west-benefit of doubt maybe ???? - Page 2

No, actually in of the rounds naveen sang only 2 lines and was given full marks where as there was more to the mukhda.. maybe they were lienient to all teams and were strict only in last round where even one word mistake was not allowed and naveen had done one word mistake there..
I cant remember the song but i was surprised when he didnt sing full mukhda and so I thought rules might be changed.
And in ladki hai kahan anyone could say he made a mistake of lot of lines..
If I am not wrong the o re kanchi which u r saying was in the same round as teh one i am sayign where naveen didnt sing full mukhda so I guess the rules of that round were as such..

Originally posted by: mini4frienz

No, actually in of the rounds naveen sang only 2 lines and was given full marks where as there was more to the mukhda.. maybe they were lienient to all teams and were strict only in last round where even one word mistake was not allowed and naveen had done one word mistake there..
I cant remember the song but i was surprised when he didnt sing full mukhda and so I thought rules might be changed.
And in ladki hai kahan anyone could say he made a mistake of lot of lines..
If I am not wrong the o re kanchi which u r saying was in the same round as teh one i am sayign where naveen didnt sing full mukhda so I guess the rules of that round were as such..

first of all,i must say I was surprised to see this post today morning.I made this post quite some time back and didn't expect it back!!

Yeah,u r right.....the last round probably didn't require singing of the chorus.I just noticed that the song'Ek main hoon' also had a chorus part after the mukhda.Maybe the round just didn' require ppl to sing it.After all, almost every song sung in that round had a chorus part 'London dekha', Jiya jale....the list is endless and no one sang the chorus part...So it was ok,i guess.

In ladki hai kahan navin made a mistake of exactly 4 words,not a lot of lines but 4 words.If u want I can write down the exact lyrics and the mistakes he made...I have a pretty good memory!! or u cld crosscheck.And yes,he deserved to get minus points for those 4 words,definitely.I'm not faulting the reserach team for getting his mistakes.I'm only saying the research team never bothered about others' mistakes.they only noticed navin's mistakes.In various posts in this column I have pointed pout at least 3 mistakes ignored by the research team... al in the QF and one in the finals.Hrithika has pointed one out too in the QF.All theses decisions favoured east/west. I was only wondering how it is that the research team ignores all other mistakes and only catches navin's mistakes.... it semed odd that major mistakes were ignored by them ard 4 times......

From last season's play I got a feeling that decisions were being given favourably to west.Last season too west got a clear benefit of doubt in the finals...helping them win.This season the score mishap in favour of the west was the last straw for me.I cldn't believe that such a mistake had been committed in the finals and moreover, no one had pointed it out ..Made me wonder ..., if the mistake had been comitted in favour of anyone else,wldn't someone have caught it????or wld the mistake have been committed to favour someone else in the first place?........ we'll never know😊