Farah judgement abt indian idol - Page 4

Ok its true that SRGMP contestants are much better than MOST of the II conterstans so far. But that is not the singers fault, its the judges fault because they are not finding good people or the problem is they just don't want to look and find a good singer, they just wanna do it for the heck of it. Its not like all SRGMP judges just sat there and magical singers appeared... the hardest part i think for the judges are pickking the contestans for the try out rounds because EVERTHING DEPENDS ON THEM, weaher they get good singers or NOT.....................they should only pick singers who ar already good at singing not ppl who they think can improve but at that moment they are not good. thats all.

Originally posted by: biswita

I think Amit Paul's voice quality beats the whole of the C07 gang put together. I could listen toAmit forever, I have never felt that way in C07.Note I am talking about voice quality. I know ppl like Amanat Aneek are technically better singers, so pl don't jump on me.

i 100% agree with u...i am also thinking what she would hv said parshant in she was also judge in indial idol3..b'cos she was always looking for x factor..here parshant got nothing no x factor no even singing

Originally posted by: MONICA0819

i 100% agree with u...i am also thinking what she would hv said parshant in she was also judge in indial idol3..b'cos she was always looking for x factor..here parshant got nothing no x factor no even singing

I agree with everything EXCEPT for one thing. u said prashant has not x-factor...well thats not true..i think he is really cute...thats my opinion. He has X-Factor and Voice Quality its so relaxing, and i could listen to him all day long.

what ppl don't realise or admit is that Amit caused a large section of viewers/voters to move to II3 even though C07 had better trained singers.

II 3 finalists got way more votes from India than C07.

ok who cares bout II3, no1 really sang dat great xcept 4 emon.........

and if ur sayin dat da II3 contestants were better dan de srgmp contestants then ur seriously mental.

cuz all of the saregama contestants are really good......wayy better then da indian idol contestants.

i agree with her also !!
in the history of indian idol we cannot find one singer we can compare him with SRGMP contestants (top6)
because SRGMP contestants always sing better than the original !!
but II singers want a fame only !!