Vishal is sooo rude!!!

I think vishal is damn rude...he didnt bother commenting on aneek at all during d ghazal episode...but he commented on every other contestant

isnt he showing tt he is not fond of himesh?? even tho der was a huge drama over raja btwn vishal n HR...bt HR still praised raja ...coz HR always speaks wat he truly feels...when raja performs badly, means he did...n when he does well, HR never fails to praise him...

Vishal on the other hand purposely said tt aneek dint perform well jus to hit back at himesh..and now he didnt even comment on aneek~!!!

how rude!!!😕

i dont think so, u can talk gr8 abt HR all u want but dont defame the others! vishaal-shekhar in my opinion r the best n the fairest judges! they r awesome!

Definitely, they are the least biased. They were the best thing that happened to SRGMP, in my opinion. And I don't think Vishal said Aneek didn't perform well spitefully, he is a music director, I think he is capable of forming his own opinion on a contestant's performance. When a contenstant sings well, VS never fail to praise them whole-heartedly. When their performances are not up to scratch, they tell then honestly.

They stoop up for every contestants good performances yesterday....which included Poonams, Amanat and Raja...
That certainly does not make them rude or biased.
They are the most mature judges on the show.....

Originally posted by: crazyfan

i dont think so, u can talk gr8 abt HR all u want but dont defame the others! vishaal-shekhar in my opinion r the best n the fairest judges! they r awesome!

when every1 defames HR on the forum, thats okay rite? and btw, the moderator herself had said criticizing the contestants and mentors are allowed on the forum...so i am just abiding by the rules! 😊

if der can be soo many topics created on HR...den why not vishal?

and anyways my point here is tt vishal was rude n did not comment on aneek during d ghazal episode...dunt u guys think tt was sooo rude of him? 😕

Originally posted by: divya_p

Definitely, they are the least biased. They were the best thing that happened to SRGMP, in my opinion. And I don't think Vishal said Aneek didn't perform well spitefully, he is a music director, I think he is capable of forming his own opinion on a contestant's performance. When a contenstant sings well, VS never fail to praise them whole-heartedly. When their performances are not up to scratch, they tell then honestly.

tts wat HR does as well...

but why didnt vishal comment on aneek dis time? HR said such nice things abt raja..cudnt he pick up his mike and say a line or 2 as well? but no, he made shekar do all the talking...like as if he didnt even listen to aneek's song...😕

Only ID is the greatest JUDGE out of all 4. 👏

AND yes i do think vishal didnt praise Aneek yesterday at all..even though shekhar did. plus HR is outspoken person but he always says raja is a good singer. after dat huge argument, vishal had started ignoring aneek 😕

i think hr is rude not vishal koi to chahiye hr ko chup karane wala

Geez!!!

As a matter of fact,it was Himesh who was brimming with jealousy and insecurity in today's episode...When Raja rendered Dard-E-Disco magnificently,Himesh accused VS of choosing the best song for Raja and for being "partial"....

When Amanat sang "Mitwa" ever so soulfully,Himesh praises him and adds as an afterthought that even Aneek would perform well..Why drag in Aneek while critiquing others' performances??...

Vishal SHekhar are the most objective judges...They support music,and do not get involved in the petty politics Himesh often embroils himself and his protege in!!

All you guys who say VS are the most carefree and fairest judges are 100% correct,there is no doubt!!!!!!!!!

However I do agree with aastha tt it was rude of vishal not to comment on aneek!!HE is a judge and should give his comments,be it good or bad!!It was wrong to ostracise one person's performance.