Should Ash stick to red carpets and commercials only ? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Justmoi

If BW is filled with more good actors than people we put up with I would 100% agree with this statement. But you just cannot have a 15 year plus year career without something in the acting department. No way. If her beauty is the only reason keeping her here, we would have Sush, Lara Dutta, Sonali Bendre and so many spectacularly beautiful women have longer careers.

Even starkids who enter BW and were given chance after chance long after they should have gone could not make it like Uday and Tusshar. The market just does not work that way. The bad performers are weeded out by the audience. I agree she is shrill when she screams, but the fact that she is standing here after so many years means she is more than a pretty face. As for the Bachchan name meaning anything, it should have given her husband a better career, what she has is all hers IMO. The good and bad.

Originally posted by: cougarTown

exceptions are always there..another such exception is katrina kaif..she has a 13 years career and still going and i don't even need to comment on her acting skills or lack of it :p

having said that..no i don't intend to say aish is as bad as kat..but i don't relate to your theory

she need to choose the right role not just iam back watch me she did great in nany good role and film but now she did bad role and bad performance thats it

Originally posted by: Justmoi

I do agree that Kat is the exception to this theory. She is a perfect example of a flowerpot career where her looks and her dancing is important in her career. But if it was that easy to have one BW will be littered with careers like that. She stands alone in that.

In the case of Ash shas worked in multiple industries and you can see the work there. Kat has worked in Malayalam too, with Mammoty. Ash has worked with Mammoty in Tamil. It was early in their careers and you can see the quality of work with a giant like Mammoty. Ash's career is a average work with sparks of good work. But I still stand by my theory that the audience would have weeded out bad work. Kat did something right to have that 13 year career be it dancing, glamor . You just cannot have that length of a career without having something to appeal to an audience.