-Gan- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
No I haven't watched the episode ... But based on what I read it seems like he gave her a mouth to mout resuscitation because she had stopped breathing ... It's a different issue that how come Shagun's body temperature dropped faster than Raman's that she stopped breathing even though he was hugging her to keep her warm...
Raman was not wrong there ... His intention was just to save Shagun ... More of a humane reaction more than anything . Yeah Ashok's omnipresent 'eyes' were capturing everything to create future misunderstanding that is a different issue.

It was a stupid forced scene the cvs manufactured to create Ishra MU. Nothing else..

The invisible arm of the ishita Raman shagun triangle just got created .

Like yhm has been these days.. All the tracks revolve around to give prominence to Shagun's character.. To justify her presence in the story. This is no exception .

Raman Ishita mohabbatien track that the viewers have been demanding and waiting for more than one and half years? Ah well like every thing else, it is in the back burner.. Everything has to wait .. As its hail the other 'mohabbatein' time .
Edited by -Gan- - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

74

Views

8.1k

Users

37

Likes

232

Frequent Posters

shivangi838 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
thanks Gan for this post , most of the world will believe raman did all that intentionally , glad that u said something which showed he was nt intentionally straying ishita😭
mayasun thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Hi Gan,
Sorry for unres the post late but I just watched the episode.

I may be on the minority side but I didn't feel anything bad with the episode or the track in itself because I want this track to explore Ishita emotions and vulnerablities they have paved way nicely to explore her vulnerability but hope they execute the track beautifully instead of killing the track by same cliched scenes.

Ishita is at a vulnerable state even though she has not shed a tear for the unborn baby she is hurt inside on top it of Raman is not taking into account her feelings about a 3rd woman being the mother of their child she is already hurt with it because Raman who makes her the center of his world could not see her hurt and she is already feeling guilty she is not able to give the one thing Ruhi and Raman wants a child.

In the olden days Ishita had no fear of Shagun because she knew she was trouble and Raman would not go behind her but there were glimpses now when she found out that the Shaugun whom Raman fell in love is back and IshRa equation also has changed so she is more vulnerable at this stage so there is a possibility that all her fears might come true that Raman would leave her because she is not able to give him a child even though in her heart she knew that is not possible but her mind would be pulling her towards that possibility so I guess this would be the reversal of the Mani track

The other possibility is CV can surprise us with Ishita unbreakable trust on Raman. During the accident track she lost trust in Raman even though she did not have any clear proof based on a some scene she saw but here with clear proof from Ashok too she might surprise everyone and show her unbreakable trust

I hope whichever way they choose they execute it properly and not turn into a comedy circus

Coming to today episode.

The first thing it strikes me was when Shagun said we are going to die he said you die but I have a family to take care off and immediately said sorry to hear but even in that dire situation he was thinking about his family.

Shagun has always been shown superficial so she succumbing to cold first was not unbelievable on top of it she was wearing a thin dress so Raman tried giving her his coat first , then rubbing her hands to keep her warm, then tried talking to her about kids so that she engages in conversation and not faint but when that didn't work tried giving her body heat and finally gave her CPR once she fainted so I would not blame Raman for what he did today but I am hoping he would not hide this from Ishita coming Monday when he sees her this is the first thing I want him to tell her if he hides from her that is when I am going to get mad with the character as well as the CV for butchering the character.

Rinki is making some mistake at least this time around she was polite to Ishita instant of shouting and at least answered back to her instead of taking every insult silently.

I was laughing like anything when Suraj said we are not murders we are business men so what was he when he was planning to kill those incident kids during Aug15 and trying to kill Raman when he sent the goons to attack him during Ashok arrest.

I am hoping there is no misunderstanding between Shanoj because of this stupid CD. I for one rooting for that pair to prosper so that they finally leave IshRa in peace😆

I guess the color code dress is going to play a vital role in Ishita kidnapping as the killer is going to kidnap a different person😉

Suraj got it right when he said you don't know Ishita she has immense trust on Raman once he explains she will believe him and Ashok was also right in stating that she will MU Raman first because however innocent no one would like their spouse to be in close physical proximity to other person.

Finally Raman has so much trust on Ishita that she will understand him so he didn't even stop to think that if Ishita saw him in this position she would MU him.

Edited by mayasundar - 10 years ago
-K.13- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
While reading the LU...I couldn't find major fault with Raman.
  • He helped Shagun when he hated her (riots, Ashok's creepy partner, etc)
  • When trapped with no knowledge of if he will be saved, he talked about Ishita, Ruhi, & Adi
----
I've read a lot on IF over time about Raman & Ishita, and if they deserve each other.

For Raman: I've seen so many comments asking what kind of husband Raman is or how he is like Subbu.

Among many things...He put Adi before her. He kept secrets from her frequently. He suspected his wife of cheating. He almost raped his wife. He tried to leave her. He taunted her for being ishima. He kicked her out of his house. He let her suffer when Shagun lived with them. He let people accuse her at Rinki's wedding. He ignored her feelings & kept pushing pregnancy on her. He was rude & publicly insulted her at a party. He considered surrogacy. He agreed to surrogacy behind her back. He did not take into consideration her feelings.

Sounds really bad, no?

And to make it seem worse what hasn't Ishita done for him?

She never let him fall in Ruhi's eyes even at his worse. She kept his respect during the accident track. She kept him from sacrificing his position. She brought him back from being a coward & running away. She dealt with her Sautan so Adi could come back to him. She comforted him during the earthquake track. She silently coped with his anger. She fulfilled the ministry contract for him. She risked her life many times for him or the family. She can't come to terms with her lost child due to his fragility.

It is easy to see why Raman is with Ishita, but I can't stop myself from asking, why is Ishita still with him? Is it because she can't part with Ruhi or Adi? Is it because she is majboor in his love?

Well here's my answer -

Time and time we see how Raman loves her beyond depth. Raman cannot live without her, but sometimes his good intentions don't justify his actions.

Ishita just wanted to be needed. That's why we always see her as a jagat mata people pleaser, and tracks like the earthquake track & miscarriage track - you see just how much Raman needs her. This week's rain scene was beyond moving b/c you saw just how much Ishita has consumed Raman.

Ishita was rejected brutally by her first love & then other men that followed. She was tossed aside as being "unuseful" because she could not conceive. Then comes this cold man that she tolerated for the sake of a daughter, but slowly the cold man melts away & begins to depend on her...he makes her the center of his world, something no man has given her before.

[in terms of storytelling - the discrepancy in their relationship wouldn't be so bad if FL were allowed to make more actual mistakes]


----
This is the time of year the Mani track was started (ironic, no?). As I wrote in the LU...

Mani track: Their relationship was weaker & Raman's more emotional & more insecure about love & women. So a hug & ILU from Ishita was enough. Ishita wasn't wrong here & Raman couldn't verbalize his hurt to her. The vehicle for drama was Sarika-Romi.

This track: Their relationship is rock solid & Ishita is less emotional and has stronger faith. So to make this track happen, something more sinister was needed. Raman isn't wrong here & for the sake of drama, I'm sure she will bottle up for a little. The vehicle for drama appears to be Mihir-Rinki-Mihika. Only thing we don't know is how surrogacy will fit into this.

[[so yes, Raman is likely going to do more things that will infuriate viewers in this track, but they will not be from a vicious place]]
---

Woof - I haven't written this much about YHM in a while! Even though the CVs suck & just want TRPs...I somehow found an ounce of my long lost mojo this week! 😳
Edited by -K.13- - 10 years ago
-Atii- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
R

Un-R

Raman only did what any human would've done. If it was Ashok instead of Shagun, he would've given him CPR too. Why? Because he is a good human being. One of the reasons why Ishita loves him.

During the Mani-Ishita fiasco, Ishita's musings to Mani was enough to crack Raman...but now...that their feelings are so deep and intense for each other, it had to be more. So CVs went with physical interaction.

Honestly, I feel bad for Raman, not only was he stuck in the cold storage with Shagun, not only did he lose his child, not only is Ishita being the strong one after the loss, but now he has to search for his kidnapped wife? Not knowing if she is hurt, if she is dead or alive.

Idk if Ishita will misunderstand or what..I don't know if Ashok will show the video, and deliberately put salt into the wound, but I think this was done solely for her to misunderstand Raman...or to glorify Jagat Behenji.


After the rain scene, it was so intense and the things Biwi was saying to Puttar, I knew something equally as disgusting and repulsive was gonna happen. In CVs mission to increase their TRPs, they stooped so low and took a cheap shot. I hope their trps fall even further. People don't watch YHM for drama, they watch it for it's realistic nature and maturity, which it initially had. People watch SNS and such shows for drama. Hope CVs will get this into their thick heads.


Whatever happens tho...Puttar cannot be blamed for his act today...and hopefully Biwi loves him enough to know that..even if she doubts him at first, eventually she will learn the truth and trust him again.And in no way can Puttar's love for Biwi be in doubt. Even when stuck in the storage, he talked about Biwi. Such is their love. ❤️ But it also kinda depends on whether he spills the beans to Biwi or hides it.

#PuttWi is love. ❤️

Edited by -Atii- - 10 years ago
-Gan- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Thanks Ati for the LU 🤗
-Atii- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: -Gan-


Thanks Ati for the LU 🤗


Your welcome! 🤗
SA1234 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Well said Gan..IshRa mohabbatein..that's the only reason we have stuck to this show..
We know it!
They(CVs) know it!
We know that they know it!
They know that we know that they know!

In shot they know how to play us!

PS : we don't need cold storage scene collages!
--QUEEN-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

IshRa's Icons

Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Of course raman would do this...
For few minutes let's forget this is a show
Let's assume there aroused a situation like this
What should have happened?


AK_2010 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Completely agreeing wid u Gan!! For God's Sake..! It's has been done to save a life..! Just bcz Shagun is Raman's ex, it doesn't mean he will let her die... And plus this is a show.. Not a real life story... It's all done for the sake of gaining TRP!!! So ppl shud stop criticizing RKB's character...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".