sania_58 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

For the First time, I am writing something on Karna.Please forgive me for any mistake.Its completely my point of view & most importantly I am not a scholar.So, with my limited knowledge, a small write up on Karna.

If anyone ask me Who is your favourite character in Mahabharata, then without any doubt, my answer will be Karna.
Sometimes, I wonder, Why it is??He knew the conspiracy of Laksagriha.He was a part of Dyut Sabha. He also took part in the murder of Abhimanyu.
Answer is very simple. Karna is a common human being & No one is Perfect.But the allegations against him are serious,
Then why some people still love & worship Karna like me?Are we lack judgement?

Lakshagriha Incident, he opposed the decision, but he remained slient for the sake of his friendship with Duryodhan.According to Karna, Duryodhan gave him his due respect, he extended his hand of friendship despite his low caste.So, its his "Dharma"to protect Duryodhan.As Duryodhan made him the king of Anga, its his duty to remain a loyal political comrade of Duryodhan.I always feel Karna's condition was more like modern days honest IAS Officers, who want to remain honest, but failed because of their duty & about Abhimanyu's killing, he listened to the Commander of the Army.It hurted the real warrior inside him, but still he did his duty which he think is right.

Dyut Sabha incident.Karna insulted Draupadi.He instigated the situation.Its the reason for downfall of Karna.Draupadi rejected Karna.He should respect her feelings.But No,typical male ego,unable to accept rejection from a woman.Yes, he felt insulted infront of all kings because Draupadi rejected him only because of his low caste.But cant he forgive Draupadi?? How he sliently watched the shameful act of Dushasan?Only to prove his loyality towards Duryodhan?? No No, he did this to satisfy his male ego which was hurt due to Draupadi's rejection.Everyone was villain including the five pandavas in the Dyut-sabha.But again I wonder, how can he forgive anyone?? Did he get forgiveness from anyone??But, he was wrong that day.No one can defend him, not even Karna I think.

Karna always have a passion for Archery, but due to the social system, he always faced rejection.Not because he lacked skill, but for his low caste. How a suta can learn Archery??After facing rejection & insults, he told lie to Guru Parshuram that he is a Brahmin.He always respected his Guru, worked hard & achieved.But his Guru gave him curse, Why?? Because he tolarated pain so that his Guru can rest.After watching his Kavach & Kundal, Cant Lord Parshuram understand that he is not a ordinary person, but a person with divine touch & Lord Parshuram was the Guru of Bhisma who was not a Brahmin.But Karna accepted his Guru's curse as blessing.He moved on in his life & tried to achieve his dream.

He donated his immortality, his Kavach Kundal to Lord Indra.It need a lot of courage.I respect his confidence.He also gave daan to Kunti, thelives of her four sons.He was unable to send her empty-handed for whom he had to suffer all humilation, who reduced his status.He rejected Lord Krishna's offer without any second thought.Proud Karna, loyal Karna.

I love Karna, they way he struggled, fought & achieved his dream, his passion.He wrote his own destiny by his hard work.He accepted curse from his Guru & moved on in his life. I love his power of acceptance.His loyalty & friendship towards Duryodhan & most importantly his Daanveerta.He is a man full of pride, but for me, his pride is his way of self-respect.For me, Karna is a trendsetter,Couragious & As radiant as sun.People will always remember him.Some will hate him & some will love & worship him & I will always remain in that second category.

Created

Last reply

Replies

37

Views

5.9k

Users

17

Likes

91

Frequent Posters

Ramya_98 thumbnail
Book Talk Reading Challenge Award - Pro Thumbnail 10th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
A very nice and thought provoking post indeed! Well, i respect your opinions and views but i still want to say a few things here.
Firstly, talking about dyut sabha. First thing that draupadi insulted karna in her swayamwara where she had every right to chose her groom.So, she had the right to reject karna but her way was insulting and humiliating.Agreed karna was hurt and he could have forgiven her but what affects me more is that karna's insult in the swayamwara was nothing against draupadi being disrobed and gravely insulted in public.And being a righteous man he should have spoken up against it. And i am making a special mention of vikarna here because while everyone stood helpless ,he was the only one with the guts to speak up.
Secondly, donating the kavach and kundalas needed a lot of courage, no doubt.But that was one of his punishments for all the wrongs he did in his life, and supporting duryodhana. I do not say supporting duryodhana was not right on his part, because duryodhana was the only true friend he always had by his side when he had no one else. His conscience knew he was doing wrong but yet he continued doing what his heart wanted. In fact, i wrote all this in a little more detail in my karn-arjun TS too.
Thirdly, about the guru's curse. Well, there are different versions to this story but from what i have heard and read, karna told parashurama, he was a soota, which he was by his actons but not by his birth. Do correct me if i am wrong because i am not sure of this.
Just some of my opinions i shared and they are not meant to offend anyone.
However, i will always remain an admirer of arjun, more than that of karn.
Samsangeetha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sania_58

For the First time, I am writing something on Karna.Please forgive me for any mistake.Its completely my point of view & most importantly I am not a scholar.So, with my limited knowledge, a small write up on Karna.

If anyone ask me Who is your favourite character in Mahabharata, then without any doubt, my answer will be Karna.
Sometimes, I wonder, Why it is??He knew the conspiracy of Laksagriha.He was a part of Dyut Sabha. He also took part in the murder of Abhimanyu.
Answer is very simple. Karna is a common human being & No one is Perfect.But the allegations against him are serious,
Then why some people still love & worship Karna like me?Are we lack judgement?

Lakshagriha Incident, he opposed the decision, but he remained slient for the sake of his friendship with Duryodhan.According to Karna, Duryodhan gave him his due respect, he extended his hand of friendship despite his low caste.So, its his "Dharma"to protect Duryodhan.As Duryodhan made him the king of Anga, its his duty to remain a loyal political comrade of Duryodhan.I always feel Karna's condition was more like modern days honest IAS Officers, who want to remain honest, but failed because of their duty & about Abhimanyu's killing, he listened to the Commander of the Army.It hurted the real warrior inside him, but still he did his duty which he think is right.

Dyut Sabha incident.Karna insulted Draupadi.He instigated the situation.Its the reason for downfall of Karna.Draupadi rejected Karna.He should respect her feelings.But No,typical male ego,unable to accept rejection from a woman.Yes, he felt insulted infront of all kings because Draupadi rejected him only because of his low caste.But cant he forgive Draupadi?? How he sliently watched the shameful act of Dushasan?Only to prove his loyality towards Duryodhan?? No No, he did this to satisfy his male ego which was hurt due to Draupadi's rejection.Everyone was villain including the five pandavas in the Dyut-sabha.But again I wonder, how can he forgive anyone?? Did he get forgiveness from anyone??But, he was wrong that day.No one can defend him, not even Karna I think.

Karna always have a passion for Archery, but due to the social system, he always faced rejection.Not because he lacked skill, but for his low caste. How a suta can learn Archery??After facing rejection & insults, he told lie to Guru Parshuram that he is a Brahmin.He always respected his Guru, worked hard & achieved.But his Guru gave him curse, Why?? Because he tolarated pain so that his Guru can rest.After watching his Kavach & Kundal, Cant Lord Parshuram understand that he is not a ordinary person, but a person with divine touch & Lord Parshuram was the Guru of Bhisma who was not a Brahmin.But Karna accepted his Guru's curse as blessing.He moved on in his life & tried to achieve his dream.

He donated his immortality, his Kavach Kundal to Lord Indra.It need a lot of courage.I respect his confidence.He also gave daan to Kunti, thelives of her four sons.He was unable to send her empty-handed for whom he had to suffer all humilation, who reduced his status.He rejected Lord Krishna's offer without any second thought.Proud Karna, loyal Karna.

I love Karna, they way he struggled, fought & achieved his dream, his passion.He wrote his own destiny by his hard work.He accepted curse from his Guru & moved on in his life. I love his power of acceptance.His loyalty & friendship towards Duryodhan & most importantly his Daanveerta.He is a man full of pride, but for me, his pride is his way of self-respect.For me, Karna is a trendsetter,Couragious & As radiant as sun.People will always remember him.Some will hate him & some will love & worship him & I will always remain in that second category.



Good analysis 👏
...Hemangi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
RES
UNRES

Madhu ignore this post. I reserved it b4 reading😆. I already read and commented it in Karna AT
Edited by ...Hemangi - 9 years ago
Nonie12345 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Fantastic post on Karna Sania😃
newmoon18 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Omg yr u rocked it
I really liked this post
Mind blowing

The way u portrayed everything is superb
sania_58 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: ramya06

A very nice and thought provoking post indeed! Well, i respect your opinions and views but i still want to say a few things here.
Firstly, talking about dyut sabha. First thing that draupadi insulted karna in her swayamwara where she had every right to chose her groom.So, she had the right to reject karna but her way was insulting and humiliating.Agreed karna was hurt and he could have forgiven her but what affects me more is that karna's insult in the swayamwara was nothing against draupadi being disrobed and gravely insulted in public.And being a righteous man he should have spoken up against it. And i am making a special mention of vikarna here because while everyone stood helpless ,he was the only one with the guts to speak up.
Secondly, donating the kavach and kundalas needed a lot of courage, no doubt.But that was one of his punishments for all the wrongs he did in his life, and supporting duryodhana. I do not say supporting duryodhana was not right on his part, because duryodhana was the only true friend he always had by his side when he had no one else. His conscience knew he was doing wrong but yet he continued doing what his heart wanted. In fact, i wrote all this in a little more detail in my karn-arjun TS too.
Thirdly, about the guru's curse. Well, there are different versions to this story but from what i have heard and read, karna told parashurama, he was a soota, which he was by his actons but not by his birth. Do correct me if i am wrong because i am not sure of this.
Just some of my opinions i shared and they are not meant to offend anyone.
However, i will always remain an admirer of arjun, more than that of karn.



First of all, Thanks Ramya.😃
Draupadi's rejection hurted Karna's male ego more than Karna.
I personally believe, he insulted Draupadi to satisfy that hurt ego, not to satisfy Duryodhan.
At that point of time, he lost all his good qualities, & became a sadistic man who want to satisfy his ego, which lead towards the path of his own destruction.
Vikarna haas that guts, I salute this, but Karna failed & I didnot defend Karna in that Dyut Sabha incident, because I know Its not possible to justify him with any logic.It the darkest part of Mahabharata.
Kavach Kundal daan is the prove of his Danveer nature.
If Karna dont give his Kavach in daan, I dont think then it will be possible for anyone to kill him, its the boon exclusively by his father SuryaDev.Karna himself cut it.He knew its Indra infront of him disguise of Brahmin.But still he did.
Karna knew he was on wrong side.He did not lacked judgement, its just he dont want to betray his best friend.
& about Guru's curse, I never supported it.
If Guru Parshuram unable to understand Karna's caste when both remained together for years, for me the caste issue is a baseless point.His Guru did wrong to Karna. Its my belief.
Thanks for sharing your opinions.Respect your opinions. But still shared some of my thoughts.
& my case is different,I will always remain an admirer of Karna, more than that of Arjun.

amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Well written...
Though I am not a scholar, with my limited knowledge on the epic, this is precisely how I want Karna to be seen by his admirers...No pretence...no baseless justifications...yet acceptance of his flaws...n appreciation of his greatness...
sania_58 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: amritat

Well written...
Though I am not a scholar, with my limited knowledge on the epic, this is precisely how I want Karna to be seen by his admirers...No pretence...no baseless justifications...yet acceptance of his flaws...n appreciation of his greatness...



Thanks Amrita.
I have no idea how to justify Karna in the Dyut-Sabha when at that time he became one of the most selfish & sadistic person.
But still, I love him, & will love him forever.😊

& I love your face off OS on Karna-Draupadi.Superb.👏
PriyaKABHI thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Thanks for PM,Dear.😊
It was so Happy to write on Karna.😊
It is My favorite Character in Mahabharata.😊
It was Awesome.😊
The way You explained about Karna was Amazingly,I loves it.😊
Please write like this.😊
__________________________________
(MISSING KSG and KABHI So Much)
PriyaCherry.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".