his present. The act of being the provider just does not leave him. He has thus made love something tangible.

But after meeting Sona, slowly he has started seeing love as intangible.

Yes the Dixit's are broken inside.. Constantly looking for 'the' thing that would heal them.
Push-pull thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
👏👏Loved your ranting!!! Will join you as well... 🤗

Dev-Ishwari-Neha: I wouldn't want anyone else coming in between them to mess their already messed up relationship 😆... If they do then they at their own risk... 😆 They will only take the blame on themselves for the new problems that they might create while in fact the problem has been already there existing among the Dixits for long long time🤔... If Ishwari hasn't let the sisters come in between her and her son, now it's the time for Dev to break that thing and let them in😊... Giving a reality check to Ishwari...He cannot be enjoying all the attention of his mother all to himself and then looking for someone else to be the solution for all other problems of his and his sisters😆... It should be either him or his mother who can get them there... Now it must be an opening to them with someone else already coming in between their relationship... To open the long closed relationship within their family!!!😃

Dev-Sona: Their moments can never fail to soothe my ranting mind... How I wish Dev-Sona first fight be something about themselves❤️... And it was a perfect topic that started as well... Opening about their relationship to their family!!! I would have loved to see Sona differing in wanting to tell her family about their relationship and let Dev take his own time.. and like Dev not wanting it that way... But no... instead our lovely Sona fell for the being a chocolate that Dev doesn't want to share with anyone!!! Cute but next time around I want Sona to pick a fight on this and decide to tell her family about them even though Dev is not happy about it... She has her own values too...😃🤗

bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Buzzinnn...

Many of us know that this is not a typical mother-son relationship. Both of them are highly dysfunctional people. They're so co-dependent on each other. And this co-dependency has made Dev overly responsible. He doesn't seem to be able to get out of it. Ishwari because of her situation was forced to put the entire responsibility of the family on Dev's shoulders when he was very young. And Dev became a parent long before he was ready to be one. We've seen Ishwari telling Mamaji, that she herself wasn't sure who the parent was & who was the child. Dev, with the kind of upbringing he's had, the only thing he's learnt to do is to shower unconditional love & support to his mother & his sisters. He has always ended up sacrificing & dedicating his life by putting his family's needs first than his very own needs. And finally, we saw a Dev breaking out from that hold when he fell in love with Sona. All those feelings were completely new to him. Sona is a breath of fresh air in Dev's life. His confession was brilliant, the way he's been cornering & lingering around her gave us all goosebumps..and those amazing dialogues. But amidst all this, his attention to his mother & sisters had diminished little bit. He never ignored them, it's just that he didn't give them top priority & attention. But if you think about it, just like how Ishwari gives full attention & priority to Dev, in the same way he was giving full attention & priority to Sona... I see no difference in them at all. He was transferring the same importance & value that his mother has for him into his relationship as well. Well, you can't blame him for that, because that's what he's learnt from his mother till now... Just like how Ishwari needed Dev all for herself, he was beginning to need Sona all for himself. Like mother, like son! There's no balance at all here. I want Dev to first take care of himself as a separate independent person, without the help of Ishwari or Sona. And when the time comes for Dev & Sona to part ways, I want Dev to yearn for her, not in the obsessive possessive way. But in a way where he experiences a sense of emptiness, longing & the lack of having his true friend.

At the same time, we've Ishwari who has begun to notice that Dev can actually make decisions without sharing it with her first & we can clearly see her discomfort. She can't confront him & say I'm a possessive, insecure needy mother.. Can she? Instead she's using manipulative ways & guilt. She says, "If you spend time with me, I'll be perfectly fine". Isn't she putting the responsibility of her distress on his shoulder again?? And how does Dev react to all this?? He's doesn't know anything else, other than always pleasing his mother. So he just ends up being silent/blank whenever she says anything. This is such a complex situation. And why should we blame Ishwari?? She was young, when her husband died & she was left with four children to look after. What could she have possibly done? She worked, ended up thrusting the family's responsibility on Dev & ended up making Neha the mother of two kids. Was there any other way she could see things work out for her & her children without the presence of a husband & a father? This was the sensible option then but the kind of damage it's done to Dev & Neha is disastrous. Yes, what Dev brought home at the end of the day was only profitable & quantifiable for her & the family and whereas she completely turned a blind eye to recognize Neha's efforts. Just to clarify..were there any flash back scenes where Ishwari was present around Neha when she was looking after Riya & Nikki?? I agree that she didn't equally appreciate the efforts of Dev & Neha & I want her to realize that as the story progresses. A mother's unconditional love & her emotional availability are the most significant & important necessities for a child. And Dev got that in too much abundance from his mother & Neha didn't get half as much Dev did. If the spoilers are true & if Neha comes back... It just proves my point. She cannot function without the support of her family. She's highly dependent on her brother. And in the same way, Dev cannot function without Ishwari & vice versa. Ishwari, Dev & Neha all have flaws & they are so deeply rooted. It's going to be difficult but all of them have to work together to bring about the change in themselves. One person changing alone will not work. It's really sad to see such beautiful people so deeply broken inside. Don't blame Ishwari yet, am sure there's more to her side of her story. And we've got to wait...Khatriji is still hanging in the air... And if Ishwari is going to take out her anger on Sona for the way in which her son is behaving...then yes, please go ahead & blame her. She has no right to do that to Sona. Sona doesn't deserve her wrath. And where does Sona come into this?? Her upbringing says everything about her. Her family is so different, so normal. We've always wondered why they keep showing scenes of the Bose family. They are not mere fillers. They are an example of a happy normal family (Period). It'll be Sona who will be facing this complicated, dysfunctional family. Poor girl. Sona will be broken, but she will pick up the pieces & walk with her head held high. And if she needs to share her feelings with anyone, her entire family will be there for her. Yes, each of them will have their own opinions & suggestions but all of that shows the aspect of moving forward in life. Whereas, the Dixit's don't seem to want to move forward at all.

This was my supposed to be my weekend rant..😕 Kinda late...but never too late to rant I guess.. Hope I don't sound confusing at all. I may be completely wrong in looking at things...This mother son duo has definitely gotten me a little rattled...😕



Well written!

Somehow after watching yesterday's episode I ended up feeling bad for Sona being caught in the midst of this complex dynamic. Strangely enough I did not get that feeling because of that scene with Ishwari because that one actually made sense. She does not know they are in a relationship so she can feel emotional about her son not eating something she knows he loves and which she made with a lot of effort. My mother is that way too, she makes stuff that is unhealthy but will obviously be hurt if we avoid it completely

I felt bad for Sona after her cafe date with Dev actually. The vibes from the scene indicate a relationship driven by him - when to get into it, when to make it public (even when it seemed to mean a lot to her to go public but he dismissed it rather casually), when to stay apart with little room for her to influence any major milestone. Even all the love that he showers on her somehow could not banish that feeling..

Someone wrote something I liked in another thread ...Sona needs to move out of Dixit house, needs to stop roaming the house looking for someone to heal...Her value in his life is not on account of her ability interfere and help him resolve his family issues. I so want her to have a life of her own..Post the accident phase, that aspect diminished on the show, everything about Sona became about Sona-Dev whereas there are many things about Dev on the show that have nothing to do with Sona..

Sorry if I have digressed from the point of our post in my reply but when I read about the complex Dixit family, these thoughts were uppermost in my mind...:)
surbharati thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
We have seen that Neha understand Ishwari better (Like change in any thing related to Dev ...Maa will not accept..this was line by Neha when Dev bought Saree for Ishwari)..and many other instances...So when this track will go down with separation...one day only Neha will be the one who will join the pieces...will make Ishwari Realize...and bring Dev-Sonakshi together...
adoremevirgo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
nice analysis...the separation track is actually needed for dev to realize that relationships r not meant to be to used as sacrifices...ishwari's disapproval doesnt gv him the rite to push sona away from himself...
sometimes distance is needed for two hearts to find the way to become one again...
saumiee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Lovely analysis dear😊
I am very confused about what actually Dev-Ishwari bond is? Do they actually understand each other. . Or are busy being the ideal son and mother that they forget to share what they are actually feeling.
Dev thinks love is just that . . And thus he did not want to share the Ranveer thing with her, just like he does with Ishwari. . It is sona who coaxes him into telling..and reminds him that love is not only about sweet talks but sharing the bitterness together.
I agree, Dev is quite a reflection of Ishwari that ways, he wants to keep Sona to himself just like how Ishwari wants to keep Dev to herself.
Obviously the intensity of both these obsessions or possessiveness is different because the relations are not alike. One is mother and son, while the other is that of lovers. However Dev is much more mild and meeker version because A. He is sensitive than Ishwari B. Ishwari has strong emotional background to be clinging to Dev.
Sometimes I wonder if Dev is actually possessive for sonakshi, specially after yesterday's episode. . The way he walked out on her. .when He said that he doesn't want to share her. . It was more of his sub conscious mind refraining him to enter a situation where he could enter a conflict.
Edited by saumiee - 9 years ago
telly_buff thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Awesome Analysis

I second it that Sona and Dev should part ways. It is only then Dev would realize whom his heart really yearns for.

Sona is going to face the brunt. I am sure Dev would tell Sona to leave the job. He would be the one to initiate a separation.

Even i felt bad when he left her at the cafe alone and left the cafe without paying the bill. He himself told Sona that we would sort out our differences. Dev should practice before e preaches.

So now onward whenever there is a fight, it is Sona who will always say Sorry and compromise. Hadn't she apologized. He wouldn't have waited for her. He wanted her to say Sorry first.


Buzzinnn... thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Loveforlife

The past has affected the Dixit family in a big way. Mentally they all are still stuck in the past. It is true that one should never forget ones humble beginnings because that is what keeps us grounded, but it's also true that one must not let ones past colour every aspect of ones present and future. Past should reflect in our thinking and less in our actions.

In the past Dev used to finish the halwa Ishwari used to make, he loved and loves the halwa she makes. But now Dev is grown up, he decided to eat less of the halwa for health's sake but Ishwari was offended that he did not finish the halwa as he used to in the past. The mental thought that Dev Loves the halwa she makes is not enough for her. She wants Dev to keep proving his love for her in actions.

Dev too keeps thinking about buying gifts for everyone to show his love. But he does not realise how wrong it is. His intentions are right.. He loves his family but his past colours his present. The act of being the provider just does not leave him. He has thus made love something tangible.

But after meeting Sona, slowly he has started seeing love as intangible.

Yes the Dixit's are broken inside.. Constantly looking for 'the' thing that would heal them.


Oh yes! The past is what that has completely disrupted the Dixit's. I was wondering, if only Dev's father was alive, I think theirs would have been like any other normal family. They always looked back into the past more often than looking ahead. Sad! But about the halwa issue, I feel if Dev hadn't uttered Sona's name & if he'd simply said that he'd eaten too much unhealthy food during the wedding & didn't want to eat too much halwa, I feel she would've understood him & agreed on a little bit...But to hear him say that 'Ms.Bose' told him not to eat unhealthy food got her completely miffed. She's his mother & it was 'her duty' to tell her children what is healthy & unhealthy. She didn't like someone else taking charge of her role...And I completely agree about the fact that she always wanted him to prove his love for her. It gave her some kind of reassurance..

17 years of giving & contributing to the family is not going to stop Dev from gifting/giving anything to anyone. And he did exactly that in yesterday's episode...In spite of Sona clearly explaining it to him that he was interfering with Neha & Ranveer's lives...he still didn't get the picture. Giving is an in-built trait now in Dev. But if you look, he's always gifted Sona things as well...the earrings, the saree & the jewellery... That's the way he knows how to shower his love..

Buzzinnn... thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Push-pull

👏👏Loved your ranting!!! Will join you as well... 🤗

Dev-Ishwari-Neha: I wouldn't want anyone else coming in between them to mess their already messed up relationship 😆... If they do then they at their own risk... 😆 They will only take the blame on themselves for the new problems that they might create while in fact the problem has been already there existing among the Dixits for long long time🤔... If Ishwari hasn't let the sisters come in between her and her son, now it's the time for Dev to break that thing and let them in😊... Giving a reality check to Ishwari...He cannot be enjoying all the attention of his mother all to himself and then looking for someone else to be the solution for all other problems of his and his sisters😆... It should be either him or his mother who can get them there... Now it must be an opening to them with someone else already coming in between their relationship... To open the long closed relationship within their family!!!😃

Dev-Sona: Their moments can never fail to soothe my ranting mind... How I wish Dev-Sona first fight be something about themselves❤️... And it was a perfect topic that started as well... Opening about their relationship to their family!!! I would have loved to see Sona differing in wanting to tell her family about their relationship and let Dev take his own time.. and like Dev not wanting it that way... But no... instead our lovely Sona fell for the being a chocolate that Dev doesn't want to share with anyone!!! Cute but next time around I want Sona to pick a fight on this and decide to tell her family about them even though Dev is not happy about it... She has her own values too...😃🤗


Thank you so much 🤗 Oh yes, the Dixit 's should handle their issues on their own, it's too messed up...So many years of mess 😕 And I don't want Sona to be anywhere close to them. Poor girl, she doesn't know what she's gotten into!

Oh yes, Dev & Sona .........😆 Letting the respective folks know about the person you want to be with for the rest of your life is an huge call.. I kind of didn't like how he took complete charge of the situation & cut her off immediately by saying that he's didn't want to share her with anyone. Found him a bit aloof. I expected a little more discussion on that front. Him asking her if her parents would agree or not... He just thought about it from his pov & expected her to stick to his decision..which she invariably did. I would've been ok even if he said what Elena said - Chori chupke pyar karne ki maza kuch aur hai or something like giving themselves more time to get to know each other. But this 'not sharing business' sounded just like his mother 😕
Edited by Buzzinnn... - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".