Weekly discussion topic # 1 - Portrayal of love in TV shows

Page

Next Last

rosesidni

@rosesidni

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

From this week every weekend we'll TRY to have a Weekly discussion topic😛. Everyone do try to participate in it , even silent members are welcome to put in ur views about the topic😛 The comment can be small or big, it doesn't matter, participation is imp..

So, since this was the Valentines week, lets have a discussion about LOVE❤️ and ofcourse its portrayal in TV as a whole and JR in particular.. The questions u should try to address are..

1. How realistic is the portrayal of love in TV shows in general? What have u found absurd about love on TV? How realistic is love portrayed in JR?

2. Why u find SidNi love story, the best among a lot (if u find it so, if not why😆)? What is the USP of SidNi love story for u?

3. How much boldness and physical intimacy of a couple, Indian shows can take up? Since it is said many scenes r embarrasing to be watched with the family😆 Do u think CVs should limit the amount of boldness in JR?😆 Or do u think other shows should replicate JR bold romance so that Indian audience becomes capable of watching any bold romance😆😲😆

Do discuss about the topic.. U can talk about all the issues/ questions raised or any one😛

Edited by rosesidni - 10 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

prathe

@prathe

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

Realistic potrayal of lvemore than that i wud prefer saying a perfect magination of love stories cos in real nowadys its hard to find cos we see lve in twiiter insta fb pda's more

so what we see may nt be real in most of case i just prefer to keep it as entertaiment to viewrs actors hard wrk and chemisty emotions thy emote

Sidni stry is best cos here trust factor is there which hero heroin are equally impprt its nt always femaale leads carying burden on her shoulder dialogues are quiet natural and fun

usp is their eye talks and ofcourse bindaas and no location constaints wen it comes to romance

Wat we see in JR is nothing as its internet wrld if thy cant watch on tv option is there for thm to watch online alone😆 or to say switch it😆

Audience are now more open minded i feel some prefer to shw some hide it

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

skinnypal

@skinnypal

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Wow Rose Nice topic of discussion on valentine's day! 😛

1.Frankly speaking portrayal of love in movies and TV are overrated. For me it's impossible to be in love like this 😆 The absurd part of love in TV specifically is how the leads goes through so much of ups and downs but they still stick together. How quick some leads are ready to sacrifice their "love" for the sake of a greater goodness. I am sorry, but that's impossible in real life. No practical person will do stuff like those.

In JR the SidNi love is HIGHLY unrealistic, it's like a fantasy for me and i love fantasies ;)

2.The best part of SidNi is as an individual character both Sid and Roshni are unique from what we have seen on TV. Where one is a very real character and the other is very unreal - it gives us a glimpse of something new. USP is NiVi.

3.I think Indian TV should grow up in terms of romance, they should make shows generically so that people will know which show they can watch with their family and which they can't.

Quote

abinaya98

@abinaya98

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

Nice topic rose...👏

1. No way.. Sidni love nd generally all love stories in serial nd movie's r highly unrealistic.. But sidni first phase without constant meeting..it looked little realistic😆😆

But seriously love in seirals s highly unrealistic

2. I felt attached to sidni more s NiVi..first when insaw few episodes.

Didn't feel so Mich connect.. But after seeing d epi frm d intual in a go..I fell in love wid Ravi ..I already love nia...so.NiVi chemistry nd their scenes important importance to sidni throughout s d USP..

3. Depends on d family..some family prefer bold ..some prefer normal...I don't know..but bold level should be like Jr atleast in other seials...but its k...nay be 2 yrs ...more bold wil be seen...

Quote

abirami

@madhuharini

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

1. How realistic is the portrayal of love in TV shows in general? What have u found absurd about love on TV? How realistic is love portrayed in JR?

I love 'love stories' only in books, Tv soaps and movies. Donno how do it'ld affect oneself in real life😛 And I was a biggest hater of love, marriage and all, though I have no love failures or any related experiences😆 Till I saw virman cancer track, I didn't like any love stories even in movies also.. Donno why and how I was such a bad girl that time😆 But frm virman luv story, I thought may be in someone's life, love may workout as like Virman. My frnds always use to advise and try to change such thoughts from me and now I got changed a lot I think bcoz of their counsel😛😛 Bcoz of Virman luv only I started to read some other luv stories, fictions in IF, books and try to accept love sometimes😳 But SidNi luv inspired me so much beyond anything😃😳 Luv stories being shown in TV are just fictional and we know well, but still showing unrealistic things as realistic ones becoming their successful part and SidNi is the best example specially Sid's luv for his wife❤️ I donno anyone can love his wife like Sid.. may be😳😳

2. Why u find SidNi love story, the best among a lot (if u find it so, if not why😆)? What is the USP of SidNi love story for u?

I find SidNi luv story the best among anything and I can't specify 1 particular reason alone😛 I am impressed bcoz of so many things I captured from them...

the trust thy have on each other, undergoing so many hurdles without losing any hope, their positivity, being each other's energy, confidence, they never trust anyone other than each other even their own parents which is making it difficult for others to separate them, being each other's breathe and life, the feel I am getting from their intimacy and last but not the least the love they having for each other all making SidNi luv very special for my eyes and I swear I'ld not see any couple like them 😳❤️

3. How much boldness and physical intimacy of a couple, Indian shows can take up?

That depends on the actors' comfort level I think so... If they are not comfortable, how much ever they get close we can't feel their chemistry, passion or anything. And I am happy that NiVi is the best of all doing such bold and intimate scenes with a great comfort level😳

Since it is said many scenes r embarrasing to be watched with the family😆 Do u think CVs should limit the amount of boldness in JR?😆 Or do u think other shows should replicate JR bold romance so that Indian audience becomes capable of watching any bold romance😆😲😆

I have no problem how bold and hot SidNi romance goes bcoz I never watch any luv story/movies particularly this JR and SidNI with my family 😆😆 I can never set a boundary level for the romance specially to my SidNi romance bcoz they reaching any kinda boldness and creating new history in romance is a #fullpower treat for my eyes and my craze for them also increases and go limitless in that case😳😳

Do discuss about the topic.. U can talk about all the issues/ questions raised or any one😛

Lovely discussion topics & questions set by U Rose babee 🤗 Wish everyone should participate and have fun with us 😳

Quote

Aayushi

@A.Green

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

1. No story be it on TV or in Movies , or even the books for that matter is realistic. But we can't really blame TV or any of these media for the wrong or incorrect description. They frankly show us what we want. In reality , the things we see in daily soaps are the things we want in real life and since we can't have it in real life we are content and happy seeing it on celluloid. Though we can't say that the love stories portrayed are totally unrealistic. For instance in JR , on one side lovers looking for their long lost love like Sid kept looking for Roshni in Bangkok is very absurd and happens only in a dream world. No one cares so much for anyone but again lovers standing beside the ones they love is true. Like how Sid stood beside Roshni when they lost their child , that was pretty realistic in my opinion. That's all on this point.

2. Well can't say they are the best of the lot , there are others which are as good as them. Obviously they feature among the best for me. The fact that makes them so good is the amount of emotions that are shown during their love story. The pain is shown wonderfully , the love is shown beautifully and even the tears have an effect! Sometimes when they are together on screen there is a big smile on the face and at times there is a frown. It is because of the phases their love has gone through. Their love story is really one in a million.

3. In my opinion we are the new generation and if we can talk about these things , we can see the things as well. I mean why to stop them from doing these scenes when on one hand we are openly talking of live-in relationships and intimacy so openly. We should become more open-minded , obviously there's a thin line between vulgar and aesthetic , and I am happy that JR CVs haven't crossed that line. According to my perspective it gets embarrassing to watch it in front of parents as they haven't quite moved forward from the "old concept" of serials where puppy love was shown. Yes , this is also another realistic approach of Indian TV by the way. Showing boldness is the reality and that should be shown but to a certain limit which of course the censor board will set.

Lovely topic Rose and happy Valentine's Day to all. Keep falling in love , it is a nice feeling🤗

Also do join in the discussion folks.!!!😃

Edited by Aayu27 - 10 years ago

Quote

Aayushi

@A.Green

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

Rose where's your viewpoint on the topic?? I am awaiting that

Quote

Aayushi

@A.Green

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: prathe
Realistic potrayal of lvemore than that i wud prefer saying a perfect magination of love stories cos in real nowadys its hard to find cos we see lve in twiiter insta fb pda's more
so what we see may nt be real in most of case i just prefer to keep it as entertaiment to viewrs actors hard wrk and chemisty emotions thy emote

Sidni stry is best cos here trust factor is there which hero heroin are equally impprt its nt always femaale leads carying burden on her shoulder dialogues are quiet natural and fun

usp is their eye talks and ofcourse bindaas and no location constaints wen it comes to romance

Wat we see in JR is nothing as its internet wrld if thy cant watch on tv option is there for thm to watch online alone😆 or to say switch it😆

Audience are now more open minded i feel some prefer to shw some hide it

@bold I totally agree with this. The internet is very vast as compared to TV.

Quote

Aayushi

@A.Green

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: skinnypal
Wow Rose Nice topic of discussion on valentine's day! 😛
1.Frankly speaking portrayal of love in movies and TV are overrated. For me it's impossible to be in love like this 😆 The absurd part of love in TV specifically is how the leads goes through so much of ups and downs but they still stick together. How quick some leads are ready to sacrifice their "love" for the sake of a greater goodness. I am sorry, but that's impossible in real life. No practical person will do stuff like those.
In JR the SidNi love is HIGHLY unrealistic, it's like a fantasy for me and i love fantasies ;)

2.The best part of SidNi is as an individual character both Sid and Roshni are unique from what we have seen on TV. Where one is a very real character and the other is very unreal - it gives us a glimpse of something new. USP is NiVi.

3.I think Indian TV should grow up in terms of romance, they should make shows generically so that people will know which show they can watch with their family and which they can't.

@bold true that Pal , no one is so MAHAAN!!😆😆

Quote

Aayushi

@A.Green

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: Purni12
Nice topic rose...👏
1. No way.. Sidni love nd generally all love stories in serial nd movie's r highly unrealistic.. But sidni first phase without constant meeting..it looked little realistic😆😆
But seriously love in seirals s highly unrealistic
2. I felt attached to sidni more s NiVi..first when insaw few episodes.
Didn't feel so Mich connect.. But after seeing d epi frm d intual in a go..I fell in love wid Ravi ..I already love nia...so.NiVi chemistry nd their scenes important importance to sidni throughout s d USP..
3. Depends on d family..some family prefer bold ..some prefer normal...I don't know..but bold level should be like Jr atleast in other seials...but its k...nay be 2 yrs ...more bold wil be seen...

@bold same purni , I didn't feel the connect initially , then saw some bunch of episodes together and started watching but my case was different too. I already loved Ravi and now love Nia too but a bit less than him!😛

Quote

1 2 3 4

Weekly discussion topic # 1 - Portrayal of love in TV shows

Related Topics

Explore Topics